Tony’s Pizza

I’m so happy that I had the opportunity to eat the pizza while I was visiting from Chicago. Chicago is known for their pizza just like NY. Amazing! I had the chicken bacon ranch pizza! MUST HAVE!

Very expensive for sub standard food. The pizza was just okay, garlic wings just sitting in a pool of oil and still flavorless, and the seafood bisque was like nothing I’ve ever seen/​tasted before, the absolute worst — loose consistency, no thickness the way a bisque should be, grizzly seafood pieces, and absolutely flavorless. The only redemption was the cheese knots, but not worth $ 5 for 6.

I’ve been coming here for over 10 years, consistently the best chicken parmesan hero anywhere around. Super friendly owner and staff. Also the pan slices are awesome. For me consistency is key and Tony’s delivers on that. Great job guys.

I have been going here for years. The staff is very friendly and the food is great. My favorite pizza place on Long Island by far!

Was in the area and oh yes again I needed pizza.
Decided to try Tonys, Had 2 slices sicilian.
The service was excellent, And the staff friendly and helpful.
The pizza was just ok, Nothing to write home about.

Not a great pizza spot pizza is terrible glad I order some garlic knots the sauce was okay. Store looked like it needed to be swept. Employees seem to have an attitude or just doesn’t care. Good thing this isn’t my normal pizza spot cause never again.

My wife and I have been using Tony’s Pizza for years now for all of our family parties. The food is excellent, portions are plentiful, the price is right and the quality is great.
Luigi is so accommodating and helps me create a great menu every time. He even created simple catering packages that help me easily order based on my party size.
Nothing like home style Italian cooking! (especially when I don’t have to cook it)
Looking forward to the next party!

We recently ordered pickup from Tony’s and I am seriously disappointed. We ordered one white pie and one pepperoni, when we went and picked it up they have us the wrong order. When we got home and realized the error we called and the girl on the phone was rude and told us if we wanted a new pizza we would have to return the wrong pizza and pick up a new one. But we would have to wait 20 minutes for them to make a new one. We did that and when we went to pick up they new one they were short with us and even charged us extra to get a speciality pie. I asked to speak with a manager and they told me nobody was there and I would have to call back a different day. By the time the pizza swap was over I had one white pizza I overpaid for and one cold pepperoni pizza (took an hour total to get things sorted out).
The actual pizza is okay, nothing amazing, but this place is closest to my house. Fortunately there are 10 other pizza places on 112 and I will definitely be making the switch. It’s a shame that some rude and inexperienced employees are going to cost Tony his customers.

This place has really gone downhill. We have been ordering delivery from Tony’s since my fiancé and I moved into the area three years ago and up until recently had really enjoyed it. However, the last 4 times have changed that. Each time we ordered a side of sauce with our dozen garlic knots they’ve charged us for it and forgotten it. Even though I was a little mortified by doing it (I’m not much of a complainer but garlic knots without sauce are useless to me) I actually brought it up before hand saying, «Hey, no worries or anything but please remember the sauce, the last three times we’ve ordered it you guys forgot it.» The person taking my order laughed a little said he was sorry and then added, as if he were noting it on the order «Remember the sauce.»
They forgot the sauce.
To be fair, I called and complained and they did offer me a free dozen knots next time but I informed them that there wouldn’t be a next time. It’s a shame what’s happened to this place. Good thing there’s at least a dozen other pizza places on or around 112. I would suggest you go there. Even their far superior sister store La Mahgarita just a few miles away.

This is one of my weekly regular eateries. Very friendly staff! Food is typical pizzeria takeout quality. Good but nothing special. I personally haven’t found any better in this area.

We go to Tony’s once a week, they know my husband by name when he picks up the pizza. Pizza and garlic knots are good, my husband also likes the wings. I am not a fan of super thin crust and their crust is a little bit thicker so that is one reason why we come here so often.

Love this place! Delicious food and fast friendly service! My husband and I ate here 4 times during our two week vacation in Long Island. We even requested a frozen pizza to take home to DC with us:)

I must say. I love the pizza from Tony’s he has the best pizza on long island.
The Thin crust slice with lots of cheese and it melts in your mouth. yummy !!
The staff is very nice and clean and always friendly.

Tony’s Pizza has some really good food. Very good specialty pizzas and some tasty food coming out of the kitchen!

The people behind the counter give me an attitude everytime I go there and the pizza is sub par at best. The last time I went there the guy gave me the wrong slice and it was burnt. That’s the last time I’ll go there.

Very disappointed. I have been here before and never had a problem, but tonight I ordered meatball heroes to go. When I got home and opened one, the bread was totally burned. You do NOT use a burned roll for a customer’s meatball hero, that is so wrong. I will not return to this place!

This part of Long Island is full of good pizza, but Tony’s is worth a stop. All the usual stuff is top notch, and the white pie is sublime, although perhaps better enjoyed with knife & fork. I really enjoy the multi-​layer stuffed pies, where a single slice is a meal. The chicken Parm sandwich is also worth a couple minutes for them to batch it up fresh.

Another 3-​star, A-​OK, pizza place.
Slices here are generally pretty good, although I think they’re smaller than the slices at nearby joints. There’s always beer in the soda cooler, a sports game on the LCD TV, and the guy behind the counter is always so freakin friendly.
I think it’s owned by the same people that own La Margherita in Medford. There are coupons on the La Margherita website that can be used at Tony’s Pizza.