Pie Lady Cafe

The coffee was great and my butterscotch scone was so yummy. It was lovely to sit on the big front porch on a beautiful day and enjoy those.

I saw Alanna B.‘s ROTD and I decided it was time to update my review on the Pie Lady Café.
My daughter and I (also most of my friends) love this place! It is a really great little find of a shop.
We have pretty much tried everything on the menu and these are my observations/​tips:
— Although the store is titled the Pie Lady, the scones are fantastic. I am especially fond of the Blueberry Lemon or any scone with icing. These babies warm are deadly. The scones are dense and almost like a biscuit.
— I have tried most of the pies. The Blueberry, Cherry Almond and Mixed Berry being my favorites. I have also had the Pecan, Coconut and Apple. These were also good but I prefer the berry pies.
— The quiche and soups are also surprisingly good and make a solid lunch when in Moorestown.
— The porch area is great to sit and watch the world go by. They have some heaters during the colder months. In the Summer there are tables on the sidewalk with umbrellas.
— Things sell out quickly on the weekends, especially the scones. Get to Pie Lady early.
— Pie Lady has odd weekend hours. They close at 3:00 on Saturday and 1:00 PM on Sunday. Sometimes they close for vacation.
— They brew La Colombe coffee and it is very good.
— The Apple Cider doughnuts are also good but only available on weekends.
— Their muffins are pretty darn tasty also.
— CASH ONLY
Parking is easy on the street. The inside dining area is very small. Sometimes they can be very busy. The smell when you open the door is glorious.
4.5 Unilocal Stars.

This place was love. The workers were very friendly and extremely settling. They ran us through their menu that can be found on the front 2 chalkboards. For being a small and quant café it was particularly busy. I treated myself to a slice of the Strawberry/​Apple pie as well as their heavy favorited Blueberry and lemon scone. Both were very satisfying. The pie was a massive slice on this neat cold plate. The pie had a good overall sweetness and the scone lives up to the hype. Each thing on the menu tasted exceptional. Kate got the apple cider doughnut and these are only available on the weekends. She LOVED them so we may be coming back traditionally on Sunday’s lol. The only downside was that for a single slice of the pie your options are slim. I came with hopes of tasting their blueberry or apple pies but learned after the long travel that you have to buy whole pies for certain flavors. So this was disappointing but other than this minor thing the place was great I recommend giving it a chance.

Everything you buy here is DELICIOUS!!! I ordered a gluten free pecan pie for the Holidays, and received rave reviews. Highly recommend this place.

I know they are called the pie lady but their scones are my favorite. Definitely worth stopping for their lemon blueberry scone.

Excellent pies, scones, doughnuts and service — do not miss an opportunity to stop and enjoy the wonderful experience here!

The sconesssss!!! Awesome, creative, and very friendly service. Who can ask for more.. . Oh wait super good and strong coffee!

The food here is scrumptious. Everything here is delicious. The people are polite, and their central goal is to please the customer in any way. The whipped cream is 100% natural, nothing like the Reddi Whip. The parking is okay, speaking that nobody goes back there a lot. Will definitely go back anytime I am able to.

This is a very very very small boutique pastry/​pie shop. The pies and scones are delicious. The scones are probably the best I’ve had in a long time. My favorite is the lemon blueberry scone; highly recommend.
Street parking only and it is usually not difficult to get a parking spot.
There are a few picnic tables outside for you to enjoy a scone or piece of pie with a cup of coffee on a nice sunny day. Take out is easy.
Note: Cash Only

Quaint little shop with amazing baked goods. My husband and I shared a slice of mixed berry pie and it was divine. Come here for homemade feel good treats. Maybe it’s best that I live far away from Pie Lady.

The best scones I have never had. Not to thrilled with the pies or their hours (random) but her scones make up for it!

Someone from work brought scones in for breakfast from the pie lady. I wouldn’t say I’m an avid scone fan, but this woman has changed my mind. I have tried butterscotch, citrus and chocolate chip cinnamon. Baked fresh in the morning so when it’s out its out, but if you get there early the baked goods are still warm! You can purchase pie by the slice, as well as biscotti, all home made and flavored changing by the day. The place is extremely small. A rainy day or anything concerning outside would be concerning inside if it’s crowded. There are some tables and benches outside to sit if it is a nice day. Definitely a breakfast must!

I’m giving this place four stars for now. The service is spectacular. I got a lemon and blueberry scone which was really good. I also got a piece of the coconut custard pie that I didn’t much care for. It wasn’t that sweet and kind of bland tasting. However, I plan on trying other things because I’m sure they have some kind of pie that I’ll love. They are a little pricey but they rent a prime location on main street so that’s to be expected.

Great place for a cup of coffee and pastries/​pie. Have a seat out on the porch and relax.

The best spot in Moorestown. Wonderful scones (blueberry lemon is my favorite), quiche (love spinach feta) and donuts/​pie. They serve La Calombe coffee, which is always hot and fresh. The owner is wonderful and her staff works hard. They also serve tea, water, iced tea, etc. There is very, very limited indoor seating, but the locals sit out on the covered porch or patio to eat. We need more breakfast/​café options in Moorestown, so I hope Pie Lady expands one day. OH– and cash only!

Really tiny place but I dont mind that. It makes it more intimate. But its not very interesting nothing spectacular sets it apart from any other coffee shop that isnt starbucks. I got a chai tea latte with an apple raisin scone. The chai was $ 3 and it tasted like water with cinnamon. No flavor didn’t do anything for my taste buds. The apple scone was REALLY DRY AND CRUMMY. Totally disappointing, this little place has tons of potential! Great locatio. also I dined inside and recieved my chai in a to go cup :/​would probably never go back.

Love the Pie Lady Café! Excellent Service from Emily (who has cute purple hair) who provided both delicious food and comedy :). I highly recommend the Spinach and Mushroom Quiche!

The blueberry lemon scone is reason enough to stop by! So delicious. I also got the crab and green onion quiche which was also very yummy. It was packed with crab! It’s the perfect little place to pick up breakfast. They also carry La Colombe coffee!

The quiches and pies are fantastic. The scones, just the right amount of crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. So fresh, flavorful and I just love the smell walking in. I have yet to try their other goods, but I will for sure.
There’s no doubt, you have to get here early if you want to see and try what they have that day. Once something is gone, you’ve missed out.
They are cash or check only! So come prepared to get more than what you came for. It is reasonably priced which is great. Under $ 5 for a big slice of quiche or pie, under $ 2 for a cup of coffee, and only $ 1 for a bottle of water.
They always heat up your quiches and I like to sit outside and listen to the hustle and bustle of E Main Street.

Love this place! It always smells great and the prices are mad reasonable. In addition, the owner is incredibly friendly. I recommend the apple cider doughnuts or whatever the scone of the day is. Yummy!
The only downside to the Pie Lady is that once she runs out of something, that’s it for the day. So get there quick.