Pizza Shuttle

You know the saying, even bad pizza is pretty good?
Not pizza shuttle. How is something mushy and overcooked at the same time? We ordered the Wisconsin 3 cheese pizza, which was both extremely bland but had a very very strong basil taste in certain bites.
We ordered it as drunk food after a night out on NYE, the delivery driver was really sweet especially for working so late. The cheese curds were fine, but holy moly I have never found a pizza I didn’t like until yesterday.

Yaaas, it is gooooooooooood.
I have a hot tip for everyone: join their email list b/​c they will send you a coupon for a complimentary ‘za on your birthday. I claimed mine and got some wings on the side. Pretty awesome.

Great food, menu and service. Had the Cobb salad and it was excellent

The food is always good but I don’t know, would it be to much to ask if I’m dining in, add my drink on to my meal instead of charging me then offering it for free the next time.!! Clean your dining room.!! I’ve been in on several occasions and COULD NOT find a clean booth! Not a good look!!!

They think that when a black person complains it is to get free food. However, you have to have proper customer service skills and management skills to know when to save a customer relationship. I ordered a bacon cheeseburger and received a bacon hamburger. I advised them I did not any of the food and to pick it up and issue a refund. Apparently they have no ownership and certainly think black people are wasteless moochers. So if you are BLACK, DO NOT SPEND YOUR HARD EARNED MONEY at this establishment.

My favorite place for pizzas and chicken wings. I love love love their wings — hot garlic, hot barbecue and hot buffalo! I would recommend this place to everyone!
A bonus point — it is open late at night :)

Pizza Shuttle is some damn good pizza pie. They are open late, real late. Satisfy any late night munchie craving. Nuff said!

The Panko Fish Fry (cod) was dry and bland. I ordinarily don’t even use tartar sauce, but was glad they sent 3 ramekins of it so that I could salvage the fish somehow. The macaroni and cheese was also bland, tasting worse than Kraft in a box. The baked beans were dry and not very flavorful. The only thing good about any of it was the strawberry malt. Then, they had the nerve to send me a straw slimmer than a pencil. But they did send a spoon, so that was helpful. To top it off, it took an hour for the food to get here, so it was cold on arrival. I’ve never had the pizza or anything else here, but maybe they should stick to that. The menu is out of control and it shows.

Great food! I love the delivery service. I just ordered food for the second day in a row. I’m waiting for my food now. Yesterday I had ordered Mac and cheese pizza, soup and the smoked Gouda poppers… all amazing. I ordered more soup today and ice cream due to me not feeling well. I would definitely order from here again if I came to Milwaukee again!

Have gotten delivery a few times and at best its horribly inconsistent. First time, they got my order right but the pizza wasn’t very hot. Second time instead of Chicago style deep dish I got normal crust. And third time they gave me bread sticks instead of bosco sticks. Pizza itself is pretty mediocre. Granted its incredibly greasy. The inability to add peppers to the build your own pizza is a big downer in my book.
Not a huge fan.

Our Pizza arrived absolutely raw in the middle. We got the Sicilian Square, and the majority of the pizza was uncooked dough. I’ve never been particularly knocked out by Pizza Shuttle food, but my partner insisted we give them another try. Bad decision.
I think he learned his lesson on the Shuttle, and my prior assessments were borne out. Yuck.

Great, greasy pizza. Perfect for late nights or hangovers. I don’t mean greasy in a bad way because I love this pizza, but if you’re not into that then you might not like it. However, if you go there and just buy a slice, it’s usually more bread/​crust and not greasy.
They also have Cedar Crest ice cream which is great! And for just $ 3 or so you get A TON of it! Very tasty!

Dirt cheap food that’s not half bad. Staff I encountered were nice and I found absent at the window straight away. Not a big fan of the crust but the slices are huge! Good stop for a cheap and fast piece of Zza. Parking sucks so try to not drive here.

I asked the first guy at the counter if I could get a single pizza slice with pineapple and green peppers. Just 1 slice, just 2 toppings. I’d pay extra for it if they had to make it separately. Sure, he said, just tell guy#2 next to him and he’ll make it while guy#1 rings us up.
I head 2 feet forward and tell guy#2 what I wanted. «You can’t get that!», he says, seeming annoyed. Confused I order a plain slice. Guy#1 is playing on his phone. Wasn’t he supposed to «ring me up»? Whatevs.
We sit down in the large seating area. The cardboard we are eating is greasy. One of the «cooks» comes out from the back, all dressed in flour, to watch the basketball game that’s on the TV next to us. He’s right next to our table. He isn’t 1 foot away, his apron is touching our table. At first we thought he came out to talk to us. But no, someone misses a jump shot, the cook curses, slams his palms on his apron, then heads back to the kitchen.
I will never return.

