Oceanside Beach Resort

Terrible place. Just visited off season. Price was ridiculous for an old crummy place with lousy beds, lousy pillows, peeling paint, and no amenities. As everyone said it stank of smoke. If it had been close to full it would have been noisy too, those are some damn shoddy walls.
Oh and there’s almost no view at all from the second floor (for which we paid extra, yay!) and none from the first thanks to high artificial dunes. Don’t let the name or location fool you. Beach is close but the view is shitty.
One more point of criticism: kid working there had a pickup truck covered in racist, anti-​immigrant, and misogynist stickers too, really made us feel creeped out and unwelcome when we realized it was a staff and not guest vehicle.
You are entitled to display your in-​your-​face racist bumper stickers in America. As my wife said, every time we pulled in we felt aggressively insulted by a hostile and violent message.
But you should expect public displays of bigotry and hostility to lead others to associate that bigotry with your business. You may then experience MY freedom of speech and lose my custom and get bad reviews like this. It was a crapola hotel like any crapola old divey motel, but I wouldn’t have bothered saying so on Unilocal if we didn’t also feel insulted and creeped out by your staff or owner’s truck.
Highly not recommended. As others have said it’s an unpleasant and unwelcoming place.

Stayed x2 nights @ Rm #4 = paper thin walls & ceiling, squeaky sliding doors, lumpy plastic mattress, sticky floors, water damaged walls … It ain’t cheap either!

$ 150ish off season dollars will get you a room that smells like smoke, paper thin walls, a dirty shower curtain and bizarrely loud squeaky and uncomfortable beds. Some nice fixtures cheaply done but would have preferred being able to sleep on beds that were not like sleeping on a deflated air mattress that sounded a loud warning every time you moved. We also got a call from the front desk asking when we were arriving so that they could go home. It was 6pm. Front desk is not manned so no one to make anything right.

Updated but done cheap n quick big tub didn’t even work, clean thy n nice people. Good close to town n beach not good for night crowd it’s quite at night and also its good for families pool is clean

We stayed here after we had a horrible experience at Ocean Surf Resort and it was a great experience. The room was clean and had a tub tub. The views were great and the staff was really friendly. The bed was SUPER comfortable! Great set up. We had a kitchen, a little breakfast area and really great furnishings. Definitely recommend this place to anyone!

I’m not even going to bother reading the negative reviews, because this place was exactly what I was looking for. I booked a last minute trip to Montauk for a one-​night stay over the weekend (Saturday to Sunday) and the staff could not have been more accommodating. My friend and I arrived around 3PM and our place was ready for us when we arrived. Clean, spacious, with a fridge, patio and coffee maker. I mean, what else do you need when the beach is calling your name? They allowed us to have a late checkout and gave us great recommendations on restaurants in the area. I will definitely stay here again!

Granted I stayed here off season, but I really have no complaints. Arrived a bit late and the manager came down right away and offered a free upgrade since he had the room available. The room was clean, nicely appointed and maintained. Only having one chair was a bit annoying, but I wasn’t there for chairs.
Technically the second floor is ocean view. You can even see a 25 foot break in the dune where you can see the water break. However, this barely qualifies as water view in my book.
We chose to stay an extra night. I was disappointed that the owner wouldn’t negotiate the price further. But she did give me a little break.
I would return but I might check out a different location actually on the beach.

I booked for valentines day about 3 weeks in advance unfortunately a blizzard was going to happen that day. I called the hotel the day before the woman who answered the phone wouldn’t even do anything I know she has no control over the weather but something could have been worked out but she would not hear of it. I booked though price line they called the hotel too and she said she would not help resolve the mater I would have to pay full price I would have been happy to split the bill but she would not do anything, I think thats poor business, this left a sour taste in my mouth. That’s why I gave it one star, it’s a bummer.

Worst place ever!!! I felt like a teenage that was being spied on by my parents!!! Hotel staff is awful. I stayed in Montauk a million times, unfortunately we booked late and this was the only place available and now I know why!!! We had a few guest visit to go to the beach and for the firework show. I brought a few of them back to use the my bathroom and the Hotel manager came to my room asking me how many people were staying over I told her none, I said we have a few friends visiting for the day. She told me that it’s private property and she needs to charge them $ 20 a head. I said they are not staying over, she insisted that if they use the bathroom or step foot in HER rooms she needs to charge them. She was so rude and nasty! My boyfriend payed the woman $ 120 just to shut her up. And she still watched over us like we were doing something wrong!!! I suggest staying at the Royal Atlantic, Same price, friendly staff, clean rooms and your not stalked and you can have visitors!!!

