Preston’s Steak House

To say that Prestons is outstanding would be an understatement! 10 of us dined on Friday the 18^th to celebrate my birthday. From start to finish everything was perfect! Our waiter, Michael did an amazing job. We’ve had him before and he feels like an old family friend. We shared several starters and entrees including the rib eye, filet, grilled shrimp and salmon. Everyone on our party was more than pleased! The owner himself visited our table more than once to make certain we were happy. As a special surprise, his wife made an entire coconut cake just for my birthday! How special is that. Prestons is one of a kind and a true gem. Worth every penny. Thanks for making my birthday so memorable!

Felt like I was dining at a «members only» restaurant. Small and intimate, service is exceptional. I would say the steak was one of the best I’ve had. Mind you, it will look like a slab of chocolate cake when it’s being delivered to your table… nothing wrong with that (Speaking of cake-​amazing coconut cake!) The sides are all old school steakhouse. It’s a very special place.

Love love love Preston’s! Coconut cake and Buggs! If you don’t know what Buggs are you NEED to find out!

Went to Prestons after hearing it was the best steak house in Naples! My husband, who is a beef connoisseur, ordered the riib eye, when it arrived it was a bone in strip and shy of the ounces that was stated on the menu. My husband questioned the waiter, Matthew, about the cut of meat and he told him it was definitely the rib eye. My husband didn’t argue with him but went ahead and ate the steak which he said was just average in taste and a little tough. My friend and I ordered the fillets which were very tasty. The «bugs» appetizer that we ordered was excellent.
Will we go back? Probably not!

Absolutely the best steak I’ve ever had. Very quaint and service was top notch. Very good wine list to compliment every meal and homemade desserts.

The best steak I’ve ever had. The food was delicious. Great service. Cozy atmosphere.

Prestons is the kind of place you go to for special occasions. It’s family owned and operated and one of the best steak places anywhere. Service is very good and the atmosphere is cozy. We went there with good friends who were visiting for the holidays. There were six of us and two of the women decided to share one steak. Everyone else had their own entrée and we also had salads, two bottles of wine, sides, and dessert. The bill came to about $ 475 before tip and we were surprised to see a charge for $ 10 for a sharing charge for the girl’s one entrée. When we complained to the waiter he asked the owner to come out of the kitchen. He bluntly told us that’s the way it is and «every» restaurant in Naples has such an up charge. He didn’t handle it well. For $ 10 he lost a customer, but he doesn’t seem to care.