F.I.B. from Chicago, came here for a bite late but not too late. Really enjoyed the Pizza, got the one with a lot of meat. I will say it was greasy as hell, I mean there was a puddle of grease on the metal pan. It was kind of disgusting but the pizza was so good. When in Milwaukee, I will definitely be back!
Also someone threw up in the bathroom and I don’t think it was cleaned up that well.
Loved the decorations, just had a cool vibe. Oh and the beer was cheap! Or maybe it cause I am from Chicago so I am used to paying $ 5-​$ 7 for Miller or Bud that it just seemed cheap.
Hope I’m not being a typical F.I.B.

Where else can you order at 5am on Sunday morning after a night on the town !!
Pizza Shuttle to the rescue.
Just got a pepperoni pizza with extra cheese. It was hot when delivered, and tasted very good.
Thank you Pizza Shuttle

The best way to describe pizza shuttle is it is the ramen noodle of pizza. So if you prefer ramen noodles to a nice homemade chicken noodle soup, you actually might like this pizza. After I ate the pesto chicken pizza, I hate the shits for about two days. I possibly would give Pizza Shuttle another try if they upgraded quality of the dough and laid back on the grease.
On a positive note, the delivery driver was cool as hell and our food was delivered incredibly fast.

Oh Pizza Shuttle. The noise from your parking lot keeps me up at night, and I can’t stand a single one of your delivery drivers who speed down the alley like they own they world. The one time I even went inside the service was complete crap. The cashier was rude as can be and the tables were disgusting.
Your pizza tastes like cardboard, but I keep coming back because you are across the street and open late. Sober me hates you, drunk me who is currently snowed in loves you. I just can’t win. At least I get a free slice on my birthday.
I don’t recommend unless you are broke and drunk. Otherwise just about anywhere else has better pizza and better service.

You know when people say «I don’t want to think about how much money I’ve spent at Pizza Shuttle over the years?»
Well, when I say that, I reeeeeeally mean «let’s not think how much money I’ve spent at pizza shuttle over the years.» I probably could’ve bought a new SUV. But Pizza Shuttle is deeply engrained in the lore of the east side here… it somehow worms its way into a zillion stories I have from my two decades in Milwaukee.
A phone call from around 1994:
«Oh wow, when I come up there does pizza hut deliver to the dorms?»
«We don’t have pizza hut, its pizza shuttle up here.»
«Is it any good?»
«No it’s kind of gross but they deliver late.»
Many 20-​something romantic dramas were solved with a girlfriend over an order of their breadsticks during a too long visit to their weird little dining room. Longtime friendships were made at 2:45 am by ordering wings and mozzarella sticks from «the shuttle».
The place serves a little bit of everything (menu is the size of a small newspaper) from pizzas with cashews as toppings, to a lebanese chicken sandwich to funnel cakes. Luckily I’ve whittled my orders down over the years and have sampled way too much of the menu so you don’t have to (unless you want to – and i can’t judge you based on what I’ve ingested from here over the years)
The Good:
Sicilian pizza (any pizza really, esp. if you like it doughy)
Cheeseburgers
Wings (really surprisingly good and many flavors)
Chicken strips with mashed potatoes and gravy
Ice cream
Their brownie sundae
Mozzarella sticks
The Gross/“I can’t believe I waited for delivery of that”:
Sub sandwiches (dry and gross)
Fish fry
Garlic bread
Bosco sticks (dry and gross — possibly a theme here)
Veggie burger (dry)
Any pasta dish (too salty)
You’re hungry, forget to order and its past 4 am on a Friday night? Nap for a few hours… they’ll start delivery again by 10 am on a Saturday.
These days I usually only eat their slices because a.) They’re very filling, cheap (.99 to $ 2), and quick, and b.) because the universe is playing some sort of crazy jedi mind trick on me and planting my 24 hour gym a few steps away from it.
Get a slice… but if you end up ordering some crazy delivery of way more than you can eat at 3 am? It’s a’right…I can’t judge.

Ive been here a few times and for the most part the experience is satisfactory. Parking shouldnt really be an issue since it has its own garage. The food in general is perfect for a college student since its a.) cheap like crazy and b.) is sooo bad for you but it tastes good. Pizza slices are pretty big and are about a dollar. The garlic breadsticks are cheap as well and you get quite a few of them. In my opnion they aren’t that great but are filling nonetheless.
I went earlier in the day and late at night and I must say at night it attracts a rambunctious crowd. Kinda annoying actually but if you dont mind it then go for it. I cant comment on the ice cream or any deserts since I mostly go there for pizza. The waiting time varies: it was a surprisingly long wait for breadsticks but usually the pizza is ready as soon as you order it.
All in all Pizza shuttle is a hit or miss depending on how you feel that day. Its not one of those «you absolutely need to try this» sort of places but its not an entirely bad place for some low cost pizza.