Amici Pizza & Deli

OMG. I am a N.Y. pizza snob and even bring pies home with me when I visit N.Y. I was waiting for a tow and went in for a slice. I almost cried when I smelled the aroma an ended up with a large pie and small calzone. The pie barely fit in the box and the calzone was HUGE. (I can’t imagine what large is) Everything was made to order and piping hot. This is an authentic N.Y. or even Italian place. The cheese was ample and gooey and had the traditional orange oil dripping down your fingers when you folded the slice. I couldn’t stop eating so my hubby took it away after the 2^nd slice (I am a petite 115 lbs). When I got home, the calzone was still hot and I HAD to try it. I cut off a slice and dipped it in the amazing sauce. The mozzerell and ricotta oozed out. If you think this is expensive, I guess you are a Lil Ceasars person (fake cheese on cardboard pizza waiting for you.) For all of you who gave it less than 5 stars, you belong at McDonald’s.
Live in Tampa, but worth driving in every week for.

I love this style pizza and we’ve been ordering from them for about 8 years. We typically order the same items, large cheese pizza and a large Greek salad. I’d give it five stars if they’d just deliver! :)

Been here many times. Never a bad meal and always have good service unless there’s a huge party. Pizza is top shelf as are the pasta dishes. The sandwiches from the oven are good but the cold sandwiches are blah. The cold sandwiches taste like the bread isn’t fully cooked.

Best pizza and calzones in the area! Great experience — this is my go to pizza place from now on!

The pie was truly delicious and truly NY style. A bit on the pricey side, but for a large supreme it is what it is.

The food is amazing ! Garlic knots are to die for. I’ve had almost everything on the menu and I’ve never been disappointed. the staff is wonderful super friendly.

Yummy pizza and yummy garlic knots. Will be back to support my local pizza joint. And want to try some of their other Italian offerings too.

Good pizza but the crust was too chewy. Also, it’s a small restaurant and everyone in there was staring at me as I was picking up my order.

Worst service ever! Stood at the door for 20 minutes and a huge party who just walked in for sat before us. There were only four of us. We walked out. Will never go back

Went by today at 345 says on here they open at 3 but the open light was off so confused on the hours.

Always excellent, best pizza around

So I just left Amici’s, we had an extra cheese pizza and buffalo wings. There was a mistake on my order and the cook and the waitress were so understanding giving us a «hook up» on the food. The pizza was delicious, the wings were very tasty and the only place in the area which serves BEEF PATTY WItH CHEESE, just like I used to eat in NY. The food is so good I would recommend it to everyone.

We used their side room for a graduation party. They were so accommodating! They let us set up a chocolate fountain, play our own music, set up a slide show. Great food, wonderful service. Highly recommended for a party.

I can totally survive on their garlic knots and sauce alone! And then the calazones! Thank you for amazing food!

Great Lil Italian place right in Wesley Chapel. They have the best NYC style pizza in the area. Another item they are known for is there awesome garlic knots which are always made to order fresh…

I have been there twice while visiting my inlaws. They have great pizza and antipasto salad. My husband waited 3 years for Amici’s and tonight’s dinner was excellent as usual. His parents eat there all the time. We wish they had a place like this in California.

I can only comment on the take out service from Amici’s seeing as that’s what we used, but what a great experience it was! When we went to pick up our order, they were very busy, but despite that they had our pies ready in just over 20 minutes. They took the order quick and efficiently and, upon arriving to pick up our order, greeted us promptly, cashed us out, and even checked our order and showed us each pie to assure that everything was done correctly. This is just a little gesture but definitely means a lot.
The pizza is AMAZING and will be our new go to place when we visit my mom in this area from now on. I am excited to try out the rest of their food and their dining room service.

The pizza is yummy. Owners are from Sicily and the food is authentic. Family friendly little local restaurant.

Visited on 10÷6÷14 as I just moved about a mile up the street from Amici’s. I am from NY so I know a little more then most about good NY style pizza. I have to say the pizza here was as close to NY style pizza as you will find in Florida. I will be returning to Amici’s for sure, and plan on take out at least once a week. You guys definitely passed my test for pizza !

Have eaten at this establishment many many years ago and protested since due to bad service but decided to roll the dice as we remembered the product to be very authentic and very good. If you like foldable large slices of New York style pizza then Amichis is the oven for you. Very hot, very fresh ingredients. Sweet italian sausage from flavor town and the cheese actually has flavor instead of a gooey texture with no taste to it. I didn’t get the crust coma fr the dough as some pizza doughs leave you feeling heavy and lazy and sleepy. Lol. This was doughy on the bottom an crispity crusty on the edges. You can tilt a slice and not have a tablespoon of grease run off your slice. Very well prepped and and just a great Italian experience. I’m glad that we decided to forgive and forget and plan on returning again soon. One thing. The place is small and they have all ovens running on all cylinders. It’s very hot in the restaurant and it feels as if the a/​c is non existent. It’s better to take your meal on the road. It’s time for a move to a bigger place and higher ceilings to give the oven heat a place to go. All in all a good dining experience. Manga!