That Deli!

I’ve been eating here about once a week for four years. I have tried most of their menu and I love almost everything they offer but my absolute favorites are their soups and daily specialty sandwiches, they are absolutely amazing and unique!
I usually get take out during lunch and I tell you they have never gotten my order wrong, not once! It’s always perfect!
I read online and they told me in person that they will be closing at the end of this month and I’m heartbroken! The people there and the owner Roy are all amazing and I wish them all the best. But now they’ve turned me into such a soup snob nowhere else even comes close! You will be missed That Deli.

I should kick myself for waiting two weeks before they close for good to try this place. Sandwiches are the key to my heart and this place took my heart played with it and threw it on the ground and stomped on it.
The hubby and I decided to have a quick lunch and good ol Unilocal led us to this place. We decided on splitting the I-​4 Deluxe… Hands down one of the best sandwiches we have had in a long time… It was thick and the flavors were all there. I can’t afford to come everyday for the next two weeks to try everything before they close but I will definitely stop by before they say goodbye for good… So unfortunate

Ok, this place is fantastic. The food is homemade, fresh, and absolutely delicious! The prices are great too. I got ½ a sandwich (which was ginormous), soup, and a side for a whopping $ 8 and change.
There are two downsides to this place. The first, which I guess is a great problem for them to have, is that they are ridiculously busy. I went at lunch time, waited in line for 15 minutes to place an order, and then had to wait 40 minutes to get my order. Next time I will call in my order ahead of time. The second downside is that it is tiny! There are only a handful of tables (for 2) and a few counter seats. There’s also nowhere to stand when waiting for takeout.
Overall, it’s a great find! The food is spot on bu don’t expect to be back to work within in hour if you head over there at lunch!

Where to start. I heard a lot of good things about this spot. It is ALL that and more.
You have a variety of choices when it come to sandwiches. I tried to be more conservative since it was my first time at this place and picked The Bird on the Bayou. Let me just say that every sandwich comes with a side and the sandwich by itself is pretty big.
My side item was a pasta salad with artichokes and sundried tomatoes (I highly recommend this side it was really good).
Also you have your choice of breads for your sandwich (sour dough, wheat, spinach wrap)
The service was OK. I came in at lunch time and even if it was quite busy my take out order took more 20 mins to come out while dining in people’s order seemed to be served faster.
I will have to go back when it is less busy and update my review.

Went for the first time today and I’m in love. Had the Beef me up Scotty sandwich and a cup of beef and barley soup. Everything was excellent. Fast and friendly service for lunch. Will definitely be going back on a regular basis.

Not overly impressed at all! The girl who was taking orders was not pleasant! Maybe it had something to do with her having to be there on Valentine’s Day but she could have been a little nicer. A nice welcome or goodbye would have been sufficient!
My sandwich was the bird on the bayou. Good flavor but lettuce was welted. I asked for the chicken to be sliced thinly bc I don’t like my sandwiches thick, that didn’t happen. Mac and cheese was ok but overall I wasn’t impressed and don’t know what all the hypes about!
I will not be returning.

Everything is made in house from scratch and its all good! I am sick of panera and places where the soup is always the same this place gets it right! Love the buffalo chicken soup, the motsi potsi and the salmon corn chowder. The corned beef and cabbage soup is incredible though and reminds me of being back home in south Boston!

My fiancé brought me here for the the first time and I must say they don’t dissapoint! I got the I-​4 sandwich and a side of mac and cheese. Yummy! So fresh and delicious. Also got a cup of chicken taco soup, so flavorful. We will definitely be coming back here again!

I have always heard how great the food was, now I can confirm. They have a standard list of sandwiches but they have daily specials and homemade soups each day. I had the special meat loaf sandwich with a side of mac and cheese, then finished with a lemon bar. Everything was fantastic, I can’t wait to try something else.

