Naturally Good Food & Cafe

Excellent little place. Walked over from hotel. Coffee very good and breakfast tortilla wrap very tasty. Wish the tortilla was warmed. If I came again I’d ask for it to be.

Very fresh food. They have beer for sale.
Wife had vegetarian chili which was excellent.
I had organic chicken sandwich was good.
They have seating in the front and back.
Nice find.

We eat lunch here every time we’re in town. The tofu salad is the best!!! It’s a great spot to grab lunch before the beach.

The burrito and salads were very good. The salads were very fresh, and so were their juices. The food was prepared fast. We all enjoyed a healthy meal.

We came back here to get lunch on a Sunday afternoon. I ordered «Lauren’s Go-​To Sandwich» without tomato and a «Dreamsicle» smoothie. I also tried the «Berry Hydrating» smoothie. Everything was great!

I was soo happy to find this place while I was staying in montauk. One of the only places around town with air conditioning. I won’t eat at a food place without air conditioning bc I am not Into sweat on my food. So thank you naturally good !!! Place is Clean. Food was good. I will be back.

I think Naturally Good Food & Café is a must go to if you are visiting Montauk. It’s a great place to grab something to eat that won’t weigh you down and give you the yucks on a beautiful beach day.
I went to the location on Main Street, and we ordered Fish Tacos and an Organic Chicken Sandwich. Both were delicious. They will bring the food out to wherever you are sitting. There is space to sit inside, on the front porch, or in the back garden section. I suggest the back garden section. You’re away from the main street and can have a quieter moment. There is parking in the back as well.
If you’re staying in Montauk, tons of grocery options to take home with you. Really a great store, staff was friendly and it was a great vibe.

Excellent sandwiches and smoothies! Food comes out timely. Love it here!

Came here for breakfast during a stay at Montauk. Feels more like a lunch place but we stayed to try it out. I got the costa rican platter which comes with brown rice and beans, scrambled eggs, avocado, salsa, and a whole wheat tortilla. Everything was great but the rice and beans were spicy and I hadn’t anticipated that based on the menu description.
They had a very cute sit down area in the front and back of the store, with a garden in the back. You can also browse through the store to find other organic items for purchase.

Had been to this place before before it became a healthier option and I have to say I was pleasantly pleased with the food. We ordered a breakfast tortilla called the Costa Rican, the multi grain pancakes, yogurt with granola/​fruit and a smoothie. We really liked every single item especially the tortilla! I’m only giving 3 stars because the cappuccino we ordered was just ok and also because we ordered the“short stack” pancakes but out came only 2 measly thin pancakes for $ 6.50. Yes I know it’s the Hamptons, but 2 thin, not at all fluffy pancakes do not a «stack» make.

They have a small garden with umbrellas in the back where you can sit (and wait) before enjoy some really good lunch items. The garden has herbs and plants growing all around which is really good too. Killer Korean style salad and tuna sandwiches and wraps. Be prepared for a 10 – 15 minute wait unless you grab some items already prepared.

Keeping it short, I had the montauk monster wrap that came with chips and it was awesome! I would compare the prices to any orher «healthy food» spot. I would return here for lunch. also I am looking forward to trying the shakes/​smoothies. Keep in mind you have to go to the location on main street (I think 799 main).

Quality organic goodness. Two locations for your convenience. The smoothies are great as are the food made to order as well as the grab and go. Expect a wait but you will not be disappointed in the food .
The hummus and guacamole are just some of my faves as are the simply refresh smoothie as well As the funky monkey .
Thanks for the awesome food and quality and fresh too.

Great coffee. I got an iced late with skim milk. Excellent and fast staff, very friendly.
Prices were reasonable. I will be going back again. A damn fine cup of coffee.
Update: Went back today for a cappuccino smoothie for myself and a tropical one for the girlfriend. They were awesome. And the girl behind the counter remembered my name and was very nice. A+++

I only have good things to say about Naturally Good Food & Café – I’m just trying to decide where to begin writing… The food made to order is unique, healthy, and delicious. I love starting my day with breakfast from NatGood – an egg tortilla with a side of their flavorful salsa or one of their vegan scones washed down with a fresh juice or smoothie always get my day on the right track. Plus, I love coming in and seeing friendly and familiar faces – the owners, Lauren Katz and Andrea Mavro, and manager Tory Bingham are always super busy. However, they always find time to greet and welcome their customers. On weekends, when I have time to come in for lunch, I love trying something off the daily specials board. Chef Andrea Mavro comes up with the yummiest well balanced meals. The specials always catch me by surprise. On any given day, the specials can range from a homemade sunflower burger with tomato, sprouts, and vegan dill-​horseradish sauce to a butternut squash quesadilla to a Cajun tofu wrap. Besides delicious food, owner Lauren Katz keeps the market stocked with all of my favorite organic and natural beauty products. She is always finding new items for me to try and get hooked on. Whenever I go in, I am inspired to be healthier and happier. I love this place!

Wow I wish we lived closer we would be here all the time. Delicious organic breakfast. Great smoothies. Also gluten free baked goods. They also have a little supermarket so you can shop as well. Great addition to Montauk!

Good food, casual atmosphere, and a reasonable price. Nice place to go to grab a quick bite.
Not wonderful service, however. Had to remind the staff more than once that we ordered a latte.

Wow! I usually don’t like to go to the same place twice in the same weekend but that’s what happened here. I had the best breakfast I’ve ever had!!! I got the eggs cheese and veggie sausage on an English muffin. Perfect egg to cheese ratio. Perfect veggie sausage (a hard find) and honestly the best frickin English muffin I’ve ever had.
So I went back. And I got the special salad (arugula, apples, craisins, cheese) and it was equally amazing.
To top it off I had a great celeb siting. So fetch!

One of the top places where they truly know your name
Emma is a gem, all the staff is exceptional
The new location is going to be the PERFECT fit
Boomerang juice please

Yep, five star café near the beach. Just around the bend from Aimee’s closet and Joni’s (organic etc) is Naturally Good Food & Café.
Why five stars?
Are they kidding. real yellow fin tuna not made from a can. Nice… Guacamole with just the right amount of large pieces and not over mashed. perfect… This is Montauk. suprised to have this out here. Awesome.
They do smoothies, and sandwiches and more too… had fresh fruit too. but I really liked the sound of a few of the items they carried in the cases, and the ones I tried were perfect. They have fresh squeezed OJ. thats always appreciated.
There were more than enough people to help, I was asked by more than one person to assist. And numerous people clued me in on what I was curious about.
Then the two young women that were helping me were so helpful and sweet, and I’m never usually surprised, were the proprietors. So you have two hands on owners and also some help. I asked if the blond woman my age was the owner. asuuming so… they said. no we are… lol… How cool are these ladies… staffing up right, plus being hands on, and all giving customer service… so if this place gets too busy in summer… it will be for the right reasons. not for lack of hiring staff or not being on site.
They know how to run a business in here. and it was really nice to have creative and good choices. Please don’t ask how much real yellow fin tuna salad costs. It’s more than from the can. lol It’s above average quality deli at seasonal remote location/​beach pricing. Be glad it’s here– or go to the IGA which really is awesome out here too.
hahaha
Will stop here every visit. Seriously liked this place.