Cake Fanatics

I was planning my destination wedding to Maui, being from CA, I couldn’t taste all the flavors, so I took my chances with ordering cupcakes and a cake.
The cake was adorable! The funfetti was so good, and all the cupcakes were delicious. They were really moist and the frosting was perfect.
Also, I was really annoying with all the emails, but they were very nice and accommodating.

I went to Maui for my wedding anniversary. I ordered a 6″ white cake (1) with guava filling (2) and buttercream frosting (3). I spent a total of $ 182 (including delivery). Well the cake didn’t have the guava filling. ¹⁄₃ the cake was basically incorrect. Quite the disappointment considering it WAS my anniversary and I did spend $ 182 on the cake. Insult to injury, they offered a whopping $ 10 discount for the mistake, wow… how generous of you… that equates to 5.5% off for making the cake ¹⁄₃^rd wrong. Need I say more, not very good customer service if you ask me…
To date (06.13.16) no refund has been issued. Not even the $ 10. Talk about a shady place. I would steer clear of this place.

5÷10÷16
We had a very small, casual destination wedding in Kapalua and since I was not familiar with the area, I went on Unilocal to find someone to do our wedding cake & flowers. I am so glad I found Cake Fanatics! Jordan was extremely helpful and really great to work with. I ordered a single layered round lemon cake with raspberry filling and a dozen chocolate cupcakes with chocolate mousse filling. The cake design I ordered was simple, yet very elegant. Emma Lee personally delivered the cakes to our residence at the Montage and decorated them with fresh orchids. *Jordan also recommended the florist I used. The cake table looked beautiful! (*See pics) It was the most delicious wedding cake I have ever tasted! Our family & friends all raved about it! (Both flavors) The cake was so moist and the buttercream frosting was amazing!!! I am so glad I also ordered the dozen cupcakes, leaving a little extra to enjoy for a few more days.
I highly recommend Cake Fanatics! Not only do I think you will agree that it is the most delicious cake ever, you will also love working with Jordan & Emma Lee! Thank you ladies for making our special day even that much more special!

I was so happy that we decided to go with a desert table for our recent wedding in Maui. The cake, which was a simple one tier cake with intricate piping looked amazing and tasted great!
We also had a chocolate mousse with strawberries, however the mousse tasted water down or had too much liquid in it, so the texture was a bit off.
However, cant say enough about cake fanatics, they listened to our ideas and executed.

Jordan was amazing and helped answer all my questions and before my destination wedding. The cake/​grooms cake were amazing and the cupcakes were a huge hit!
Thank you so much for making my vision come to life and for helping me surprise my new husband with his OU themed grooms cake.

I ordered a cake from Cake Fanatics for my destination wedding which was held on 01.12.2016. Jordan was most helpful to work with and her sugestion for the cake flavors — guava cake with bavarian crème and vanilla buttercream frosting — were a hit. Realllllllyyyyy yummy. For the design, we chose a white cake with peacock pattern/​piping slightly on top, cascading down one side — it was simple but elegant. Also, as a last minute decision, we ordered wedding favors from them — chocolate sea shells in edible sand — and they were a hit with our guests. They were very well made, delicious, a unique and memorable gift.

I ordered a cake for my parents surprise vow renewal and I would highly recommend Cake Fanatics! They were extremely easy and super helpful to work with giving me many options to choose from and always available to answer my questions. The cake was delivered directly to our door by the owner, Emma. The cake was absolutely beautiful and amazingly delicious, the perfect ending for our special celebration! Thank you Cake Fanatics, you are awesome!!!

I would highly recommend Cake Fanatics to anyone! We had the best time designing a cake for Thanksgiving. Emmalee is an amazing artist and made the tastiest cake I’ve ever had!
A pleasure to work with!

