Fat Cat Pizza

First time! Gonna make me into a fat cat! First time I went here this past weekend, and I gotta say it was pretty good for a local pizza joint. I ordered wings as an appetizer (BBQ) and a large pizza to share with the family. Wings were actually pretty delicious — and so was the pizza! The sausage on the pizza was kind of meh, but everything else was pretty tasty.
I have to comment on the décor: It looked like the Hobby Lobby signs section was thrown up all over the walls. I get it — it is a small town pizza place that needs to have decorum on the walls. Besides the signs, the pizza was good. Our waitress was very nice and helpful!
I give this ⁴⁄₅ stars.

Fat Cat Pizza offers a pizza on the sweeter side of things. There is no bite whatsoever to the sauce and it isn’t herbed up to give it that earthy flavor. It’s a thin-​crust pizza that is moist and coated with a hefty portion of their sweet sauce, which I’m actually a pretty big fan of. My one complaint is that they slip use those large, thin deli-​sliced pepperonis and slip them under the cheese, which as you know can result in pulling all the toppings off in a single bite. This is forgivable though because even when it happens, a toppingless piece of their pizza is still a good crust cover in their awesome sauce, so you can’t really lose.
Yesterday I tried their garlic sticks for the first time and I’m wondering why I didn’t try them sooner. They are HUGE, extremely fluffy and they are served with that delicious sauce of theirs.
I haven’t tried any of the other non-​chain restaurants in Lancaster so I can’t compare them to their local competitors, but I can say that I’m a big fan of the place and it’s well worth the half-​hour drive from where I live for a Fat Cat pizza from time to time.

I live in San Diego now, but was born and raised in Lancaster. It was a kind of a tradition for my family to sit down on Sunday nights and eat a Fat Cat’s pizza while watching a movie. And with all of the pizza joints I’ve been to, nothing can compare to a Fat Cat’s pizza. They are definitely one of a kind!
They are very generous with the sauce, and always the perfect amount of cheese and a good proportion of pepperoni. I’ve never had a Fat Cat pizza that I was disappointed with. They have expanded their store locations since I was a child, making delivery available pretty much everywhere in Lancaster. The salads and subs are also excellent.
I only visit home about once a year now, but whenever I do, I never leave without having some of my favorite pizza of all time.

Fat Cat Pizza has pretty good pizza (probably on my top 5 list of pizzas). This place is GREAT for parties if you are ordering pizza. They have a huge party pizza that many people can share. I recommend this place to anyone who likes pizza.