Falbo Bros Pizza Monona

i ordered a small cheese with pepperoni deep dish pizza. it was my first time ordering from falbos. this pizza was soooooo gooooood. and the small i ordered, it looked like a large! omg! the delivery person was the best, laid back, not acting like he was scared or whatever, this place is the real deal!!! i love falbos pizza. i just love it!!! and it’s close to my home, yeah…

Love this place, every time we order it’s consistent, fast, anytime we have a minor issue they are happy to take care of it. I really love their sausage it’s delicious. The salads are wonderful, always big and have plenty of ingredients.

Everything about this place has went downhill. Used to love the food, but not anymore. My husband really wanted food from there, so we ordered carry out. Not really wanting to eat there, I ended up ordering a sub. The girl who took my order asked if I wanted the meal with fries and a drink. I stupidly decided to do that. My husband gets home with no drink. I called them back and apparently customers are just supposed to know to go into their cooler and grab their own drink. If that is the case, why do they ask you what kind you want when you order? This may seem like not a big deal, but this is the third time in a row my order has been wrong and it’s mediocre food at best. My advice? Take your money elsewhere.

Oh Falbo. How I love thee, let me count the ways…
1. You are quality pizza, every time.
2. You are a great value. I do not mean you are cheap but you are quality without being pricey.
3. You make great thin crust. It is not cracker thin. It is what thin crust should be.
4. You do not get my order wrong.
5. You have great staff, EVERY time.
6. You are easy to get to.
7. You keep your word on when my pizza will be ready.
8. You remind me of home. Just good Chicago pizza.
9. I can get a single topping pizza and be completely happy. They have AH-​MAY-​ZING sausage.
10. You complete me.

My girlfriend had told me how great this place was, so we gave it a try. We ordered a deep dish cheese pizza and a greek salad.
The pizza was phenomenal. Tasty crust, ample cheese, delicious sauce.
The salad was the disappointment. After my girlfriend talking for months about this being her favorite salad, it was a mess. I give points for it being fresh, but there were barely any toppings. The pepperinchi were banana peppers, there was very little feta, etc.
We ordered late so I’m hoping they were just out of ingredients.

Pizza dough was raw. I called the restaurant, manager gave me the 3^rd degree first telling me it should be gummy. Then telling me she would talk to the driver and baker, followed by her telling my to describe the dough and just giving me the third degree. The dough was raw, the top, the bottom, all the way through in the entire middle 5 inches of the pizza. It wasn’t just gummy on the top layer, it was raw. I will not be ordering from here again as the manager offered no solution, was condescending and dismissive.

My first experience with another Falbo Bros. store years ago was not good. The pizza tasted good, but I was sick the whole next day. Because of this, I’ve had an aversion to eating there, but since it’s my boyfriend’s favorite pizza in Madison I decided to give it another try. I’m glad I did!
This time around I went for their Falzone (which is, as you can probably guess, a calzone) filled with chicken and garlic. Some pizza places make you feel ridiculous for having chosen garlic as a topping («No, I’m super pumped I just paid $ 2 for a teaspoon of minced garlic I can’t even taste with the other toppings! Worth it!), but Falbo Bros. used slices and it was definitely present. The chicken was tasty and found in nearly every bite as well.
I also sampled their cheese sticks, and while it was a bit of overkill with the calzone, it was still tasty and I’d keep them in mind if I was ordering a salad or sandwich.
The Monona location seems to be primarily a delivery and takeout operation — we didn’t see anyone dining at dinnertime and the counter is all you can see from the storefront. Our order was ready quickly and traveled home well! I ate the leftovers a couple days later and those also held up after being refrigerated and microwaved.

A very rude young lady just dishonored a coupon by saying that it was pickup only which was never stated on the coupon. Basically told me she didn’t want my business. After being a loyal customer for years I’m done.

I’ve lived in madison for sometime and this place has by far the best pizza. The choice of sauce and cheese they use is amazing. There cheese sticks are one of my favorite.

We decided stop in to have a slice or two. The dining /​waiting area was completely filthy. The floor was covered with a variety of dead bugs and garbage and the two small tables were sticky. I like their food at their other restaurants but will never go back to the Monona location.

The double-​decker Chicago-​style pizza is a winner! The sauce is fabulous and it’s cooked beautifully. Well done!

The pizza is amazing. I love the deep dish stuff. Don’t ever tell me how many calories — but the stuff is amazing.
Tried their salads and those were good too. Typically, I say that most restaurants do one thing really well — however, they do many.