Tony’s Pizza & Subs

No, just… No.
Husband was famished, I was hungry. We googled pizza joints (we prefer Mom & Pop places over the national chains) since I’m new to the area and the guy I married hasn’t spent any significant amount of time upstate for almost a decade. Decided to try a restaurant near Tony’s Pizza and Subs only to find the place for sale. We saw Tony’s and thought we would give it a try.
I often visit a bathroom as soon as I arrive at a restaurant I’m unfamiliar with to attempt to gauge the level of dedication the ownership and management have towards their establishment. Well-​cared for places generally boast bathrooms that are not only clean but also decorated in an appealing manner. This bathroom demonstrated neither of those traits. In the bathroom I visited, the linoleum in front of the toilet was missing leaving exposed plywood extremely worn and weathered. The mirror was placed behind the toilet instead of the sink. If you are interested in a quick freshening of your makeup, then you have to stand behind the toilet and risk dropping your favorite gloss into the porcelain throne!
On my way out of the bathroom, I happened to notice a Jurassic-​sized cockroach struggling on its back in the doorway to the kitchen. I showed the Volkswagen-​sized bug (only a slight exaggeration) to my husband who despaired as he had already ordered our drinks. We decided to order an appetizer and give the place the benefit of the doubt. We ordered the fried mushrooms, a regular favorite of ours. While waiting for our mushrooms, we made the unfortunate discovery of what appeared to be a mason jar full of moonshine sitting atop the booth divider! Now I have nothing against a little shine, but there is a time and place. This is not it. Someone’s personal hooch should not be stored in a place where it can be reached by curious kids or opportunity seeking teenagers.
Our mushrooms appeared and my first bite was still cold in the middle. Additionally, we were never given appetizer plates or flatware. This sealed the deal for us and we decided we would get food elsewhere. We quickly paid the waitress and vacated the premises. I don’t believe I would recommend this place to my worst enemies unless some major changes are made. My husband says he ate in cleaner places during his active duty tour in Afghanistan than Tony’s Pizza & Subs. Do yourself a favor and go ANYWHERE else. Your digestive system will thank you.

My advice, get dominoes. Toppings are average, crust is bland. Went a second time, got the chicken strips, they were like jerky.

We always order from Tony’s! It’s never a disappointment and they are very generous with the cheese! We prefer them over a major pizza chain in town. We also love their fried mushrooms, toasted subs and cinnamon bread.