Boneyard Pub & Grille

It was my first experience here about a month ago and I am looking to go back. I absolutely love the place especially the deep fried cookie dough in a wonton wrapping

Mediocre food and service. Nothing special but not bad for the price. Only reason I continue to go it the family atmosphere and they support local groups /​schools.

The food is alright but somehow when we go the waitstaff leaves something to be desired. My example is from when I ordered wings. When asked what kind of sauce I wanted I responded «just the plain hot sauce» when they came out they had NO sauce on the wings. I can understand that mistake, and is not what the two star rating is from
My wife went last week with our daughter for a special mommy and me day. I copied the email she sent to the boneyard that we still haven’t seen a response to yet
Recently I visited Boneyard in Mukwonago, WI on 10÷5÷2015 from 6 until 7ish PM. When we arrived the hostess greeted us and took us to our table and was extremely nice! Our first waiter was very fast at getting us our drinks and allowing us (my daughter and myself) to look over the menu and decide what we wanted. We ordered our food our cheese curds came out in a timely manner along with our meals and that’s where things started to go south. My daughter had to use the rest room I couldn’t find our waiter to tell her she just needed a potty break so I left my bright pink phone (pink cover showing), keys, and purse at the table to make sure she didn’t think we skipped out. My daughter is almost 5 and a «quick» potty break is about 10min. as we are walking back to our table a different waiter was cleaning up our meals. We literally took like 5 bites maybe and with all my stuff on the top of the table near our dinner I thought that would’ve been enough to not have that happen I was VERY wrong apparently. She then asked us if we were finished?! I told her no we only had a few bites and were not she apologized for throwing things in baskets and just ran away didn’t offer a plate to put the now jumbled food onto or to pick the straw wrappers and such out of our food. After I got our meals separated I tried to shrug it off. A few min. later my daughter had an empty drink once again our first waiter was no where to be found. So I asked the waiter who tossed our meals together for another sprite. after a few min. of her talking to other people and waiters and so forth she must have forgotten this simple request. Now I no longer can ignore the poor treatment we have received. Our waiter appeared out of no where and asked if there was anything else I told her no I just want to get out of the restaurant. She then stated that she saw we were annoyed and was sorry that the other waiter had cleaned up our meals. This is what blows my mind. She saw what was happening but yet no one tried to make the situation better?! Really?! I’ll be honest I didn’t leave a tip to be told from the waiter yes we saw your bad service and just ignored it just blew my mind. I truly hope your wait staff can improve from this letter this is not how to treat people

A favorite lunchtime stop whenever we’re in town to visit the Elegant Farmer.
Suggestions: the pizza panini (so amazing — get it with mushrooms and sausage) or the ribs (which are probably the second best in Wisconsin?). The bloody Marys are also great!

Waitress «C» took order 58 minutes later received food. Food was OK. During meal never seen waitress again till we were finished and then was only to give us bill. Never once asked how food was or if we needed anything.

Horribly dirty and musty smelling. Silverware was wrapped in napkin and filthy! The menu was so dirty my fingers stuck to it, disgusting! If the front is that bad I can’t imagine what the kitchen looks like. Food took way too long.
The manager was dismissive, arrogant, and condescending but it doesn’t pay to escalate to owner because it’s his brother.
NEVER EVER GO HERE!

My mom and I went here last night normally the food is good. But last night the food was the worst I’ve ever had. I had the fish fry it was so over done it was crispy I thought I broke a tooth. My mom ordered a wrap with turkey and avocado but there was no avocado when the waiters finally came to check on us ie bring us the bill we told her and she said there is a new cook in the kitchen. The waitress we had took our order and that was about all she did. She never once stopped to see how our food was or if we needed anything. She did however offer to buy the table next us around of drinks Wtf? Will I go back probably not if I can help it! The only way to get good service here is if you are a regular!!! And if I could give this place zero stars I WOULD.

Lots and lots of menu choices, with some very interesting and delicious appetizers. We tried the mozzarella sticks, the buffalo chicken bites and the pretzel sticks. The mozzarella sticks were a unique twist, with what appeared to be a full stick of string cheese deep-​fried in a wonton wrapper. The buffalos chicken bites were absolutely amazing. I dropped half of mine on my pants, which was disappointing because they were so enjoyable.
Definitely very easy to overeat at the Boneyard. For four meals and an appetizer sampler, our bill came out to around $ 60. We left full and happy.