You definitely get what you pay for. No grill rooms. Paper thin walls (the person Next store snoring kept us up Most of the night). Paper bath mat. Very squeaky uncomfortable beds. Only shampoo and 1bar of soap. Only perk is how close it is to the beach but seems that there may be better options out there.

My boyfriend just spent the night for the first time at OBR and was very pleased with our experience. The price was right (at this time of year I would expect it) and the room was lovely and clean. Looks recently remodeled. Also, the soft blankets were awesome. So warm and toasty! Would definitely consider staying during the season.

We checked in after being forced to pay half of the reservation month before we arrived. This is a motel, and an expensive one. The first night we were treated to trying to sleep in a sauna. The walls are paper thin and the noise that came from the room above at 5AM was impossible to sleep through. In the morning I wanted to have a coffee only to find out we had no cups and the coffee was all decaf. I went to the front desk to try and resolve some of the many issues. The blond/​grey haired lady was rude and did not care. She hand me cups and that was the end of that. She tried to argue with me that the coffee was not decaf… even when I showed her in clear text on the coffee it was decaf. Thankfully later that day I ran into Joel. Joel is the jack of all trades around the motel. I asked him if she had passed on the room temp concern and he did not know anything about it. He immediately sprang into action and said he would resolve the problem. He also hunted high and low to get us some real coffee. I doubt that Joel is paid much at this place… but if it was not for him you would not get any service. Be prepared to pay way too much and get rude service… too bad you can just deal with Joel!

I understand the bad reviews. I’ve stayed in worse, but not intentionally. Should have read the reviews before booking in this place. The mattress is SO HARD, walls thin, NO amenities, bathroom has no tub, no counter space,
no fan, poor lighting. Room does not have a closet or ironing board. Only thing resembling a nice hotel here is the price. Expensive rates with cheap hotel rooms.

Apparently I didn’t read the policies before booking a room. There is no limit to the number of people you have in a room and pets are welcome as well… Also smoking is mandatory.
Great location, but a trashy place

Not quite sure what the complaints are about. The room was quite nice– very close to the beach and seemed to have been recently remodeled. The room came with AC (we didn’t use it but it seemed new), free wifi and mini fridge.
My only complaints:
— cheap mattress (very springy)
— no bathtub
— paper thin walls– we could hear the tv in the room next door
We came for an early summer, mid-​week get away and were happy with the price/​value.

Remodeled rooms, nice nautical décor. Had an extremely early check in 5am… Owner came out and checked me in (office was closed), nice balcony, love the sound of the ocean… If I can be back out here I will stay here again

We called and booked the 2 ½ efficiency over the phone a few months back. The website does not specify how many bedrooms, so we asked the employee over the phone and he confirmed 2 bed rooms. When we showed up in August, we were surprised to find just 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom, and a living room. Yes, that is correct, a 2 ½ efficiency is a 1 br! We talk to the building manager, and they confirmed to us that they had fired an employee a few months back, and confirmed that he had given this incorrect information to other guests as well. They had full occupancy for the weekend, so could no do anything else about it. We followed up with multiple emails looking for a resolution to this blatant lie, and continued to be ignored. After finally calling back, we received a rude response. In addition, the pull out sofa was gross and dirty, there was no window shade in the bedroom, and the kitchen was poorly equipped with utensils for cooking. I would not recommend this place to anyone, as they deceived us, admitted it, then did nothing to correct it since we had to pay up front!
and no a/​c!

This is honestly the worst hotel experience I have ever had in my ENTIRE life.
To start off, the rooms are completely dirty and disgusting and have non-​functional lamps, causing you to have to get ready in the dark and no A/​C. One of the beds was completely broken and swayed back and forth and the other two beds were rock hard and dirty. We saw a cockroach run across one of the pillows in the morning so we decided to check out of the room early.
Besides this place being completely over-​priced, the owners here are rude and threatened to «spy on us» to make sure that we didn’t have more than 4 people in our room. They make you pay the entire hotel stay up front because they know that once you see the hotel in person you will regret your decision.
The website for this place is COMPLETELY misleading. The hotel is right on the beach but it is dirty and I would not wish upon ANYONE to stay at this hotel (even if they get a free stay).
I have no idea how this place has a 4 star rating. If it were up to me I would give it 0 stars.

This place is family owned. They take pride in making you comfortable. The location is great! The beach is right over the dunes which is the back of the hotel. The backyard courtyard is a great place to hang and BBQ. and we brought our dog!!! Only a 7 minute walk to the middle of town. We’ll be back!!!