Jersey Mike’s Subs

This is one of our favorite lunch spots in Mayfield. Quick and tasty sandwiches with quality ingredients. Store is clean and well-​maintained.
Always a hit!

Jersey mike’s is a better than average sub shop. In a world full of sub options I find myself regularly coming back to Jersey mike’s because of the fantastic roast beef! The roast beef is cooked up on site at each location and you can taste the difference! This is definitely some of the best roast beef around!
Simple, easy, fresh high quality ingredients make this a goto sub shop for anyone looking for a quick meal.
Also, this location specifically is always clean and the workers will always smile and are willing to make any substitution you might want!

Very surprised to see how clean this place!
Food is always great at many locations but I must say very impressed with the cleanliness here.

Jersey Mike’s is just your standard sub shop. I wouldn’t say it’s anything more impressive than Subway. However, the Mike’s sauce that it comes with is delicious! I got the sauce on the side and enjoyed dipping my Italian sub in it.

Mayfield is not lacking when it comes to sub shops. Lots of options. I love a good sandwich so I decided to try out Jersey Mikes. I never heard of them before and I didn’t know what to expect.
I walked in and it was clean and bright with 3 people behind the counter. They have a clean dining area. Mike (THE Mike?) greeted me and took my order, a Sub Club Mike’s Way. He put the meats on a bun and then passed the sandwich to another worker who finished the sandwich and asked me if I wanted it Mikes Way. (Of course) Mike then stepped down to the register and rung me up for $ 7. The third worker had their back to the counter.
The service seemed rushed, yet they weren’t busy and workers didn’t look happy to be there.
When I got home I found they made the wrong sandwich?! Instead of a Club, they left out the bacon and mayo. It was just a dry turkey sub.
I checked the receipt and it said Sub Club. Yep, they screwed it up.
Otherwise, the sandwich was really nothing special and not very big for $ 7. Subway is better and cheaper. If you order it «Mike’s Way» as I did, it will have way too many onions, a little lettuce, tomato, herbs, oil & vinegar. There were more onions than lettuce!
I understand that mistakes happen and I really hope they do better, because with all the other sub shops in town they won’t be around very long with the service I received.
In the same plaza there are 2 other places with great subs, one right next door.
If you want a real sandwich go check out the Dynamic Duo north by SOM on Rt6. Incredibly delicious and cheap.