Pie Eyed Petey’s

Horrible service from staff and the owner herself. I told her how my table had been ignored by her staff and she told me that maybe we just shouldn’t wait anymore. She also said if we were hungry we should eat at home. This woman was rude and horrible for no reason. This is not how you treat people or run a business.

3 stars based on location. On one of the best lakes in Indiana (Lake Tippy). You can drive your boat, car or walk to eat here. Food isn’t great but is decent. Downfall is the food is priced higher than it should and the place always seems to close early even when their is a big crowd. Overall a fun place to be during summer months

The last several times I have been the there the service has been awful. I used to love this place and recommended it to anyone that came to the area, now it’s the exact opposite. Very rude service and extremely long kitchen times. Not sure what happened to the friendly staff there, but it’s definitely not the same as it was. I would not recommend this place to anyone at this point in time.

The best part about this place is that you can dock your boat and grab a few drinks and something to eat.
Food is OK. I had the steak nachos, which were cold and the steak seemed like frozen cheese steak meat, ick. But, the cheesy pretzels and armadillo eggs were fantastic.
I had margaritas here two days in a row. First day, it was great (I could actually taste the tequila). Second day (and a different bartender) all I could taste was the mix. I also asked for a bottled beer, the bartender looked at me confused, then proceeded to pour me something similar on tap… it was strange.
My gripe with this place is that it’s 21 and older only. I mean, being over 21 myself I don’t care, but it’s crazy to me all the revenue they’re losing because instead of properly training staff to check IDs, they shut families out. Dumb to me!

A fun spot to hang out on beautiful Lake Tippy! Dock your boat and grab a few drinks or some snacks. I really love their thin crust pizza Supreme with ranch on the side. I have even drive from town out to the lake just to have my favorite thin crust in Warsaw.
Karaōke here is a sight to be seen. The mix of locals and vacationers is always a sight to behold. Daytime or nightime, this is a decent spot after a few trips on your pontoon around the lake.

We enjoy hanging out at Petey’s. Stoney, Megan and the rest of the staff work great together to make sure everyone is taken care of and having a good time. The Tiki bar is a lot of fun in the summer and the annual polar plunge in January is not to be missed. When you come to Petey’s you’ll probably meet some fun people and look forward to coming back like we do.

Great place to hang out on the weekend! Don’t listen to the numbnuts who
wrote bad reviews. Karaōke was not scaraoke. The local folks make it fun.

Great salad, burgers, or anything. Pie eyed pie pizza is great, along with the Hawaiian pizza. Tons of great subs as well. Enjoy sitting outside on the lake.

I love this place! Always friendly staff and Barb knows no strangers… she came and asked about my meal and couldn’t believe I ate it all. Super friendly and delicious! If you want a lighter atmosphere, go to the one in Syracuse.

Great food, friendly service, nice ambiance, but warm beer and waaaaaay to smokey! Although we loved the food, I don’t think I will be able to eat here again unless we sit outside.

Pie Eyed Petey’s is a bar & grill on Lake Tippecanoe accessible by both car and boat. The interior is surprisingly nice and they have a large outdoor seating area including an outdoor bar. There is also gas for sale next to the several piers along the water’s edge.
However, we were disappointed to discover they recently made the entire establishment, even the outside seating area, 21 and over. We’d traveled an hour by boat with our 12 year old so my parents and I sat next to the fence on the inside while my wife and daughter sat at a small table outside.
The food was good and the service friendly. We started with the fried green beans which were pretty good, if not my thing. However, the fish sandwich (grouper) was exceptionally good. My only complaint was it was served on a plain boring white hamburger bun. The fries were battered and fine.
Overall, I enjoyed it other than the ridiculous age limit throughout. Next time, I’ll leave the kids at home or visit their family friendly location in Syracuse.