Wavecrest Resort Motel

Great place. Better than I expected. Totally beachy, independently owned condos operated by a private hotel management company. Nothing fancy, but perfect for a beach getaway. Ours was an ocean front suite with a queen bed, and separate LR/​Kitchen. The bedroom was a little bright in the morning so we put additional towels over the Windows. The front desk lady was nice and told us about a great local place for food (The Dock) when we got there late the first night. The beach itself is just on the eastern edge of hither hills so it’s pretty much isolated and perfect. It’s about a 5 minute drive from town. Cell phone coverage is minimal at best, but wifi is good, so if you can hook up to wifi calling/​texting, you’ll never notice.
Our only complaint is this. Last night, in the room next to us, a «domestic dispute» seemed to loudly be going on. Being that nobody mans the desk after 9, they have a number you can call for any type of emergency, it’s listed right in the welcome packet. A phone call we decided was warranted for this situation, but when we called, we found out the number was disconnected. Not cool. I told the lady in the morning and she said she’d get on it, so hopefully she did. What would we have done if the bathroom flooded or someshit? Just something to inquire about before booking. I’d definitely go back.

We stayed at this resort this weekend and the room was filled with black mold — the stench was so strong I instantly got a headache. Because the office had booked the resort full, there was nothing they could do to help — they didn’t apologize; they didn’t seem surprised; they didn’t check the room; they didn’t offer a resolution! They even refused to refund the room fee! Not every room is like this, but the fact that they would even think to offer a room that is clearly unhealthy and unsafe is disgusting! They should be ashamed of themselves!

Fabulous beach, their beach attendants are helpful, the front desk is a different story. They are rude and inattentive. The woman acted as if she was doing me a favor by checking me in. If they did not have a great location there would be little reason to stay there based on their poor attitude.

Nothing major going on in the room. Very basic, if even a little old. But who cares, the location is great. I thoroughly enjoyed my time there and would go back again.

So I stayed at this motel this past Friday into Saturday for a wedding. The only way this gets one star is the fact that it was close to where we had to be. For starters, the «suite» we were put in was behind the front desk and the view was the street. The room was disgusting to say the least; The sheets were filthy and there was not one but three spiders in the room. There is a pull out couch with a «mattress» and by mattress I mean sheets covering metal springs. On top of that, we had to call twice to get fresh towels and actual room service as neither bed was made. Finally, the parking is not adequate at all. There is barely enough spots and most of the time you are parking along a fence or in front of someone else’s room. Never again!

Stayed here for a wedding from Thursday– Saturday and it was not adequate at all! First off, the moment we got there the lady at the front desk was very rude. The bride-​to-​be had left gift bags for everyone staying at the hotel for the wedding and the front desk lady literally picked up the bag from behind her and placed it on the desk without saying a word. Didn’t tell us what it was for or explain the shuttle service the bride had provided for the wedding. Our suite was basically attached to the front desk and so there was absolutely no parking spot provided for us. We were basically parked in front of our own door. The keys were very difficult to turn and our view was basically the street. How come the regular rooms get the beautiful ocean view but the suite has the street and a dirty pond? Seriously?
The room was another story. The oven made a terrible humming noise all night, the bathroom floor had marks all over it and the actual floor in the room was so disgusting. We found three to four spiders living in the room, which I understand its a beach motel but they had basically made homes– so was the room never cleaned thoroughly? We called for more towels and were told «Oh, when they come around to clean your room they’ll bring more.» Well guess what? Not once in the three days we were there did ANYONE come to clean our rooms.
I think I’d be fine with the quality of the room considering it is a beach motel except the staff was rude and literally lied to us at every turn. Also overcharged many of the guests by upping the price from when the guest called to when they arrived, basically ripping off many people.
One star for the view, and I can’t even credit that to the motel itself.
Also, WIFI was terrible– didn’t work even though we asked the maintenance men to reboot the system («Oh sure sure!”= another lie) and the front desk CLOSES at ⁴⁄₅ which means NO STAFF ON PREMISES. What if there was an emergency? No one to help any of the guests at night– absolutely terrible.

I’d just like to throw up a giant middle finger to our hotel here in Montauk, NY. We are here for a friend’s wedding, it’s near the Hamptons so I knew it wasn’t going to be cheap… but…when I pay $ 180/​night I have a few expectations. Let’s review a few of those expectations. An iron and ironing board… nice things to have in a hotel. A mattress that didn’t come out of a Motel 6, pillows that are thicker than a spiral bound notebook, shampoo, a telephone that actually works… which is important because of the sign that they have on the door warning you that if you have an emergency to use the room phone, because there is no cell phone coverage… in 2014, there is no cellphone coverage «in this section of the beach»…if I want to make a call I’m apparently supposed to drive into town to do so.
I should have known to go somewhere else when I had to fax in a signed credit card authorization and an acknowledgement hush that there are no cancellations within 30 days (every legitimate hotel is 24hrs) or when I was told that the group rate that was supposedly negotiated for the wedding didn’t exist.

The room was fine, nothing to write home about but it had a lovely view of the beach. That’s what the one star is for. And that’s all they deserve. The staff however were awful, I really don’t understand why people have to be so rude and unhelpful. There was no cellphone reception in the room so we called front desk and asked them if they could call us one. They wouldn’t, and told us to call one from the room — wouldn’t give us a number. Then when we checked out she informed us we owed $ 4 for using the phone! Seriously how difficult is it to call a cab for someone, and then to charge us $ 4 for it! Disgusted. And when we checked out, the snooty woman stood at the desk and continued to read her paper as I was stood there. Asked for a late checkout, was told no. Again very rudely. I will not be back again.

Stayed here 6 years in a room– clean, great beach views, friendly staff. Our favorite place!

