Miltonian Pizzeria & Wing House

Pizza and wings are great! Salads are average… service is usually really good! I go there a few times a month. The crabby sauce is AMAZING!

The only thing I had there was the pizza. whenever I try a new pizza I always get just plain to get a sense of the true nature of the pizza without other tastes. It pains me to give them a poor review because they are so nice, accommodating, smiling however if I didn’t see them make the pizza I would swear it was frozen. I understand it’s more of a deep dish style but still it was almost raw there was no color on the crust or on the bottom of the pie it was very pale and was just bland in taste again very sorry.

Great food and service! The calzone is great and the sauce served with it is so tasty, the spices are perfect! The staff is so friendly and you can tell they pride themselves on a great customer experience. I have been here several times but tonight was the night I decided to write a review. They are an underrated establishment in Milton! Will definitely be visiting again when I’m in town to see family!

Went there with the family (including a 10 month old and a 2.5 year old). Not too crowded, and the service was great. Personable, bringing things for the kids to play with, and not bothered when the 2.5 year old dropped his 3^rd fork on the ground.
The food: everything was fine. Chicken Cesar Salad: eh, wouldn’t order it again. Nothing wrong but nothing special. It was huge, but it probably should be for $ 11. Pizza: good, especially for the price. It’s deep dish (think Pizza Hut pan not Chicago uno deep dish). Definitely worth getting again. Wings cooked great but didn’t care for the honey BBQ sauce. Would try again with a normal hot sauce. We also had some beers which were priced right: $ 2.95 for coors light and $ 3.50 for a DFH 60min.
Will definitely go back again. The entire bill was $ 40 which seemed like a steal considering we went home with half a pizza and had 4 beers there.

Good, but not great. I can never bring myself to go to the Miltonian on my own. If someone else suggests going there then I won’t complain. The Miltonian benefits the most from it’s location on a busy road that leads to the beach and they are in a good, accessible strip mall. They have a lot of comfort food that is just ok. The prices can be a bit steep considering the rural area but I guess they are trying to attract more townies. They do Italian, wings, subs, and burgers. They’re in so many different areas that they don’t do one thing well. They’re not the best Italian restaurant, wing bar, sub shop, or burger joint in the area. But if everyone in the family wants something different then this would be the place to go. The service is friendly and the food usually comes quickly. Not a bad place but could be better with a retooled menu and more attention to detail.

Being from an Italian family from North Jersey, I can tell you this is terrible «Italian» food. The eggplant is mushy, meatballs taste like hamburgers and the sauce is too sweet. Plus they got my order wrong… Ordered no cheese on my meatball sub and surprise I got cheese. The wings are good… The only saving grace. Zero stars is generous but you have to give at least one

I decided to give the Miltonian a try and I’m glad I did. The meat lover’s pizza was perfect! I wasn’t a fan of the garlic bread, but the cheap Dogfish and attentive service more than made up for it.

Love the Miltonian, food is excellent, service is good! I am a fan of the pizza and wings.

Stopped in for lunch today. We had heard they had great pizza and we were not disappointed. Everything from the crust to the sauce to the pepperoni was spot on. We also had the wings which were covered in a tasty sauce. Our server, Austin, was pleasant and attentive. We will definitely be back again and recommend this place to others.

Let’s preface this post with the fact that I’m from the DC burbs (ie: probably am pretentious) and have traveled far for food. With that being said, this place is legit. I’ve been to one too many podunk small delis and diners that serve absolute trash for food that sometimes I’d rather eat at a Perkins or Denny’s than the «local joint.»
The wings were spot on and the only thing I thought was weird was the fact that they threw in some herbs into the sauce. It was interesting but it didn’t take away from the experience. Not to mention, they were prepped to order and *drumroll* NO BATTER COATING. I hate buffalo /​hot wings that are battered, that’s not how you do it! I tried the «Killer» style hot sauce, which I thought was going to be a tad spicier (would be a «sissy-​style» mild in my book).
The portions are enormous here for salads and pastas so tread carefully. My SO’s pasta dish was easily twice the size of a chain restaurant’s and came with two large hoagie rolls split in half and buttered and herbed as «garlic bread.» I took a bite of my SO’s pasta and it was pretty decent (cannot recall the name). This isn’t «gourmet» by any means but it hits the spot. Pizza looked pretty decent too but we did not partake. I got the chicken caesar along with my wings and it was enormous and they certainly didn’t skimp on the chicken. The only qualm I had about it was that it comes to you pre-​dressed and the lettuce was a little warm (I like cool crispy lettuce esp. coming from a day at the beach.) That’s my bad for assuming dressing would be on the side. The coffee was excellent too.

