Guiseppe’s Pizzeria

Pizza is decent. Round pizzas are better than sheets. Used to go to lunch 2 – 3 times a week. Last visit (⁸⁄₂₀₁₄) I was given a slice that was sitting on top of another pizza. Got home and found that piece so grease soaked it was inedible, matter of fact disgusting. Couldn’t believe the counter person could take the pizza, warm it up, and box it up without noticing he was serving me a piece of crap. I haven’t been back since. There is not enough supervision for all the kids that «work» there. Table tops and floors were always dirty.

We stopped here on our way to Fillmore Glenn state park to grab a quick lunch. It is just a small pizzeria from the outside and equally as small inside, so I was expecting for you run of the mill choice between pepperoni or cheese slice. There were 8 different kinds available, all fairly fresh, and a couple of very interesting pizzas. We got a few different kinds, one was chicken bbq with honey mustard. I tried it and it was very good — not a kind of slice I have seen many places (if any). Prices were not high at all, and the service was great. Definitely a place I would go back to for a quick lunch or if I wanted a whole pizza.

I tried to keep an open mind about this place despite its unkept and neglected appearance inside. After all, every hole-​in-​the-​wall, diner, and dive I’ve experienced had a charming and redeeming quality. Unfortunately, this was not the case. Trash was unswept and tables were dirty even though staff were sitting around doing nothing productive in an empty restaurant during dinner time. Perhaps the best part of this restaurant were the people who were pleasant enough. I thought it was neat how they make the pizza in front of you rather than in the back where you often can’t see the staff work. Chicken wings were dry and lacked substantial meat. The pizza was in an equally unsatisfying state.
Stick with your gut: If you see a lack of maintenance in a restaurant’s eating area, then it could indicate a lack of pride in the food they serve.

Not terrible but not all that great when it comes to pizza.