Holy cow! This place is a god send! I was looking for an alternative to Jason’s deli and found this place had vegan/​gluten free options and decided I HAD to try it.
I’m allergic to gluten and have a really hard time finding a sandwich that’s not only filling but also delicious. I decided to try the Looney Shrooms sand which on gluten-​free millet bread. The bread is usually a $ 1 up charge but because I have an allergy they discounted me the extra buck!
The sandwich was so insanely good! My coworkers ordered a three pigs and a chefs salad and both enjoyed their choices.
Although they are a little pricey, you get what you pay for.
I look forward to returning and trying there two other vegetarian/​vegan options!

Love love love!
Amazing place, worth the money. Even though it is a bit pricey, it’s totally worth it. The Mac n cheese is so good and the sandwiches are suburb.

This is definitely the best sandwich shop I’ve ever eaten at. Fresh soups and salads are always well crafted and delicious. I always get the I-​4 Deluxe sandwich on wheat bread (which in my opinion is the best). They have many gluten free options that are just as tasty as the other choices. Everyday they have different sides and sandwiches that they feature, around the holidays they have amazing fall flavors.
If you need a perfect lunch spot make sure to visit That Deli. Portions are large enough for me (a small female) to either split or bring half a sandwich home. Check this place out you won’t be disappointed!

Ordered from here twice ago, good stuff, though the soup was a little greasy.
Highly recommend the tuna!

I came to That Deli! based on a raving recommendation of one of my coworkers saying it was the best thing since sliced bread. I can’t say that I was overly impressed though.
The restaurant itself has a nice sit down bar overlooking the kitchen (i like restaurants like this, as you know exactly how clean everything is). The kitchen area and the prep area in the back was spotless, and i had no concerns with cleanliness up front. The young lady that took my order was quick with daily specials recommendations when asked, and pleasant to talk with.
I settled on one of the specials, a chicken philly with a a side. I got the pasta salad with chopped heart of palm in it for my side… delicious! The philly had a lot left to be desired though. The bread was soggy from being overstuffed with peppers/​onions/​mushrooms, and for cheese instead of melting slices of american, it was just cheese wiz sauce from a big can. The pricing was a bit higher than I was expecting as well. My bill for the special was almost $ 11 (no drink included), which is a bit steep for a lunch for me.
Overall, nice place, nice people, but pricing is a bit too high for my liking and the food was not up to the expectations i had.

I have been going here off and on for a few years now and this is by far my favorite sandwich shop in the area.
I usually get the beef me up scottie! I like that everything is made fresh daily and it has a good feel inside the restaurant. The owner is the cook/​sandwich maker and he does a great job usually of interacting w/​customers.
I saw someone else put that the staff is kind of «blah» and I agree w/​that. Great food, great owner, good atmosphere, rest of staff is ehhh…
I’ll continue to go back, because the food is great!
PS. His sides are well worth the extra couple bucks!

The food was just okay despite all the great reviews, but then again it is just sandwiches. I got the bird on the bayou and the chicken was so dry. The soup was really good (curry turkey) and the deli sides are different every day and I got potato salad which was amazing. I would go back again but hopefully I’ll pick a better sandwich next time.

100% recommend. Unlike many chain and corporate restaurants whose service and food quality can vary greatly depending on location and time — That Deli! Always meets and exceeds my expectations.
There has not been one negative experience in the many times I’ve visited. The area is always clean, and staff pleasant. The owner is always hands on and knows all of his regulars. That’s only part of the reason we come to places like this… What about the food?
Absolutely some of the best sandwiches in the central Florida area. What makes them great is when you break down the components. Fresh high quality meats, great cheese, and artisan breads. Add on speciality sauces and fresh produce and you’ve got the recipe that That Deli! Is known for.
Also available are varying soups, which are well crafted and full bodied (I’ve personally had 5 different ones at the time of this writing). They rotate in and out and offer some good choices for any pallete.
When it comes down to it, if your looking for a sandwich, this is hands down the place to go.

