Baroni’s New York Pizza

I love Baronis pizza. I always get his spaghetti marinara and it tastes just fantastic I would get it anytime I come here I highly recommend it this is such a fun place to go to with your friends or family even famous people come here one Stephen Colbert was here

Very disappointed with our first experience. Placed an online order and called to check the status after 35 minutes had gone by. The woman who answered the phone was less than helpful and rather rude. When our wait had reached a hour and 10 minutes, we called again and received the same, rude and unhelpful response. The food arrived after an hour and 20 minutes. The pizza was cold and the rolls with our sub were charred black from over cooking. We’re all about trying new places, but this one we won’t be back to.

Ordered delivery pizza on a Wednesday night at 6:11. Called around 6:45 to get an idea of where it was… promised it would be here by 7:15. It was.
Pizza is pretty good and the price is on the mark. I wish they had a more reliable delivery/​timing set-​up though. I think an hour is too long to wait for a pizza.

When Baroni’s first opened, the food wasn’t bad. But over the last year or so, it’s been hit or miss. We used to order the beef & lamb gyros, but the last time we ordered it, it had very little meat and the meat resembled Steak’um, and had no flavor. The wings we ordered were soggy, and the pizza was nothing to write home about. We used to order take out salads for working lunches at the office, but they can’t even get a salad right. I’ve vowed to never eat there again since the food is bad and the service is mediocre, not to mention EXTREMELY slow. If you call in and they say it’ll be ready in 20 minutes, you’re better off waiting an hour before heading out since they rarely have your order ready on time.

This pizza was so good… the service for deliver was fast… was staying in a hotel need some comfort food… and they filled the bill. pizza was hot and just like I orderd. that’s a big deal for me cause another very popular chain has let me down alot. I had the antipasto salad with thier dressing. excelent

Pizza wasn’t bad, but the service was terrible.
We placed an online carry out order at 7:15. Received a call from the restaurant at 7:30 saying it would be ready in 30 minutes.
Arrived at the restaurant at 8:00 for pick up and they said we must have ordered from the wrong location… we showed the email confirmation for them to fill our order.
After waiting an additional 40 minutes, we received a «sorry for your wait» on the way out of the door.
I hate that this happened on our first visit… probably won’t try again.

I ordered delivery to the hotel because I was staying overnight in Mount Pleasant by myself. My order took about 40 minutes and was perfect. The salad was delicious and there aren’t words for the garlic knots it came with! Just what I wantedz

I haven’t even gotten my pizza. It’s been an hour and ten minutes. I called to check on the status. They said it will be the next to leave the restaurant. I hope I’m wrong that the service speaks for the quality of the food.

The delivery service was so bad that I would never choose to eat at this place again even if the meal was for free. Two hour wait for delivery on a Sunday at 7 PM. Called at 9 PM and they still haven’t even made the order yet. Very disappointing! Beware of delivery disaster!

Joshua will make your experience very pleasant. He anticipated all of my requests. I didn’t have to ask for anything. That does not happen often and definitely exceeded my expectations.
In addition to great service, the décor suggests you are in New York restaurant and the pizza tastes great.

Ordered some pizza after a long day of touring Charleston from Baroni’s based on a recommendation from the hotel guidebook. The cashier estimated a 1 hour delivery time (which was surprising given Monday’s are always the slowest restaurant days) after 1hr10min, we called to ask what was going on and were told the pizza was almost ready. After 2hrs we called again and the cashier told us the driver already came, called us then left which was not the case. We had no missed call nor did we hear a knock at our door. My husband cancelled the order out of anger thinking it would be a fair punishment to the establishment. (As I lay in bed with a grumbling stomach, I’m beginning to wonder who really lost this fight)
Anyways, it could have been a fluke but wanted to share our experience to help and future Unilocalers out. We couldn’t help but feel they were taking advantage of us being one of the only late night pizza delivery open around the area.

I can definitely see Baroni’s becoming a go to spot for grabbing a pizza to take home when I don’t feel like cooking anything else… hell, isn’t that why pizza was invented. I doubt they deliver to me but if they do, I’ll be ordering from them even more. The pizza was good, no the best, but way better than ordering some chain garbage pizza. It’s thin crust NY style and smells just like the pizza places on the corner up in the north east. It even looks like I just walked in off the city streets to grab a slice. The biggest selling point was the price. A large Cheese was $ 10 and then we ordered a Peperoni as well which was only $ 1.50 more. The thing that might make me think twice about coming in is the fact that when I did recently, I placed an order for two pizzas to go. They rang up my order and told me it would be about 45 minutes. Normally I can order pizza from places 10 minutes from me and have it delivered in 45 minutes. I had already ordered and paid so I figured I would just wait but, I thought that was a ridiculous wait time for two pizzas. The real problem was that it took over an hour to get my two pizzas. That’s just entirely too long to wait for a to go order. Pick up the pace and we might have a good thing going.

We moved here from Hoboken, NJ a month ago. This is a solid New York style pizza. Fresh ingredients. Nice crust. I’m frankly shocked that this doesn’t have a higher rating on Unilocal.All those reviews based on «rude service» are missing the charm… And flavor! Will be a regular from now on.

Solid pizza and menu items.
One of the few places that has Sicilian and round. Saw some negative reviews. To those I say its a pizza place not a Cypress or The Post House. Good pizza right price.
Try it and decide. The 1 stars are just off the mark.

Terrible delivery service. Took an hour to get here. Driver forgot half gallon of sweet tea, said he would be right back with it. Took another 30 mins to get here. Hardly even apologized.

I placed an order for takeout so I can’t speak to their level of service when dining in. The counter staff was very friendly when I went in for pickup.
I had a coupon for a large/​two-​topping so I figured I’d give it a shot.
The pizza is really good. Everything tastes fresh and has great flavor.
After trying the other Pizza places around Mt. P, this may end up being our go to pizza place.
I would definitely recommend giving it a shot.

I really enjoyed this place — it is definitely a northeast pizza joint — the smell of garlic smacks you in the face as soon as you arrive. Solid pizza, decent beer selection, REALLY good prices. Certainly not fancy but if you’re looking for a slice and plastic seat, this is it.

I thought Slice, in Mount Pleasant, was as good as it got for pizza in the Charleston area, but through a tip from a coworker, I’ve been proven wrong. We checked this place out on Saturday, and it was amazing. The pizza was right, and it was cheap! A large pie, half plain, half mushroom/​onion was $ 10! The garlic knots were great, and they have decent been on tap! We’ll definitely be back, even if it’s a longer drive!

I’m always looking for a lunch place in Mt. P that offers a half and half combo. What can I say, I like variety, so I like to switch up my lunch choices as much as possible.
Today I picked up a slice, small salad, and drink combo. I paid only $ 6, they didn’t put onions or olives on my salad as I requested, and the pizza was good, so I’ll be back some day.

I asked the guy at the front desk for a pizza delivery recommendation and while he did have a couple fliers from different places, he said that I would be most pleased with the pie from Baroni’s. And he was right. It took 35 minutes to be delivered, but when it arrived it was fresh and still quite hot.
Since it was just me, I went with a medium «Four Seasons» which had broccoli, sun-​dried tomatoes, mushrooms, artichokes, and extra cheese. Heaven. The medium is 14 inches and there was enough to go into the fridge for the next day.
Strongly recommend!