Have been here a few times. They always provided good service and the food is tasty. They offer several sauce options for their ribs and wings and their potato roll is really good.

Good food, good service, fair prices. I had a house Salad that was crisp and fresh even on sunday no less. The ribs are fall off the bone and honestly were better without all the sauce on top. Definitely will be going back.

My girlfriend suggested this place as she said the wings are good. Im not a wing fan, but was craving prime rib (being a Saturday in wisconsin). We also ordered several appetizers including reuben rolls (really good, but could use more corned beef), some cheese nugget things with guoda, also very good and another one that wasn’t my cup of tea but my girlfriend liked.
Service was ok and almost too good as we got our appetizers and then as we were starting them our main course came. Was a little peeved by this as something was going to end up cold as a result (this was the case). The prime rib was disappointing as I was nervous when it came out and had an orange hue to the top of it. My first bite was rubbery (my napkin enjoyed it as thats where it ended up) and it didn’t get any better from there.
I will not normally say something when I get poor food as this was how I was raised, but I felt for the price they were charging ($ 19.99 for 12 oz) I should be getting a tasty piece of meat. When I stated my displeasure a manager came out and asked about and offered to replace it (which due to being relatively full from the appetizers and soup that was really good-​potato and bacon), but I declined.
My girlfriend enjoyed her boneless wings. Ive had worse dinning experiences and I respect them for owning up to subpar food along with trying to make good on it. I may return if im in the area again, but wouldnt go out of my way.

In one word, TERRIBLE.
I’ve seen friends check in at this location on Facebook and thought it was worth a try, So on my way to Milwaukee i decided to stop. The parking lot was very full which i thought would be a good sign. After walking in the place felt a lot like a buffalo wild wings another pretty good sign. We stood in line for a table behind an elderly couple who asked for a booth, i see the server take them too the booth, then i saw the couple move to a table. We were then brought to the same booth we sat down and the HVAC vent was blowing down directly on us and either the heat was either off, or turned way down cause it was blowing cold air down, The air was blowing hard enough to make my fiancé’s long hair move, and to have the napkins fly off the table later on in the meal. We decided to just stay since the only open table i saw was right in front of the door.
A few minutes later our server comes to the table and gets our drink order, pretty typical she comes back a few minutes later with our drinks. She then takes our order, and since it is Thursday the Boneyard has a $.75 boneless wing special i decided to get that. They have a 4 wing minimum for each sauce, so i got 12 wings, 4 in Garlic Buffalo, 4 in Mild Buffalo, and 4 in Boneyard BBQ. as well as an order of french fries. My fiancé got the Cajun pasta as well as an order of Mozzarella sticks, which she made mention as an appetizer. about 35 – 40 minutes pass and still no sign of our Mozz sticks, or the waitress. or any of our food. a few minutes later our food comes out, missing the Mozz sticks. The waitress said she will go find out about them. and she leaves… we look down and notice we didn’t get silverware, Which is pretty essential for boneless wings and pasta. She comes back about a minute later and says she forgot to put the sticks in, and did we still want them? We said yes please and we need silverware she said ok and went to get them. I look over and she is talking to another table. She finally comes back a few minutes later with the silverware, It’s been 5 minutes since the food was brought out, and remember the cold air blowing on us? That didn’t help the food at all. The «Boneless Wings» Are not wings at all, more of a boneless, skinless chicken breast cut into strips and sauced. Speaking of sauces the Garlic Buffalo wings were ok at best, but not very good, i did manage to eat all 4, i then went to the Mild Buffalo which was quite bland but didn’t taste good, so i only had 1.5 wings, The fact they were cold by this time might have had an effect on the flavor? By now our mozz sticks were just coming out, and actually those were quite good, but the dipping sauce lacked severely. Our waitress then came back and i asked for a refill of the soda’s which took a few minutes to receive. I then went to try the Boneyard BBQ wings which i had high hopes but low expectations for the but they were surprisingly decent albeit cold so i only had a couple of those, and finished the mozz sticks. My fiancé did say that the Cajun pasta was quite good as was the bread stick. A little while later the waitress came back and we asked for the check and a box for the pasta. she came back a few minutes later with the box, and i asked about the check, she grabbed a couple checks from her pocket and none were ours, she said she would have to go get it, At about that time i noticed the people who were seated just after us still hasn’t gotten thier food and they were starting to complain and even said they might just leave. About 5 – 7 minutes later she finally came back with the other tables food and our check. i looked at the check and it was all there, figured they might have comped the sticks or 1 of the 2 soda’s for the mistake on the missing mozz sticks. but they didn’t. I quickly got cash out as we had been there 90 mintues and wanted to leave, and didn’t want to have to wait for the waitress to get back with a credit card. luckily i had just enough cash for the food and not much for a tip, which is fine cause she frankly didn’t deserve one, and i’m usually a gracious tipper.
Needless to say i will NOT be back here, maybe their traditional wings are better who knows i wont be back to try them. I may try the Sussex one and hope for something better. But not anytime soon.