I must say I was very pleased with the cake I ordered for my daughters wedding. I had read a few reviews on Unilocal that made me not want to call but I was willing to see for myself. I did not receive a response right away but I called again and eventually received a call back from Jordan who assured me that she would take care of everything and not let me down. I told her we wanted tropical flavors as the wedding was in Maui and she recommended Guava on one tier and coconut/​pineapple on the other. Everyone loved the taste and more importantly the bride and groom LOVED it. The cake was beautiful and Jordan added the fresh flowers we provided when she arrived. Thank you Jordan for coming through as promised. :)

I am getting married on Dec. 31, 2015 in Maui.
I found this bakery online and was amazed at the beautiful cakes and flavor selection on their website. I contacted Cake Fanatics and was assisted immediately.
However, as time went on and more concrete details were being constructed their promptness became much less of a priority. I understand people are busy, so I thought that was perhaps what was happening.
I finalized all information on my cake and received an email stating:
«To put down a deposit I will have Emmalee send you over an invoice as soon as she can and you will be able to pay via PayPal with any major credit card»
I waited 2 weeks to receive my invoice information so I could put my deposit on my cake. With no response, I emailed Cake Fanatics asking for information regarding where my invoice was.
I was sent this lame of an excuse email:
«Our apologies for the delay! Emmalee has been out of town and she just returned. I was also just informed that we will not be taking any cake orders through the holidays, from December 23– January 5, 2016. I am so sorry for the inconvenience! We wish you and your husband-​to-​be all the best!»
I find it extremely unprofessional and frustrating for a company to completely finalize all my cake specifications (minus deposit) to then say they wouldn’t do my cake. It makes a girl wonder, if I wouldn’t have emailed them acquiring about my invoice would they have contacted me to inform me that they weren’t going to be doing my cake? Also, what a coincidence that Emmalee was gone for the 2 weeks that I waited and was back when I emailed them.
Not a professional way to run a business. Especially one that involves someone’s wedding!

We were so thrilled with Emmalee’s beautiful and DELICIOUS cakes for our wedding! We had a small ceremony and reception with immediate family only — just 10 guests — and the two six-​inch square cakes worked out perfectly. We had enough for everyone to have a slice of each and every guest RAVED about the cake. So light, such incredible flavor, and that icing — OMG! And they were so gorgeous — just perfect and exactly like the photo we’d shared (actually, even better). Emmalee is a true artist!
We visit Maui every summer and can’t wait for Emmalee to make a cake for our first anniversary next year. She’s got a customer for life! Thank you, Emmalee (and Jordan!) for being such a very special part of our day. :-)

Our wedding coordinator (Gabriella @ Platinum Weddings) recommended Emmalee for our wedding 7.3.15. She accomodated our food allergies and made a delicious gluten & soy free cake for us, our guests had no idea! We wanted to be able to enjoy splurging and oh did we! It was exactly as we requested… spot on the picture we sent. THANK YOU!!!

Our wedding planner recommended Emma Lee to provide cupcakes for our wedding reception. Emma Lee was very nice and professional, promptly answering any questions I had about flavor options and presentation. We decided on offering three flavors of cupcakes: coconut, marble and red velvet. They were all delicious! The cupcakes were presented beautifully in pretty, white wrappers. The flavors were wonderful and the cakes were fluffy and soft. The frosting was perfect — not overwhelming with just the right amount of sweetness. I enjoyed each flavor but my favorite was definitely the coconut. Our wedding was last week and our guests are still talking about how much they loved the cupcakes!

Emma Lee did an amazing job. The cake was exactly what we wanted and it was delicious! We had two tiers, one with marble cake and chocolate ganache filling and the other was French vanilla with lilikoi filling. Both were out of this world! I would use them again and I would highly recommend Cake Fanatics.

Our cake was by far the easiest part of the wedding planning! And the one thing that was absolutely perfect. I told Emmalee what I had in mind and it turned out better than I had hoped! We ordered a bigger one than we actually needed for the day, so the kids and us were still eating it 3 days later, it was just as delicious! Would definitely recommend.

Ordering a cake from EmmaLee was so easy. She took pictures I had collected and designed the most beautiful cake. It tasted great too! My daughter couldn’t decide what flavor she preferred so EmmaLee made each tier a different flavor. I was worried about getting the cake to the party from Lahaina but she delivered the cake on time and in perfect condition. I will definitely order another cake from Cake Fanatics when the need arises and will recommend Emmalee to everyone I know.

If I could give Cake Fanatics a 10 I would. At the last minute we got to join our best friends on Maui for their wedding. Checked on line to order a special cake and found Cake Fanatics website. Emmalee was so great to work with on line and designed the perfect cake. So very happy I found this wonderful place!