Smart Cow Yogurt Bar

Outstanding! As a Yogurt Bar aficionado, I’m happy to say this one is the perfect spot to indulge. They offer flavors that are creative yet approachable, and the selection of toppings is «TOP notch»! Oh, and, THEY HAVE MARSHMALLOW SAUCE!
They offer a rewards program that is simple to use, and a free 4 oz. serving for downloading their app.
The staff members were friendly and the place was clean, even with a steady stream of customers on a Saturday night.
It can be a little hard to spot from the road and to make your way through the parking lot maze to get there, but it’s totally worth it. Best ice cream option in the Falls.

They have a good variety of flavors and a lot of toppings, I would like to have a «plain» flavor because the vanilla (don’t remember complete name) yogurt was very sweet and sometimes you just want the plain flavor plus toppings. Is a cute place, clean, staff friendly. I would return soon.

So many flavors! Crazy amount of topping choices! Always clean, staff is always friendly. Love the chalkboard tables and patio. Pup treats are adorable. Best part is donating back to the community!!!

I could eat tubs and tubs of this yogurt. It is just delicious and there is such a great selection of toppings. Ive been to a few different froyo places and this is my favorite. The manager was really helpful and nice. She liked my cup of frozen yogurt so much she took a picture of me with my girlfriend for facebook. Cool place in a cool town. Definitely recommend it for its price and taste. Oh and theyve donated thousands for the local schools. Branching out to other locations I will continue to support them!

Love it here! They always have a great verity of flavor and the toppings bar is vast! From other places around here this one is the best! Prices are a little high but they’re no different from everyone else pause I like being able to bring something home for my pooch too!

Best froyo place yet! The setting is perfect for the young and young at heart. Chalkboard tables are set throughout next to modern seating.
They have a vast variety of flavors — both standard and limited, holiday flavors. Not only do they have for oxen yogurt but also gelato.
I have been to many froyo places in Wauwatosa, Milwaukee and cities within Washington county. This is the best place yet.

Love this place! They have a great variety of flavors and they change them fairly often too. I find myself stopping in just to see what’s new (the S’mores flavor is great)! Also, we’ve brought our dog to their outdoor patio several times. It’s nice that they sell frozen dog treats at a reasonable price. Clean place and friendly staff!

Best yogurt in Milwaukee! I’m a froyo snob and have been to my fair share of places all over the US. This one is clean, has great service, and offers great flavors of creamy yogurt. Good prices and even 20% off for teachers and military with a valid I.d. Definitely stop by here– you’ll want to come back! Love that they support local schools too!

Delicious! Great flavors and great staff!

I love this Fro-​yo shop, I have been to almost everyone in the Milwaukee area and this is hands down the best. They have great flavors, toppings, it is clean, they have trivia to play while you eat, and they even give back to the area schools. Their customer service is amazing! My daughter left her hat their and the lady working there called me too let me know. Thankfully I am a rewards member and she had my number on my receipt. I can not say enough good things about this place and their company values. Plus the frozen yogurt is creamy, just the way I like it. I try to stop in at least twice a week.

Finally! A frozen yogurt store. With 16 flavors of frozen yogurt and more serve-​yourself toppings than you could possibly count, you can make your own «flavor of the day» every day. The best part, no waiting with a number at a table. You make your own original frozen yogurt masterpiece with toppings and dig in as soon as you make it.
Menomonee Falls has more frozen custard locations than I can count (some good — some not so good). We had been going to a store like Smart Cow Frozen Yogurt Bar downtown in the 3^rd Ward. Now we only have to drive 1 mile for a great dessert!
I came in with my 2 teenage sons after school to try the frozen yogurt and «buy local.» We will definitely be back. The store is immaculately clean, and well staffed. The owner was out and talking to customers. We were there at about 3pm and the store was full of everyone from local kids on their way home from school, to college age girls, families and some more elderly couples. There are great tables for the kids that have chalkboard tops and chalk sticks in the middle to draw. There is also a «patio» area that faces Appleton. I assume that will get some use this next summer.
We had 16 flavors to choose from, and you can mix and match. There are small tasting containers if you want to try a small sample. There were some sorbets, white chocolate mousse, triple chocolate, red velvet cupcake, cookies and cream, cheesecake and others. There was even a no sugar added flavor. The frozen yogurt is sold by the ounce and is self serve.
After we created our mix and match frozen yogurt flavors, there were toppings consisting of every manner of cereal, crushed candy bars, nuts, cookie dough, oreos, fresh fruits, and glazes and sauces at the end to cover it all. There were also «to go» containers of frozen yogurt available.
We WILL be back — probably more often than we should :0)
ps: Ask for the loyalty card.