Nella’s Frozen Yogurt

I love Nella’s! Amazing staff, amazing owners, amazing yogurt. They have an option for everyone. The only family owned yogurt shop in town. Love supporting local business.

Cassidy is very helpful and nice! Great flavor and topping choices too! Their service and quality is all around excellent! Will definitely be back frequently!

Simply Delicious! Always friendly service, a large variety of fresh toppings to choose from as well as at least ten varieties of yogurt flavors (even gluten free). A great family environment with plenty of seating for birthday parties and events. It is always kept impeccably clean! My favorite flavors are Raspberry and Pineapple as they are well aware I visit them often!

I have visited here with my husband whom is lactose & tolerant but loves to come here because of those options for him. I love this place because it truly tastes better than any other frozen yogurt in town. The young teenage girls who work there are very friendly too!

Good frozen yogurt, but not the best. Probably deserves 3.5 stars. Some of the flavors are icy sand not creamy. Their fruit flavors are better than the rest. Fresh ingredients for toppings.

I went over to Nella’s to try my first Boba Tea and fell in love! I had the Mocha Milk Tea with Boba and it was amazing! The girl working the counter was super helpful explaining the options of teas and juices. While I was waiting for my tea, I sampled the Cup of Joe yogurt and it was sooooo good! Very creamy and flavorful while not having any added sugar. The nutrition facts show it only has 25 calories per ounce and barely any fat! I have found my new frozen treat spot and will definitely be visiting this yogurt shop on a regular basis! YAY for Nella’s!!!

My 7 year old LOVES this place he even cleans his room as reward for going. Very tasty & what a nice staff. We feel lucky to live so close. Make it a great evening enjoy some frozen yogurt & a walk around the lake.
Peg

Nella’s is a great local place to grab some yummy frozen yogurt. We enjoy going there after walking the lake just behind it. Nice selection of flavors and toppings.

YUM!!! We LOVE coming here. It’s a special treat. Staff is always nice and respectful

I rather enjoyed this shop. The staff was very friendly, and the store was very clean. I don’t typically enjoy fruity flavors, but theirs were delicious. Lots of different topping options, and they even have Boba Tea. I enjoyed my experience and will journey across town to visit again.

Extremely friendly staff, there are some very nice people working here.
The yogurt tastes more like flavored, frozen water, sadly. And some of the toppings are super gross, artificial crap. Go for the fresh fruit, if anything.
All in all, you’re paying too much for cheap, artificial «food».

I agree with the other astute and more knowledgeable yogurt Unilocalers. I don’t know all the nuances of frozen yogurt making, but Nella’s undoubtedly tastes more artificial compared to the numerous other places I’ve tried.
Between our three family members, we tasted almost every flavor and only one didn’t leave us with a blegh aftertaste. I now remember that I had the same experience when I came here last year – maybe that’s why I haven’t been back since.
Whatever the scale is to measure fresh/​real vs. synthetic froyo flavors, Nella’s definitely leans toward the latter.

Nella’s Frozen Yogurt is not close to my house… at all, but it is definitely my favorite choice for frozen yogurt :-) I have always had pleasurable experiences here. The cashiers are funny and friendly and their yogurt always seems to just taste better to me then the other places in town.
My favorite combo at Nellas is the salted caramel yogurt with a little salt on top. I love that they provide the salt at the end because it truly makes this combo out of this world! Their boba is also great.
They are located in a perfect location as well. We always get our frozen yogurt and then take it to the lake and walk around the lake while eating. Great way to work off those calories from your treat :-)

I’m a huge froyo fan, and have been to tons of shops in Colorado and California. I’m still trying to find a shop here in Colorado that compares to my favorite in California (I only lived there a short time, back before the frozen yogurt traveled to Colorado)
This place was a huge disappointment. The flavors were either terrible, not good, or just meh. There was maybe one flavor I liked. The tart flavors are always my favorite, and I know no matter where I go I can count on them to be delicious. This was the first shop I’ve ever been to that had a tart that I didn’t like, and it was actually pretty terrible. Not exactly a good accomplishment.

Decent frozen yogurt. They have a ton of options for toppings. Definitely a good place to stop by if you need something sweet and cold. I also love that they have a bowl of water outside for dogs! I happened to come here after a hike with my pup, so that was a nice surprise.

Awesome Froyo place! Will become a new go-​to! Spoons are recycable… I now use them for my cereal at home!

Multiple flavors, multiple toppings candy bits syrups what have you. Pay by weight and there’s the regular size bowl and the «I dare you to eat all of that really fast and not puke» size. My flavor combo: coconut, chocolate, strawberry froyo with brownie pieces, strawberries, chocolate chips, and chocolate syrup :)
I’ll be back!

The only alternative to Pinkberry in my humble little opinion.
The shop was clean. Very important (and rare from what I’ve seen elsewhere.) The flavors were interesting and varied. Again important.
While I’d never get their Tart Original (Sorry… Ain’t nobody’s as good as Pinkberry) I was quite a fan of their Caramel. So Nice, I Went Twice! (In two days.) I like that they have a variety of syrup toppings (REAL Hot Fudge not just Hershey’s in a bottle!) and fresh fruits. Cereals, Mochi, and the «Junk» toppings round out what is a very serviceable toppings bar. (Careful: They charge by weight.) The Hot Caramel with Sea Salt sprinkled on it is NOT to be missed.
So glad there’s (FINALLY) a passable FroYo Option that’s closer to me than Pinkberry. (For those times, like Rush Hour, when you just don’t want to think about i25)

Nella’s is the best froyo place next to Pinkberry that I’ve tasted, and I’ve been to MANY of them including Yogurtland, Froyozone and Red Mango and Nella’s takes the silver cup.
Deliciously decadent froyo flavors including the Dulce de Leche (highly recommend) Oatmeal cookie (Noms!), Cookies and Cream and Birthday Cake Batter (next time, baby). I sampled most of the flavors with the taster cups and it was difficult to choose because they all tasted so good but the Dulce mixed with Oatmeal Cookie really tasted yummy and I couldn’t help but indulge (see photo). Rich and creamy froyo. Win!
The toppings selection was great too. I especially liked the cheesecake bites and the cookie dough bites. Fruit toppings also looked really fresh, like Pinkberry’s always are which is a huge plus.
Nella’s is the best substitute for Pinkberry I’ve found. When I can’t make the long drive I’ll definitely be coming back to Nella’s. Best self-​serve froyo so far!

I’m ordinarily not a fan of self-​serve froyo, and Nella’s was no exception. The line, although short, took forever because people are indecisive and go back and forth. I’ll admit that selection was good. I went with a mix of vanilla and chocolate, and while the vanilla was actually quite tasty, the chocolate had a strange flavor to it. They didn’t seem to have cones. Pricing was reasonable, but I wouldn’t call it cheap.
I think I’ll keep looking for a froyo spot.