I have to admit, the first time I saw this shop in passing, I thought, «A ‘unique’ name like that won’t attract any business!» Little did I know, it was the most packed sandwich deli shops in town. I also heard it from a co-​worker who mentioned that this is the place to go for a savory sandwich. She had more fun saying the name of the sandwiches than actually describing the taste and ingredients. And I concur. The fun names pair well with the fresh ingredients, unique concoctions, and family-​like service.
I kid you not, I think everybody knew the owner. They were on a first-​name-​basis with this guy who asked each one what he/​she would be having today. Not one customer said «the usual.» I would assume that would be a crime. The menu is full of options. If you’re satisfied with usual ham, cheese, and white bread syndrome then Publix is down the block. Taco Bell is closer if I dare mention.
It took me awhile to narrow down my options. I had to remind myself that I only have one stomach. I decided to be festive and try the Rush Limbaugh: hot turkey, stuffing, cranberry relish, tarragon gravy with a side of red potato salad. I asked for walnuts and to my surprise, they did not have that ingredient. It’s okay. I’m not picky. I had a choice of bread so I chose rye.
Now this is probably my fault, but I didn’t like it. Lol. It was mushy, hence the walnuts would have created that crunchy factor. And a hard sourdough would have been better fit. The mac and cheese looked great as watched them pack it up with other to-​go orders so that will have to be ordered the next visit. But the potato salad is equally good! It just didn’t work well with my mushy sandwich.
Unfortunately I’ll have to label the first visit as a false attempt… or practice round. Next time I know what to look for. But no matter what, I know that this deli makes everything fresh and in the house, including the soup. The service was a little slow for a deli but I would choose quality over efficiency so no argument there.
I’m giving this 4 stars not based on what I ordered, but the menu options, the service, and the preparation into each ingredient. Try That Deli!

That Deli!, I wish you would open up a spot closer to where I live because that would be friggin amazing!
Anyway, on the occasions that I do end up in Lake Mary; I always want to see if I have time to stop by for a quick meal. Are you in a roast beef, melty cheese, & Portobello mood? Then I recommend the oh-​so-​delicious Beef me up Scotty! Do you want chicken instead of beef? Then the spicy Bird of the Bayou will satisfy your cock-​a-​doodle doo craving. If you’re feeling whimsical, then blindly order their special sandwich of the day. Honestly, you can’t go wrong with any of their sandwich choices.
The prices are reasonable considering the quality ingredients that make up your sandwich. I remember getting to go one time and not being able to eat my lunch until an hour later. When I finally got to my sandwich I was so relieved to see that it was still intact and not falling apart into a soggy mess. Yay for awesome sandwich bread! In addition to your sandwich, you also get a side too. How’s that for a combo meal?
Service is always friendly and efficient. If you have questions, then just ask. They will gladly answer any questions or even offer samples of one of their daily soups. Yum!

Where do I begin to explain how amazing ‘That Deli’ is? RARELY do I ever get blown away from a deli. For the most part– it’s just a sandwich, BUT not here! The sandwiches are filled with fresh ingredients, wide selection of different toppings/​sauces, piled and stacked high, concoctions that will make you craving to try every sandwich on the menu AND most importantly it’s made with love. Even the sides are plentiful and delicious– I love that this restaurant does not hold back on quality OR quantity.
–Caesar side salad was a generous portion, dressing was creamy, salad was fresh, croutons and cheese definitely brought the salad to the next level.
–Spicy chicken enchilada soup served with a piece of cornbread. Writing about this side makes my mouth water. The flavors were bold and it was probably the best soup I’ve ever had (Sorry mom!)
–Roy’s new munchies and Bird on the bayou deli sandwiches were phenomenal. Once again you could taste the freshness of the ingredients, the flavors all just came together so well, it was just exceptional!
…the only downfall is I don’t live in Florida and I do not know if I ever will get the chance to revisit this amazing deli. That in itself saddens me. So if you are ever in the area– it’s a MUST try! You will not be disappointed.