Frederic Goodman Jewelers

they are amazing — they are so helpful and have helped fix /​enhance many pieces of jewelry for me and my family. I purchased our wedding bands with them and get compliments all the time. Everytime I get a piece back from them it looks better than when I dropped it off. Can’t say enough good things about the team there. Karen, Tony. everyone. They’re the best.

I chose this as my first Unilocal review to write what an outstanding experience I had with Frederic Goodman Jewelers.
I was referred to them (by a friend who had an excellent experience) to purchase first an engagement ring for my girlfriend and (after she said yes!) wedding bands.
For the engagement ring, I had a pretty specific request of a top tier blue sapphire and a french halo. This was absolutely NO problem for the incredible staff. Jeannie was amazing and walked me through the entire process. I even received a personal email from Mr. Goodman ensuring I was getting excellent service and my product was satisfactory. It was above and beyond what we could have ever expected for the price. My wife is constantly getting complements on it. Their payment plan was also extremely flexible and easy. They made it work for me.
We then needed wedding bands and the service could not have been better. As we were on a budget due to the wedding, they worked with me and came up with a price that was well within my budget.
I can’t thank them enough for their first class jewelry and customer service. I would highly recommend them to anyone in need of an engagement ring or anything else for that matter. 5+ Stars.

Very reliable store. Staff is very friendly. Always bring my watch for a battery replacement and cleaning. Never a problem after receiving back the watch.

This store will not receive a dime of my money!
New to town, I stopped in WITH MY HUSBAND (read opportunity to make my wishlist) to have 2 pieces of antique jewelry appraised. Two shop workers saw us and averted their eyes without speaking. When we finally had the attention of one of the workers, I asked about appraising the pieces. She was not friendly at all and came off extremely judgmental. I was enamored with the items in the cases and so stayed a little longer hoping the experience would get better.
When I was uncomfortable leaving the pieces over the weekend as she suggested and trying to decide if I wanted to leave them, she repeatedly suggested that I take them elsewhere. By the third or forth time she said it, I decided she was right. So I took my 3 carat diamond ring elsewhere to be appraised.
I found a reputable shop nearby to have my rings appraised at only $ 70 instead of the quoted $ 250 from this place. AND the salespeople at the new shop were extremely friendly.
Frederic Goodman Jewelers, you were very shortsighted today. We may have been in our gym clothes, but you didn’t notice the fat wallet, did you?

Hours not as posted. I was disappointed to find the door locked prior to the posted closing time, especially because the hours are not very accommodating for those with a full time job. The store is attractive and repairs were well done, but the service is rather indifferent. I would give them another shot but they could benefit from a stronger customer focus.

Whether you are purchasing, fixing or appraising — this store fulfills all your jewelry needs. From purchasing high end gold and diamonds to replacing a watch battery — this is now my go to place.
Looking for cuff links this is your place. OMG I’m in trouble. They carry a wonderful line of enamels (my favorite) and for years I have been looking for a jeweler to repair one of my vintage pairs of cufflinks. These are the first pair that I ever owned and they are special as that started me on my collection. Not only did Tony fix my links, he cleaned them up while keeping the patina. Plus, he gave me some great advice on caring for my other 100+ pairs.
The staff here are warm and inviting. It’s nice to see a store that also has a mens section with a nice range from traditional to edgy — at varying price points. The staff has extensive knowledge of their jewelry and can to guide you to unexpected pieces. If they don’t have something in stock they have catalogs and go that extra step to find you just the right item.
Of course I have them looking for me – and Bob will have a wish list next time.

Frederic Goodman Jewelers is the best. It is the perfect place to go pick out a gift and really make it personal. The ability to walk into a local, classic, family-​owned, store and actually handpick a piece of jewelry is overlooked these days. The staff is incredibly knowledgable and friendly. They are also excellent with repairs.

Last year I set out to find the perfect engagement ring — I can’t say enough about Frederic Goodman Jewlers! Everyone there, especially Karen O’Neill, turned a potentially very stressful situation into a memorable, lovely occasion. What I appreciated most, she took the time to find out about my girlfriend and what type of person she was to help select the stones. Karen arranged to have four diamonds for me to look at, stayed exactly within my budget, and patiently explained the 4 C’s! When I went to the store, I learned a lot without feeling pressured and she let me make my own decisions. And I got there in 30 minutes from mid-​town Manhattan. Most importantly, the quality was beyond compare. I was deeply impressed by the clarity and cut of my final selection.
Once I made my decision, they took it from there, had the ring mounted in an exquisite setting and worked with my delivery time. My fiancée absolutely adores her ring and I keep catching her staring at it — sometimes as the sun comes through the windshield, while she’s driving!

Absolutely the best for high quality upscale jewelry in MTC. Wish I could buy everything in this store. Low pressure helpful sales people.