Benny’s Pizza

Horrible customer service. Called and placed an order, they told me it would be ready in 25min. Got there and they claimed to have never gotten my order. Pizza is good but the idiots answering the phones is why I’ll never go back.

I’ve had the pizza from many places here in Milwaukee and I’d have to admit this is my favorite place, the pizza is thin and always has a great amount of toppings, the price is reasonable and I’ve also had the Italian beefs which are equally as good no complains from this picky girl… I’d definitely recommend this place to friends.

It use to be a good pizza place years ago but I would not order from them again. The pizza toppings come from cans and paying over $ 20 for a large pizza with mediocre to below average ingredients is not worth it.
Who ever answers the phone to take the order wants to get you off the phone quick and you will not understand a word say.

The food was actually pretty good, burgers, fried stuff, a thick pan pizza with lots of cheese Chicago style, I used to go to this place to pick up or have food delivered a lot, it’s not far from my house and open late. In an interesting coincidence, I used to order from the Benny’s in Chicago (same owners), when I worked security at Wrigley Field, you can’t imagine how hard it is to have a pizza delivered to Wrigley Field at midnight in December. So, I became a regular customer here in Milwaukee. But one night, I ordered a pizza delivery, and after an hour and a half, I called up to find out where my food was, they said my «credit card was bad.» I told them there was nothing wrong with my card, they must have copied the numbers down incorrectly, they didn’t seem to care that I was a regular customer, didn’t even bother calling me to tell me that the card didn’t go through. The fellow I was complaining to kept on telling me that my credit card was «no good,» which was insulting, he never considered the possibility that the person taking the order got the numbers wrong, it also never occurred to anyone to call me and tell me they weren’t coming. Too frustrating to ever go back.