I stayed here this past weekend for memorial day. After staying in a super crappy motel in Manasquan, NJ last summer — I wasn’t expecting the hotels in this little beach town to be that nice. It’s no Ritz Carlton of course, but the rooms were clean, the shower was big, and it even included a kitchen with a stove, refrigerator, dishes, and microwave! Ours had a balcony with two lawn chairs as well. It was very cute and for the price I would highly reccommend it! My only gripe is there was basically NO cell phone reception. I have AT&T and the whole time I was there my phone said «No Service», and my friends who had Verizon got very spotty service as well.

Got the «Garden View» room labor day weekend because it was one of the last places with vacancy and it was the cheapest! The location was great because it was right on the water, but you definitely need a car to get around and to downtown Montauk. The room was very damp though and mostly because we had a handicap bathroom and the water went everywhere after you showered and never evaporated! The staff was really friendly and gave us extra pillows and towels when we asked. They have mini kitchens in the rooms too if you want to cook — but I say dine out!

Solid 4-​star experience. The rooms greatly exceeded my expectations. Very clean, large, nicely decorated, with a fantastic balcony, and large sliding glass doors to take in the exception ocean views. The bathroom wasn’t huge, but it was in good shape, shower large enough and everything was in working order. The little kitchenette was useful. Full cablevision service with adequate channels.
When you sleep, leave the large balcony door open so you can hear the waves crashing. I wish I was back there with my girlfriend right now. We had so much fun!
The little books in each room are a nice touch, it’s cool to read the little notes from the last people who’ve staying in your room.
The only really negative thing I can say about it is that they don’t take American Express but I think I would still have given them 4-​stars either way.

We stayed here on a lovely October evening. The staff was friendly and recommended some great local restaurants. Every room has a view of the ocean and a private deck. The room was clean and cozy and we slept with the ocean tide in our ears. If you’re looking for a good deal on the water this seems to be Mantauk’s best bet. Would definitely return.

My wife and I celebrated our 10 year wedding anniversary by staying at Wavecrest for 4 days/​3 nights. We stayed after Labor Day, so rates were lower and tourism had died down a bit. It also helped that we were staying during the week rather than on the weekend.
I agree with Melissa’s assessment. Wavecrest is a great option for couples but less so for families. The reason is that there’s not a lot to do, so if you enjoy simply beaching it and relaxing with great views, this is the place for you. If you have a car, it’s easy to find places to eat as well.
Although this is a «resort,» do not assume you will find 4 star accommodations. At the end of the day, this is a «beach hotel» meaning that you are paying for a good location, not for excellent amenities.
With that said, our accommodations can best be described as «cozy.» Melissa’s right — I could not get my AT&T mobile phone to work and it was a pain to have to pay, even for local calls. However, there is free wifi, so you’re not completely cut off from the real world.
So, would I return? You bet! I do not need 4 star accommodations, and the view right on the beach is spectacular. I’d pay just for this kind of seclusion.

Let me start out with who should consider this place as a vacation spot and who should not:
SHOULD
honeymooners
a couple who wants a romantic getaway
grandparents
parents escaping their children for a quiet weekend
anyone sick of a bustling city and looking for some peace
SHOULD NOT
spring break kids
a girls weekend
partiers
—
We vacationed here for a week July 2008. On a personal experience basis, I give this place five stars, but I was on my honeymoon and that makes me bias. Stepping back and really considering this place, it probably should realistically get a three because of its lack of amenities, but a four because it was great at what it was meant to be (a quiet vacay spot), so that’s what I’m giving it, and here’s why…
PROS: It is super quiet and super relaxing. Hubby and I reserved a suite on the Beach Dunes. We had a private deck that overlooked the ocean. The sound of the waves were hypnotic at night. The beach is private and near empty every day and every night, weekday and weekend. The closest person to us was about 120 yards away and we were right outside out window. The waves are huge… sometimes so much so we didn’t dare challenge them. They have a cabana boy who will load up chairs and such for you and haul them out to the spot of your choice. You can just leave them there with you’re finished. Limitless towels at your disposal. The small kitchenette is perfect, the bathrooms and place is as clean as a Montauk lodge on the beach can get, and the towels were always abundant and fresh. They’ll change your bedding as long as you ask them. They won’t wash your dishes. Walls are either super thick or our neighbors were super quiet, but we definitely never heard them once! (hopefully they experienced the same from us! ha!)
CONS: The staff is as bitter as old unsweetened coffee. Very curt and unhelpful. They could really not care less. There isn’t any internet, wireless or otherwise. No cell phone reception (Sprint & AT&T at the time) The TV, when upon day 6 we turned it on to check the weather for the first time, took 10 minutes to come to life and offered probably three channels. We also had to pay a $ 20 refundable deposit for the remote, even though we didn’t want it. They charge to make local calls (something I think is unheard of and which they don’t tell you when you check in). The closest place to get something to eat is Gosman’s Dock, a 20 minute walk down the beach, otherwise you’re stuck with a vending machine and maybe two places from town who will deliver, depending on what day it is and how much you order.
Glass Half Full /​Half Empty — This place is located off the beaten path; definitely can’t walk to the town unless you have an hour to kill each way. It’s about a 7 minute taxi ride to town (I’d recommend Pink Tuna Taxi, they’re awesome and the cheapest!) or a 10 minute moped ride, which is what Hubby and I did… rented a moped for the week. Best choice. Romantic and fun, and we could come and go as we pleased without waiting on cabs to show up. We liked being away from the main hubbub, again because of how secluded and private it was, and having the option to go in to town and get some nightlife when we wanted it, but next time we visit (for our 1yr anniversary), we decided to go for a second type of experience and stay in town this time.
Overall, to all you romantics and quiet-​weekend getawayers, I highly recommend this place!