We have been to Miltonian Pizza a few times for dine in. One time we ordered pizza and another time we ordered entrees.
The pizza is deep dish style, not at all like a New Jersey pizza. It was good and everyone liked it.
The night we had entrees, someone had the chicken parm, another had a fried shrimp platter and I had scallops and shrimp with angel hair.
The chicken pram was good. The fried shrimp was too deeply fried and salty and my scallops and shrimp were small and the angel hair was overlooked.
They offer wine for only $ 5 (or $ 6?) a glass. However they don’t have any Chardonnay on the menu. I was puzzled as to why this restaurant does not serve Chardonnay. That’s my favorite wine.
But all in all we like the casual atmosphere and the staff is always so friendly. Bottom line-​stick to the pizza and you will be happy.

Stumbled upon this place on the way back from the beach. We were sitting in traffic and didn’t want to deal with crowds. So, I turned off ‘highways’ and ‘toll roads’ on my GPS, let it recalculated and started taking the two-​hour longer back road home, just to get off Route 113. Within 10 minutes we saw The Miltonian — the only open tenant in the shopping center (It was a Sunday evening).
No joke, this is some of the best pasta I’ve ever had. Seriously. The prices are unbelievable in every which way, as well.
The place was half empty and you would never of guessed the food would be so good based on it’s location and appearance — random little restaurant in the middle of a rundown shopping center with a generic sign.
Also, $ 2.75 mugs of Dogfish?! I know Dogfish is brewed down the road but you won’t find those kind of prices anywhere.
The menu is not extensive. This is not a 5-​star review in the regards that they have a wild craft beer scene and eclectic selection of authentic Italian cuisine. It’s a hidden gem, off the beaten path of two major highways, with superb pasta and four different choices of beer: Coors, Bud, Miller-​garbage and Dogfish. All for the same price. My girlfriend and I make a point to come here now as often as possible.

We accidentally stopped by this place on the way back from the beach… little do we know this place has the best pizza EVER!

Saturday at 7. Not full. Service was fair at best. Pizza was not good. Frozen better. Wings has a funky almost curry taste. Yuck. Mugs are puny. Salad was 20% of the size of the bowl. Basically; although not expensive, a waste of money.

Ate here last Friday. Still the best local pizza! The owner is on an extended family visit to Greece, but the staff have been careful to carry on the warm and family friendly traditions and service attitude she and her nephew have instilled. We enjoy the pasta dishes and fresh salads – missing lasagna that only Eve makes, though and hope she comes back soon!

The pizza, sandwiches and standard Italian dishes on their menu aren’t bad, but the one thing that always keeps me coming back are the excellent wings. They’re always served hot and crispy and the sauce… it’s so addicting that I like to call «crack» sauce! It’s the best wing sauce I’ve ever had! Tangy, and thick with lots of herbs and spices. I even order extra sauce on the side for dipping the wings and french fries in! If you ever stop in, do yourself a favor and order at least a dozen of these babies!

As a New Yorker I found this to be pretty basic without surprises. Pizza is pretty good, but nothing fancy. Salad is very boring, yet typical. Beers on tap are welcomed. Atmosphere is really fun with very nice and professional wait staff and friendly patrons. Video games in the back keep kids occupied while dad can drink his beer.
Very friendly!

3.5 stars…
I’ll try not to be too harsh in my judgement of a suburban Delaware pizza and wing restaurant when I’m a New Yorker who loves both those things. Given the area it’s really quite good pizza and wings, nothing amazing and if it was in NY I’d probably give them 2 stars but I was generally pleased. The crust was not too thick or thin and the sauce was sweet and went well with the slightly crispy pepperoni slices. The wings are available in a number of sauces and though the BBQ was just goopy sweet BBQ sauce the wings were a good size. The service was pleasant and attentive, the low key atmosphere was spacious and clean, and the prices were good.

Most excellent salads, pizza, and wings. Service is fantastic. The grape leaf wrap is to die for. Only complaint is the tables are sticky. otherwise, very clean and reasonably priced

There is pretty much nothing more you would ask for from a small pizzeria in a coastal hinterland than this — except maybe a bit more bacon in the bacon and pineapple pizza. Amazingly I had some left over fried bacon at home and had thought to bring it with me for precisely this eventuality. I chose not to follow my fearful instincts … and well — they should have just at least doubled the bacon on that pizza!
The crust on the pizzas is way way above average — and the prices here are awesome — we were 9 people and 3 large pizzas would be more than enough — $ 45 plus drinks.
We will definitely be back — maybe bearing bacon reserves.