Warren & Annabelle’s

This was our 3^rd visit. Warren was out of town and it took the talents of two really amazing magicians to fill his shoes, but boy did they. My wife and I thoroughly enjoyed the magical performances of both John George and Chris Blackmore.
I’ve seen John George perform before and even though I sort of knew what to expect we were so greatly entertained. Both John and Chris know how to entertain and amaze with such finesse. Warrne and Anabelle’s is a Maui must.

Entertaining, funny, great service and a fun atmosphere. Overall the best magic show I’ve ever seen and very highly recommended. You will regret not going.

Summary: A great show with some great, hiliarious magicians. John Shryock and Chris Blackmore are rockstars. The food and drinks were good. Royal Flush package is worth it.
My wife and I went to Warren & Annabelle’s just after the New Year while on a trip. We had the Royal Flush package, which consisted of two drinks each, four appetizers each (coconut shrimp, chicken satay skewers, etc. A full meal), and included gratuities. We arrived an hour before the show (with sweaters in hand because of the very air-​conditioned lounge area) and went through the secret entrance to get to the lounge. We were seated and served drinks and food. While waiting to be seated for the show, we were entertained by a player piano that took requests from anyone that called out a song title. We were approached by a someone asking if we wanted to sit in the front row and be part of the performance. Being the adventurous type on vacation, we said «yes» but wondered what we were in for.
A few minutes for the first showtime for the evening, we were all escorted into the theater and my wife were seated along a front set of tables right next to where the magicians would be performing. Soon the show began, and for the two hours or so we were delighted by fantastic tricks and comedy (and we were part of the show ourselves). There was one strange woman sitting in the crowd that heckled the magicians throughout the show (it was really awkward), but they just took it in stride and retorted back with comedic mastery. Both were fantastic, and after the show we purchased their DVDs to enjoy and had a great story to share with our families upon our return home.
Definitely a super entertaining way to spend an evening in Lahaina :-)

An absolute must for anyone staying in Maui. This is such a fantastic show. We first saw the show when we were in Maui on our honeymoon. We have recommended the show to any all all our friends who visit the Lahaina area. It was so great we booked our seats to see it again when we returned to Maui. This second time we saw Warren perform and what a treat! He is so talented and absolutely hilarious. This is a great show for people of all ages. Don’t miss this experience!

A Must see. We have been many times and seen all of the magicians as well as Warren himself. You can’t go wrong no matter what magician is preforming when you attend the show they are all fantastic. I love that the theater is small. You are right there to see it all and wonder «How did he do that» !!! I would bring a sweater it is a little chilly in the theater. The pre show in the parlor is entertaining. If you get the food package you are served during this portion of the show. The food/​drink package was good. but, if you decide you want a dessert and something a la carte or from the bar you can still order it. I personally love the dessert menu we had a fantastic Key Lime Pie .The show itself is AMAZING and they are great comedians as well. I love Dana Daniels and his bird «Its a Bird «you will understand when you see the show. There is great interaction with the audience. My husband was chosen and part of one of the tricks it was a lot of fun. Seriously its a great evening.

UN b e l i e v a b l e !
We almost skipped this show: it wasn’t pushed by the concierge at the hotel. Somewhere I heard Warren and Annabelle’s was a must-​see and added it at the last minute. Lucky move!
I won’t spoil it by saying another word about Warren’s magic. I don’t know when I have enjoyed anything more and I have seriously never seen my husband… of many years… laugh so hard. In a tiny theatre (it seats 70-​something) where every seat is good and we were in the second row, Warren does things you will simply not believe and will never figure out! And he’s hysterically funny!
The «Annabelle» portion of the show is just okay, but they have to do something while they feed you. I would go à la carte rather than purchase the «Royal Flush» package again. Don’t get me wrong: the hors d’oeuvres were excellent. I just would concentrate on the crab cakes, coconut shrimp and perhaps the chicken satay rather than order the prepared plate, and order drinks ad lib from the bar. (It would probably price out the same in the end, however.)
All in all, this is a wonderful evening, expensive, and worth every cent! Skip Ulalena and go see Warren instead! (You might want to check and make certain Warren himself is performing when you make reservations, although I have heard excellent things about the other magicians who perform there)

