A-1 Pizza and Subs

I still love this place. The food is delish & the delivery is so fast and awesome. I love my 2 delivery people. Unfortunately I’m terrible with names but it’s either an awesome cute Asian dude or an awesome hip & cute chick that normally delivers & they makes A-​1 well worth ordering from. Thank you guys !! (It’s your every Fri night couple in Millersville… Lol)

I’m only giving this restaurant 2 stars because I never actually had the chance to eat there. We placed a delivery order online and everything went through fine. They accepted our payment and told us they would be notifying us soon of an estimated time of delivery. Well 15 mins later some guy from the sub shop calls and says that they don’t deliver to my house, it’s just too far. Too far? According to map quest it’s less than 5 miles away and we share the same zip code. Anyway when I told him to just refund the money he said he couldn’t and I had to call a company they deal with… I called the number they gave me and after getting the run around for two days I finally got an email saying my refund has been issued but it could take up to 10 days. What? The whole experience was ridiculous. If you don’t want to deliver don’t offer it. I won’t be going there anytime soon.

We have been looking for a new sub place since we just moved to the area. We chose A-​1 based on the reviews, and I have to say, I am disappointed.
We ordered the 2 sub special. When I called, right off the bat the guy was rushy-​rushy, but I had questions. I asked what came on the mushroom cheesesteak, because typically a restaurant has «standard toppings» for each sandwich and you can pick extras or ask for something to be taken off, well he snarkily answered «whatever you want»… Duh, Guy. Of course I can get what ever I want on it, but what do YOU normally put on it when someone asks for it? The whole rest of the conversation was rushed.
The food came and it was pretty bland. Although the side of gravy I ordered was pretty tasty. The Greek salad I ordered was way overpriced ($ 8.99) and instead of crumbled feta, it was a huge square of it with seasoning on top. No olives. No onions. But two thick slices of green pepper.
We’re not ordering here again, especially with the terrible customer service.

We ordered here before but I couldn’t remember if I liked them or not. I ordered delivery anyway so I didn’t have to go out in the rain with my toddler.
We got a pizza and some wings. The pizza had a ridiculous amount of cheese and very little sauce. And the wings didn’t have any sauce and were pretty tasteless.
Quite disappointed.

The food was pretty good but it took over an hour for me to receive the food and I live less then 5 min away (don’t have my car so couldn’t pick it up) when I called to ask what was going on she said she was waiting on the delivery guy I called again still waiting. He finally shows up and my fries where kinda warm and I had stiff cheese on my pizza. Then the delivery guy had the nerve to ask how much change I wanted… I want it all

It was rainy and we weren’t in the mood to grill again so we opted for pizza. The previous reviews didn’t seem bad and they had really good specials. We bought two XL pizzas with two toppings for $ 21. Great price! Unfortunately it was bad. The pizza was awful. We barely had sauce on the pizza so it tasted dry. It was loaded with cheese, too much cheese. We’re not big fans on ordering chain pizza but Domino’s blows this restaurant out of the water. We won’t be returning. Go somewhere else if you want a satisfactory meal.

our favorite local pizza and wings place! love their specialty pizzas!

Excellent pizzas made locally by a non-​corporate company. Food is decently priced, and they always have sales. They usually have a pick up special for an XL 2 topping pizza for $ 10.99. Their subs are good and wait time is small. Check them out!

I will never order anything from these ignorant disgracful ingrates. You order your meal and tell them how you want your food and they bring you dark fries from old cooking oil you call back to complain they claim we will send fresh fries the driver lies and says he came to your house no one answers when i no thats a lie because you were out there waiting. Then you call back and complain to get your money back they say its no refund so i got a cold sandwich and no fries. But you got my money though, how about i call the better business bureau. Also im call my bank

I’m quite disappointed to be giving this location such a low review.
I had just moved to the neighborhood in October and decided to finally try this place in December. I had gotten a sandwich and loved it. Though the tahini on it was quite bitter it was still good overall. I even went and got the sandwich again just omitted the tahini.
A few weeks ago I got a large Taco pizza and a Greek salad. I LOVED it! So good and cheesy and had so many tortilla chips on it and the Greek salad was also quite good. A lot of feta cheese included in it.
Tonight I finally convinced my boyfriend to try something other than his go-​to pizza place and to order with me from A-​1.
I got the Taco pizza again. He ordered the large carry out special with two toppings for 9.99. (which is a great deal)
Tonight must have been the wrong night to order (I hope). My pizza, instead of having tortilla chips like the menu states, was covered in regular potato chips. Which had become burned from cooking the pizza. Leaving a very burnt taste to the majority of the pizza.
His pizza was barely cooked and was extra doughy and stuck to the box. Leaving a slice useless.
I called to just let them know of my disappointment. Not really expecting anything in return just wanted to let them know to be more diligent when it comes to following instructions. Ya know, like you should at your job.
I wasn’t received well and that’s just that I guess.
Oh well. I may try them again but will probably wait awhile.

Love this place. Local and the food is great. I am a fan of the shrimp chicken cheese steak. They make it perfect! The only thing I would change is the bread if they had better bread I would eat there more often. Other than that I usually get the best service when I go there and order versus over the phone which is not bad for me because I live close by. The pizza and wings are great too! Try them out they are pretty nice people!

Not to shabby, the interior is pretty typical privately own pizza place style. But the food is quite good! The last few times we got pizza it was spot on and they delivered fast. Went in to get a pick up order and the woman at the front desk was friendly and chatted with us while our order was being made.
Everything came out great.
Worst part about the whole thing was having to wait to get home to eat it!!!

We found A-​1 Pizza while moving my Mom into her new house & haven’t ordered out for pizza since. There’s booths to sit @ but it’s really carry-​out décor. We’ve only had their pizzas & salads but the food is always good. The staff is always busy & though we always order to feed a crowd, we’ve never had an order mix-​up

I used to like it, but the last few times it’s been bland. The prices are good but I usually get waited on by someone with major sass. The food is decent enough to go back, the attitudes make me want to go somewhere with courteous employees.

These guys are the best. They are fast and friendly. The owner also isnt scared to get his hands dirty and work. The food is good and consistsnt. Thank you for being an area staple. But they need to clean up the front area a little. Looks like i might catch the flu on those tables. All in all good :)

Stopped in for a quick bite. Has a toasted tuna sub. It was excellent and enough for two people. Great prices, too. Will be back for more.

Love this place! Right up the street from our house, delicious pizza that’s very cheesy, nice staff, cheap prices!

Nothing remarkable about this place. It is a hole in the wall not sure if I would dine in there. I got the cheesesteak which was good and I got my son the grilled cheese. I would go again.

A-​1 is good pizza and damn good wings. I’ve been happy each time I’ve ordered here. It’s not super authentic Italian and it’s not specialty, but it’s good pizza. Try A-​1, you will not be disappointed!

Another one bites the dust. The pizza I ordered was XL for $ 8.50, wow, that’s a good deal. A-​1 pizza is good, however, I specifically instructed I only want cheese, NO TOMATO SAUCE. I guess they can’t make a wihite pizza for that price or they don’t listen to customers. Well, what can we say about pizza? Expect something different and special? No, not really. I’m still breath taken away by Uno Chicago”s deep dish cheese pizza. A-​1 is okay because it’s just regular, but for that price, helluva, you can feed your family in 1 hour or just yourself for 3 days.