Gaetano’s Steaks & Subs of Marlton

It was okay. Chicken philly was overcooked and didnt have much flavor. Regular philly was pretty good, but nothing that i would write home to mom about.

Well I have to admit it was big, but who ever compares this steak to Philly has obviously never been to Philly !! The meat had a strong flavor and was chopped. The roll had seeds, of which do not belong anywhere near a steak sandwich. I would not recommend this steak. Take the extra time and drive to Philly if you want a good steak

If you ever wanted to try a premium cheese steak here is where you go. This is my go to place for cheese steaks. Every time I bring them home the family raves about em! Nice wide soft rolls (the sesame seeds make them), loaded with steak, cheese and whatever else you could desire.
I see they also have cheese burger hoagies and will have to try them and update this post once I do.
Great service, quick and friendly.

This review is ONLY for their cheesesteaks. I had their wings but they were nothing to write about. However, my lunch buddies had the steak sandwiches and I’ll never go anywhere else for them. The portions are HUGE. The meat is tasty and well seasoned. My mom only cares about the meat and flavor. I go for the off-​the-​cuff like chicken cheesesteak with mushrooms, bacon, fried onions, honey mustard sauce on a garlic roll. This place made both of us happy.

Wings were horrible. They were soggy and my husband and I both think they were frozen. The blue cheese is homemade and good, but what’s the point if the wings are inedible (we actually through them away).

Great cheesesteaks!!! Always delivered nice and hot! Quick too. Seeded rolls so but still great. Best cheesesteak without crossing the bridge!

Huge hoagies and sandwiches! I had the italian and the cheesesteak. I ordered both the «small,» which was 11′ inches. Width wise, it was bigger than most other places. I could only eat half of the «small» hoagie. The bread was very good on both hoagies.
The italian hoagie had lots of meats and cheeses. They are plentiful with the lettuce and tomato toppings. For the cheesesteak, I enjoyed the sesame bread used. Again, there was plenty of meat and cheese. Oh and I had a side order of cheese fries that was enough for 3 people sharing.
I would definitely order from here again.

A little hard to see, because it’s off the main road, but definitely worth the stop! We stopped here on a long road trip because we were craving cheesesteaks, and even though they were closing in 40 min, they accommodated us and extremely nice about it.
The food was also very filling (we got the cheesesteak and curly fries) and the good. Wasn’t the best cheesesteak I’ve ever had, because I’ve tried a lot places in and around Philly, but it was definitely among the best!

Had the philly cheesesteak. Really good, but could only eat a 3^rd of the small. They have a mini size, I would recommend that for most women. They actually delivered it straight to my hotel room. They were very nice and friendly. I thought it was a little pricey untill I saw the size. You get a ton of food.

Great sandwich place. They are well known for their steaks. I had the American sub it was great. I got a small, it’s not its huge! But delicious. They also were so friendly and helpful. They did mention the chicken salad is fresh made and a food item too. Go here!

Pretty darn good for a cheesesteak in Jersey. I have had better but it definitely hit the spot. The service was good as well.

philly style cheese steaks and the best wings hands down

The last couple visits have been really disappointing, i called for delivery and ordered a very simple order. 2 hoagies, lettuce, tomato and onion on both. It should have been a signal when he asked me 3x about my order. The order arrived within the time stated but they forgot to add tomato, lettuce and onion. And it was like they poured an entire bottle of oregano. It was obvious they really rushed the order.
I called and they offered to bring the lettuce, tomato and onion. So over an hour later, we were eating. But it just isn’t the same quality, I didn’t even complain about the oregano. Unfortunately I could tell they just didn’t care.
We won’t be ordering there again.

I’ve grown up on Gaetano’s in other areas of Jersey and have loved it. Unfortunately, while Gaetano’s Marlton is decent, I really can’t recommend them unless you have no other options.
A number of times we’ve gotten the food there it has been undercooked. One time my wife got a chicken wrap from them and the chicken was only partially cooked, and just this week I ordered fries from there and some were barely cooked at all — one time it felt like I was biting into an uncooked potato.
Their actual cheesesteaks are good, but other than that don’t expect anything stellar. That being said, they «get it» that it’s the bread that makes the cheesesteak, and they shine in this area.
I really, really, really want to give these guys a better rating, but until they get their cooking processes in order I don’t feel like I can.

Great cheesesteaks! The 17″ is great. Love their toasted rolls. Highly recommend!
Definitely coming back soon!
This location is the best.

Delicious cheesesteaks!!!

For a cheesesteak/​hoagie restaurant, Im giving it a 4star rating. They have the best cheesesteaks around! and great hoagies too. I have a Gaetanos right across the street from me and drive 15min to come to this Gaetanos! That should tell you something…

Ordered from here after the other two cheesesteak places we went to were closed. I’m only giving this place an extra star because the cheesesteaks are good, not great, and the staff is friendly. I almost threw up when I saw that the «minis» are the size of regular cheesesteaks and the 2 larges (that me and my girlfriend ordered) were not only 17″ but also $ 16 each. 3 cheesesteaks, cheesefries and two sodas came to $ 50, can’t exactly refuse or return said items when they come out but that is not cool, at all. You have got to be kidding me.
You need to revamp your naming system, unless the average guest is 400 lbs. I’m 6 foot 250 pounds and I would have only needed the mini. We were not looking at a menu when we ordered, and I feel the person on the phone should have said something when my girlfriend mentioned «for the two of us». I feel absolutely cheated, and will never be coming back. I would have never ordered $ 40 worth of cheesesteaks for me, and my much smaller girlfriend and little sister.

The best Cheesesteaks!!! As a transplant from South Jersey to NC, I make sure to take the trip up there at least twice a year and always have to get a Gaetano’s Cheesesteak. I even had someone bring me down Cheesesteaks and Gaetano’s separated everything for them so it wouldn’t go bad. Even told them the best way to heat everything up and put it together!!!

I have had cheesesteaks in several cities (including an excellent one in California of all places) and the one I had at Gaetano’s today is in the top three! The bread was super fresh and the crust had the perfect crunch. The meat was premium quality, very tender and the onions were perfectly translucent and very sweet. I’m only here for a week, but I’m sure to go back at least twice to try the Don and get my fill of another cheesesteak because nothing like this is available back in Seattle.