This is a really unique experience on Maui, so if you’ve been to the island more than once and are looking for something fun and different to do in the evening, I highly recommend Warren and Annabelle’s! Even if it’s your first time to Maui, it’s such a fun time. My fiancé and I live in Maui, we saw the show when John Shyrock and Chris Blackmore were the magicians — I can not stress enough how hilarious they were, the magic was amazing but the comedy is really the highlight of the show. They offer the Royal Flush package that include appetizers and 2 drinks per person with the show admission, but if you’re looking to save money and eat better food, I’d suggest eating somewhere else before the show (there are lots of great happy hours in the area) and just buying drinks a la carte in the parlor since the food with the package is nothing special. The drink pricing is pretty inexpensive though which is great, and they do a round of drinks before the show starts, but I’d suggest trying to get your drinks while you’re in the parlor because the server didn’t make it around to everyone right before the show. Overall, the show itself is the star, we’ll definitely be going back to check out the other magicians!

Warren is an amazingly talented and hilariously funny magician. Do not hesitate to make a reservation and see this man in action. His wit and sarcasm are spot on. You will be totally amazed at his magic. We were in the first row, literally feet from the stage and have no idea how he does what he does. The wedding ring trick is awesome. Thanks Warren for a really fun night!

Me and my wife laughed so hard! The comedy was great, the magic was outstanding, and the interaction with the audience was wonderful. Thank you Warren for your support of service members! This show is a must see while at Maui. Book before your trip!
What a show!

So glad we went to this show! Service was amazing food tasted great so did the drinks! The magic/​comedy was hilarious me and my husband loved it I would definitely recommend coming here!

First, let me say, I’ve been to the Magic Castle in LA and I give this show 5 stars.
John Shyrock and Dana Daniels are outstanding magicians and comedians. We left with our sides hurting from laughing. The sleight of hand magic was nothing less than remarkable and very entertaining. (I’m a person who sits and enjoys and I do not agonize over how they did it.)
We bought the Royal Flush package and while we enjoyed the parlor, the service and the music, we probably wouldn’t buy it again. They allowed people who did NOT buy dinner in early with us. Mark, the seating manager, put those people at the more comfortable (higher) tables for eating and left us with a coffee table for dinner. Not a good way to treat your clients who spent more money.
I would highly recommend the show — as three Maui residents did to us.

My wife and I came to Warren & Annabelle’s during our most recent trip to Maui on the advice of a guidebook. I had initially skipped over this show as we were more interested in a performing arts show, however, I’m very glad we decided to go with Warren’s.
The show was awesome! We saw John Shryock and Chris Blackmore. Both of them are incredibly skilled magicians and are hilarious entertainers. We were engaged and laughing the entire night. We were even lucky enough to be invited to the first row to participate in some of the tricks — my wife’s weddding ring disappeared and fortunately reappeared.
We purchased a non-​alcoholic royal flush package to share, which is a decent deal. For about $ 30 each of us got a free drink and we shared the appetizer plate, which comes with chicken satay skewers, pork wraps, coconut shrimp, and a crab cake. The food was OK, not fantastic but not terrible.
We attended the 5 — 9pm show. We had appetizers and drinks until about 6pm when they started seating for the show. If we go again I would skip the pre show drinks and appetizers and have an early dinner elsewhere then arrive at 6pm for show. Also, they validate parking in the outlet mall lot, which saves about $ 15 and lots of time as parking near Front St is tough.
Overall, I highly recommend!

This is a great dinner and show! Well worth the $ 100 for the appetizers, 2 drinks and dessert (best apple pie) package along with the most entertaining show we’ve seen in years! We laughed the entire two hours! Our cheeks hurt from all the laughing!