Food was really good. They didn’t have enough booth space for 6 so, we put the older 2 kids at a table next to us. We asked our waitress if that was ok, she said she didn’t care what we did. Nice! Then the kids were getting a blast of cold air every time the door opened. We moved table up against our booth. Waitress said, oh no! From across the tables. Told us it disturbs the pathway for the waitresses. But it was fine for today. She must of told her other customers about it, then we heard it from them as they walked past our table to the door. Rude waitress! Mgr said she would talk to her. Wow! Won’t go again. Rude waitstaff!

Thank goodness I live so close to this place! My hubby and I have been enjoying Boneyard since it openned probably 5 years ago! The staff is great. The bartenders are wonderful. The owners are friendly and personable. The menus pretty darn big. Their homemade Chili is a staple for me in the winter. And their Deep Fried Pickles — O.M.G. Best I’ve EVER had.

Food was ok nothing to brag about… The stupid hot wings completely tore up my brothers stomach for 2 days…

One of the best burgers I’ve had. Extremely friendly wait staff. Pleasant atmosphere. Average prices

Fun atmosphere in general. I’ve frequented Boneyard on many occasions and the food is consistently good. The only problems that do arise is that service can vary drastically from visit to visit. One night you can get a very attentive waiter with quick service and other nights your interactions with the server can be few far between and in my experience it rarely correlates with how busy they are. Still a fun place to hang out. Trivia on Monday nights too!

I have two favorite places for wings — and this is one of them! Forget about the national chains — you’ve got to try the Boneyard… take their hot sauce challenge if you dare. I haven’t yet, but will someday soon.
Big and meaty wings with your choice of sauce (s). The usual wing thing, but these are good wings!
The other thing that has me coming back is their breaded fried pickles — come on if you have tried them elsewhere and think — «what’s the big deal… that’s gross!», well you have to try the Boneyard fried pickles. These are spears — not slices and the breading holds them together so they aren’t some slimy limp hard to make out what it is kind of appetizer. If you are just looking for something different, just stop in for a beer and order some fried pickles!
They have opened another location now, but I haven’t had a chance to get to their new location… wish they would open in Burlington as I’ve heard rumored.

I’m giving them 4 stars but really they should be 4.5
I think if I had one more shot at this place the review would go to 5
However I don’t live in the area. Just visiting on business.
½ the place is a sports bar and the other half is a restaurant.
The wait staff are cute (girls) and smart.
I have had the ribs here with the honey BBQ sauces and they fell off the bone (which means BTW that ALL the flavor has been transferred to the meat. Truly among the best baby back ribs I have ever had… in my life.
All of the sides you can get were home made recipe and were fantastic. My fave was the Texas corn.
Today for lunch I had a the Tri burger. It had three cheeses and it was a top ten burger. Huge amount of beef. Fresh everything on it. Buttered toasted bunn. Just killer.
This place has more variations of beer than I could count.
I’m sure you will not be sorry
H.

Boneyard, I crave you!
A large space with tons of TVs tuned to Packers and whatever else the customers want to see, this place none the less feels cozy and warm.
They have a special wing night once a week and the places gets packed. Even so, their service is quick and very friendly. The servers seem to know regulars’ names and their favored drinks. The wings are the best I’ve had outside New York – large wings, crispy skin, savory, rich sauce. Perfect. Highly recommended. Speaking of appetizers, don’t miss their fried cheese curds, an artery-​bursting slice of heaven.
Boneyard has sandwiches on delectable pretzel rolls as well as a wide assortment of fabulous burgers. The salad mixed greens and other veggies are fresh and and high quality, too, which is not common for a pub, in my experience.
Tons of beers are on tap; they also have wine and a large cocktail list, along with monthly specials for an even better price than the reasonable cost of everything else on the menu.