Macedon Hills Restaurant

Wouldn’t even give this place a star. It was disgusting and extremely disappointing. They served our food cold not once but twice. I’m certainly sure they would have served it cold on the third try. Also to top this off they got all of our orders wrong and the service was awful. And yet the didn’t have the curtsy to give us our breakfast for free.

Best Breakfast food ever. Very clean. Great Service. Very accommodating staff. Always check out the daily specials for some interesting food! The coffee is great too!

Good food, generous servings, very reasonable prices. Friendly service. Takeout service.

This is one of my favorite diners. Great breakfast specials and coffee, comfortable like home especially with the girls.
Had lunch there today. Went with the hot turkey sandwich. In house roasted turkey not deli meat. Strange bright yellow turkey gravy but was very good. Hubby had turkey club made with the same roast turkey.
My only complaint — they make excellent biscuits and gravy but only in the winter. They need it year round!

Went there with my wife for lunch the other day. We were seated promptly and then forgotten about. Three other tables were sat and received their drink orders. After about 25 minutes, we left without even being able to place a drink order.

We still love coming here. They have FANTASTIC specials for breakfast and the food is good. It’s not gourmet or anything but it’s good diner food :)

Good, solid family restaurant/​diner fare. Free WiFi! Folks, it’s worth the trip. Great French toast, great omelettes! We’ve never been disappointed by the food or service here. It’s the epitome of a small town restaurant. I’d give it more stars *but* I hear (from good authority) that the ladies room lacks a bit of privacy. Outside of that, no complaints!

Good breakfast at a great price. Although the breakfast selection is limited to eggs, pancakes, and waffles, they are all nicely prepared with lots of options. For example, the pancakes come with nearly a dozen different topping and content choices. There are five different kinds of bread for toast. Service is fast and friendly. I’ve eaten there twice and had my order on the table in less than 10 minutes. For a good basic, no frills breakfast I would recommend Macedon Hills Restaurant.

I have been going to Macedon Hills for over 15 years, and the quality has dropped to unacceptable. Most of the food is from frozen packages or a box, and the service is mediocre at best. Today was the day to let others know. Breakfast included eggs over easy. The cook translates this to one broken hard cooked egg fried with edges crispy. The home fry recipe is surely potatoes warmed through with paprika and grease. One of us ordered onions with home fries. This was the above with onions sprinkled on top. One of the kids ordered corned beef hash, which was out of a can almost warm. It is quite apparent that Orange marmalade is not the preferred jam of their customers. Thankfully we could remove 17 of these little squares of undesirables to get to the one lonely grape. Too bad there were 4 of us.

Last night we ventured out in the biggest snow storm we have had thus far. It was one of those nights where you just don’t want to drive too far but you are already on the road so why not go out to eat? I passed several dining establishments with empty parking lots on our drive there– not surprising… What idiot would be out driving in that kind of a storm besides me? Well me and the 50 other cars in the parking lot of Macedon Hills! I was shocked to see such a crowd on a night that was so bad you were risking your lives for bacon and eggs… or chicken parm… whatever it was that drew them there they couldn’t be stopped!
I ordered a fish fry– it came with soup and a salad. The soup was a Manhatten Clam Chowder and the salad was a simple garden salad with ample dressing on the side. I was quite pleased with the fish fry– it was very meaty, extremely large in size and fried just right– not too oily and just the right amount of crunch. I don’t usually eat fish, after having been vegetarian for so long I am finally eating animal protien again. This was a nice revisit to the land of «meat» (well, fish anyway!)
Both of my kids chose the Chicken Parm that came with loads of garlic bread, pasta, and a soup or salad. They ordered the Italian Wedding Soup and they were humming in delight.
My husband got the goulash. He is particular about his Italian foods as he grew up spoiled by his mother’s cooking. The dish did not disappoint. It too came with a soup and salad.
Next came my mother who ordered scrambled eggs, toast, and a giant amount of homefries that could have fed an entire family was just as please.
The Bomber Sandwich was on my father’s plate and nothing was left at the end of the meal… even though he kept saying that there was too much food on his plate. He left a very happy man.
Another successful family dinner at Macedon Hills… on a night that we should have arrived by sled. Well worth the dangerous trek out!

Great breakfast — delicious veggie omelets and waffles.

About average, though they have the best turkey sandwiches. Real turkey right off the bird, no weird processed stuff. Their fries are pretty good, too — crinkle-​cut like from Tom Wahl’s or other «old-​fashioned» restaurants. I’ve also had their bomber steak sandwich, which was not really my thing, but tasty nonetheless. Their fried clam basket was just alright. They also have some good, but not cheap, cake. About four bucks for a slice. After paying like 8 – 9 bucks for a sandwich and fries, it can get pricey. Plus tip. They do have a list of specials that are a buck or two off the normal price, with a good variety to choose from.
Their everyday selection includes the basics like appetizers (chicken fingers, quesadillas, etc.), salads, soups, sides, and then has dinner entrees (steak, ham, ribs…), seafood platters and baskets, a few Italian dishes such as chicken parmesan and a few pastas, a kids section, lots of sandwiches, and pretty much whatever you might want for breakfast.
Service is decent, sometimes a hostess or waitress is a little cold, but never anything more. Some of them are quite friendly and attentive. Location is easy to get to, right off Route 31, and they have plenty of parking. Gets more full during the usual meal times, but generally not much crowding. Overall, good place for a nice, relaxed meal once in a while.

Diner Reuben test resulted in blah. Tough, dry, thick, stringy meat. Bread sogged out by the kraut. The scene is just ehhhhh.

Good food, good prices and the biggest piece of veal parm ever! :)