Coney Island Cafe

The service was good. Very friendly wait staff, however… I paid $ 6.80 for a «breakfast wrap» and a cup of coffee. It was basically a bunch of bread sprinkled with a little bit a little bit of cheese and a little bit of sausage.

DO NOT EAT HERE. It’s the dirtiest place in the scum of Middletown, NY. I literally threw up when I walked into the bathroom.

It’s confusing for a first timer… I wasn’t too sure if I should sit or order at the counter. I did both, but it seems if you’re here to stay, you’ll get table service! I wasn’t the only one to make this mistake upon walking in.
The hospitality here is excellent. The cozy kitchy feeling reminds me of mom and pop places.
I ordered a buffalo chicken wrap with some changes. I personally was satisfied with just half the wrap, but I’m sure I could have eaten the whole thing on a hungry day!
I also had the sweet potato fries. I only wish they served them with sauce, which I asked for and they gladly brought.
Overall I was pleased, and will be back to try some sweets!

Good dogs (not great) good service. nice place in a sketchy area. good value with free wifi.

Diner food at GREAT prices. Atmosphere okay. I usually pick something up for take out. Great breakfast deal coffee and sandwich under $ 3. Can’t beat that!

This place has taken a nose dive hard recently. I don’t know what happened but it’s a not a pleasant experience any longer. The service is now spotty and inattentive. The person behind the counter used to be a friendly young woman and it’s now a strung out, irritated young man. The desserts have all but disappeared. I’ve been 3 times in the past 2 months, and I won’t be back.

Hot dogs: good, but make sure to request beef, or they’ll give you pork hot dogs
Fries: good
Burger: decent
Cincinnait chili, served on pasta with cheese and onions — great!
Desserts: excellent! I’ve had the cannoli cheesecake and the pumpkin tart, both good, but the cheesecake was the best!
Service: friendly, but a little lax
Major con: My sister went to use the bathroom and said it was really gross, and in major need of renovations :(
I haven’t had the breakfast, but co-​workers have, and say that they’re very good.

I went here about a year ago in the summertime and I just kept forgetting to write this review, but here it is. I was stranded at the Middletown Coach USA bus stop because the bus broke down and we weren’t able to get back on the road for eight (yes, eight) hours and it was scorching hot out.
The only food vendor in walking distance was Coney Island Café, so I decided to stop in and have a grilled chicken wrap with their potato chips. I give the food two stars because the chips were soggy and the wrap was poorly made. The price was also very expensive from what I could remember for not only the location (pretty much in the middle of nowhere) and for the lack of quality.
Since my bus was not for another seven hours or so, I decided to order a drink and just hang out there and read a book to kill some time. I had not been planning to stay there for all eight hours, but I did want to just relax in an air conditioned place after eating my meal. After about a half hour of my meal being completed, one of the counter girls scolded me that I «can’t sit there anymore because people are coming in for lunch so you have to leave.» I was in utter shock, so I just got up and left and walked back out in the summer heat. Keep in mind, there is NOTHING else around besides the bus station, at least in safe walking distance anyway.
The funny part about this was that once lunchtime hit, the table I had been sitting at was still open, along with 10 other tables that I could have sat at. Guess she was overestimating how many patrons would be arriving at lunchtime. Needless to say, I probably won’t be in Middletown, NY anytime soon, but for those who are in the area, I certainly do not recommend this place.

Great food, great value, amazing service!

Went here again with the family. Everything we ordered was great.
Chili dogs all the way– can’t go wrong. The dessert was like a 5 star restaurant but affordable and presented beautifully. Since the owner is a chef, even typical wraps and sandwiches are ahead of the competition.
Don’t let the bus station fool you, make this place one of your regular stops.