While on vacation, we were treated to Warren & Annabelle’s as an anniversary gift. We were given the Royal Flush package. We were able to get the tickets the night before the show.
The atmosphere was great! Such a tucked away treasure, I was really blown away.
The first 2 hours (5−7pm) are for you to come, relax, unwind and have drinks, appetizers, and dessert. While the appetizers were good, I probably wouldn’t have ordered them on my own. The drinks were good, not skimpy on the alcohol. The desserts were HUGE portions. I had the cheese cake and it was DELICIOUS! My wife had the chocolate dish (was supposed to be a mousse) and it was wayyyyy too bitter and not edible. Maybe just an off night for that. Had it been me, I would have eaten at a local eatery before coming to the show, for $ 80 you could probably have a pretty nice dinner.
Our server Joey was great. For those who have said she is too New York or rough, come on. We had a nice chat with her, good laughs, very personable.
It was a little awkward sitting there for almost 2 hours though, because we were done eating in about an hour and just had to hang out. Might be a little too long to sit and wait.
As for the show. I’ve not laughed like that in a long time. It’s engaging, entertaining, and well worth the visit. While the younger crowd may not understand the Andy Griffith references, it made the show better. I really appreciated the sincere thank you from Warren at the end of the show. It’s a guy living his dream. You can tell he truly loves to make people laugh, and he’s GOOD at it! I love that he doesn’t have to be crude or use foul language to make people laugh. He took a room of strangers and had each one of them laughing. People like Warren are hard to find.
I would absolutely see the show again. Would love to come back and see Warren and possibly when another act is there too!
If you don’t do dinner, the $ 60 for tickets is WELL worth it!

This was not worth $ 350 for three people! Although the ambiance was great, we had to listen to Mark, the mgr tell everyone the canned welcome and where the bathroom was about 60 times. The food was terrible. I think Joey the waitress was a bit too New Yawk… she was a tad gruff. I ended up throwing up the food because it was so tough on my stomach, so was up and down all night with that mess. The show was «ok». He was a great magician, but his humor was very old school. He used the Andy Griffith Show character names for people in the audience. He also asked people where they were from, and what they did, but only asked MEN, for the most part. He asked the people helping him with magic tricks, but no one else.
I think his conservative Christian views were way too overused. His schtick was a but schmaltsy because he did not take into consideration young people, especially from Canada, do not know old TV shows or references to Lorena Bobbitt and others from 20 years ago.
Oh, and the parking sucks. Ended up paying $ 10 in another lot, then $ 4 more in a lot nearer to the theater… blah.

Awesome show. He had the entire theatre laughing. We didn’t do the food portion but they have you arrive at the show about 1 ½ hour before the show actually starts. A tad disappointing. But during that time they offer food and drinks for purchase.
Make sure to make reservations before arriving on Maui. Tickets sell out quickly.

I think I will go with a 3.5÷5. If I were writing only about the show I would say it was a ⁴⁄₅.
The bad:
The seating arrangement was weird for the dinner. We were forced to sit with another couple in an inconvenient arrangement that made no sense for eating out of a large plate of appetizers. The other couple tried to request for a separate table but was turned down. Almost all requests were turned down by the server who was downright rude at many points. We happened to be served by two different servers and neither made us feel comfortable. The food itself was very average and high priced even by Maui standards. I would skip it any day and I saw many repeat customers doing that happily and was made the wiser.
The good:
The show itself was very entertaining for the most part. It was cliched and cringeworthy at times. Not too intelligent always but the tricks were pulled off with panache and ease. So there is your 4 out of 5. The room was never chilly for me.

We discovered this show through trip advisor like many others. We had a group of 6 grad young grad students, and to be honest, a «magic show» was the last thing I imagined doing in Maui. But we took a leap of faith, got on a wait list, and made it through for the show only. I would recommend booking early if possible as it is a popular attraction apparently, being booked out weeks.
We arrived after the dinner was over, there was piano entertainment in a medium sized swanky room, eventually led into a smaller theater (maybe ~50 seats?), we sat towards the back. Despite this fact, it still felt quite intimate and cozy.
The show was Awesome! The time leading up to the show, my attitude was pretty pessimistic. Thought it was going to be corny jokes, a lot of «been there, seen that» tricks, but the entire show was more entertaining than just pure magic. The magician was witty, his tricks were of course pretty amazing, and his jokes were actually funny.
Highly recommend the show at the least.

