Berry Creamy Frozen Yogurt

This is a liquor store now. Consumer Square Liquors in fact. There’s a bar in there, but no froyo.

Shop décor is not the most appealing ive seen but the flavor& consistency of this yogurt was by far the best ive ever tasted-​and i have tasted froyo from any&every shop i pass. The strawberries i used as my topping were not only fresh (5 mins till closing!) but they were so sweet! Took my 4 kids& we were all raving!!!

I go there for the dark chocolate. They moved the vanilla flavor to another port so I can’t make a «twist» of chocolate and vanilla. ‘makes no sense to move vanilla away from chocolate. Their hours are very limited. ‘showed up last Sunday while it was still close to 80 degrees and they were closed at 8 p.m. Were supposed to be open until 9 p.m. (God forbid!). And I rarely see advertising or coupons. Someone needs to review their marketing plan and their hours of operation.

Now that I’m heading back to the shore on the weekends it’s time to visit my favorite froyo place. I can always count on Berry Creamy having fresh toppings and a friendly atmosphere. Now that froyo shops are popping up everywhere I appreciate the quality of Berry Creamy even more. Unlike other yogo factories, Berry Creamy is always clean and their employees are always friendly when I walk in the door. Even better is that they just started using Spot On! Now you don’t need to carry a rewards card, you can just store it on your smart phone!

Good, but not great. Vanilla was «airy» and tasted slightly artificial. Milk chocolate was good. Strawberry was very good. Poor selection of fresh fruit. Friendly staff.

I read on their website that they are a family-​owned business, and as everyone knows, there is no bigger proponent of small businessowners than myself. That being said, Berry Creamy could definitely use a little tweaking.
While offering an abundance of flavors, it was pointed out to me by one of the employees that only three are homemade. This was, sadly, very evident upon my tasting my combination of Red Velvet (you knew that was coming) and NY Cheesecake. Both flavors tasted exactly the same. I was hopeful for some tart, cheesey flavor in the cheesecake, but there was none to be found. The red velvet just tasted like sugar. There’s more competition now for you guys; you’re going to need to step it up a little with the flavor profiles and offer more, if not all, homemade flavors. They do offer waffle bowls, which was a novel and interesting touch.
There weren’t nearly enough toppings. Also, the pieces of cheesecake and cookie dough were way too big to be manageable. Smaller cuts of toppings are much more conducive to frozen yogurt. A lot of the toppings were also in desperate need of a refill.
I’m not sure of the price per ounce, but it seemed to be a little less expensive than other places I’ve been. The cashier did provide me with a punch card and filled me in on their rewards program.
I can’t lie, it was a little (ok, a lot) creepy that the employees all appeared to be at least my age. There’s something disconcerting about a 25 year old in a pale-​blue-​and-​white frozen yogurt shop sticking a spoon in my candy-​covered sweet treat. In my opinion, this type of work is better suited for a younger set.
The shop was very clean and I was greeted upon entrance and exit, which is always pleasant. However, with my favorite frozen yogurt shop right around the corner, I can’t say there was anything that would compel me to come back.