While the magic show was entertaining, albeit in a sometimes cringeworthy way, the food was terrible. Frozen food that tasted chalky and rubbery was the lowlight of the evening. Watered down drinks didn’t help much. The included gratuity made for abrupt, unfriendly service as well. That and sitting through a player piano recital in a vintage 80s room with a plate of food in my lap was not fun.
If you decide to partake in the show be prepared to be part of the joke. It’s a clean show and the tricks were amazing, but I didn’t care for Warren’s comedic insults to people’s professions.
By all means save money by skipping the Royal Flush package and only pay for the show.

I am a bit torn about this review. This 4 hour events surely has its ups and downs. I would average it out to be a 3.5÷5. I had high hopes for this show given all the glowing reviews but I’m not sure anymore. I’d like to think it’s because I’m from NYC and I’ve seen numerous Broadway shows and that is what I compare it to. Or perhaps, I’m at an age where the magic stuff will intrigue me but not mystify? Lets start from the top.
First, don’t even think about coming early. If you come by car, you will park at the Lahaina Outlets parking center. The show will validate it for 4 hours, so if you come early, you will have to pay the rest (which is only a few dollars). But that’s not the reason to not come early. It’s because they don’t do ANYTHING until the time they say they will start. I.e. my show started at 7:30pm and we were all just waiting awkwardly outside until they opened the doors. I think they do this because there is a special way of entering and want to get many people at once. Check in isn’t long but they are serious about the ID and being over 21.
Entrance: won’t give away too much. Wasn’t as big a deal as everyone makes it out to be. Seriously. Perhaps, if they didn’t make so many people do it at once it would be much more interactive for EVERYONE *hint hint*
Parlor: Once you enter you go into the parlor. Some manager will divide you up. He seemed to be good a splitting up ages. The young folk sat with the young folk and the old sat with the old. There were PLENTY of old folks. They offer what is called a Royal Flush Package where you get a plate of appetizers, dessert and two drinks. After having bought that, my advice: SKIP the package, eat dinner else where, buy dessert and a drink and save a few bucks. I’d say the Royal Flush kind of pays for itself because it includes the gratuity and the waiter will not bother you with a bill for the drinks and food (unless you order outside of what is offered in the package). However, the food wasn’t that great. Who said the crab cakes were yummy before. Have you EVER had crab cakes in your life?
Annabelle: Just some person in the other room who is playing a piano connected to the one in the parlor. You are supposed to call out what song for him to play but dear god, the old folks offer up some really far out suggestions. If Annabelle doesn’t know the song, you are supposed to sing it. Yeah, that will REALLY make people want to participate. My group was kind of dead, no one really got into the piano thing. We were just waiting for the show to start. The early show overlaps with the parlor time of the evening show so you HAVE to wait for the first show to finish if you are in the 7:30pm one. It was kind of an awkward 2 hours. They need some sort of opening act. Annabelle itself is NOT entertaining enough.
The show: Wow, it took Warren a very long time to come out. We were sitting there for about 15 minutes before he finally came out. Yikes. The jokes were pretty good and the tricks were fun. There was trick or two where I could absolutely see how he did it. Warren, the trick where you turned 4 coins into 3 needs to be practiced. You didn’t distract me enough for me to miss where and how you put that last coin the way you did ;)
The show was definitely the best part of the whole thing. One complaint is that there were certain parts of the show that dragged on. You eventually realize what he was trying to do but isn’t it a cardinal rule in show business to not let silence linger for too long? He did that a few times and it was so awkward!
The crowd seemed to enjoy it that night. However, two people did leave in a huff about an hour into the show. It was during that time period where he just sort of lingered and didn’t do magic for about 30 minutes (he just asked the audience questions).
No one gets pulled up on stage but you may be asked to sit front row, stage side and help participate if you are young and pretty. My night, one of the guys got picked on a lot but he was kind of a simple dude with a personality that was just begging for that kind of banter. To be honest, he might have saved that night so thank you sir!
Drinks are expensive, service was pretty decent.
So to sum up:
–Don’t get the Royal Flush Package
–Don’t get there early, you can still enter even if you are an hour late and you won’t miss much!
–There will be times of awkwardness.
–But there will be many times of laughter and amazement.
–I wouldn’t go as far as how Maui Revealed raved about it but it was decent. Not sure if it was worth the price though…