Sugar Plum Bakery

We ordered a cake for my daughter’s confirmation. Cake was absolutely amazing with chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry filling. All our guests were in love with the cake and it was gone within 1 hour. Incredible bakery making the best cakes we have had in a long time!

We used Sugar Plum Bakery for our wedding cakes and it was a GREAT experience.
We were planning on doing donuts, italian cookies and cake for dessert at the wedding, so we weren’t looking to get anything too intense, just something for us to cut and to offer a more traditional alternative to the donuts and cookies. Sugar Plum was near our venue so we decided to set up a tasting.
The tasting was fantastic. Johanna, the owner, brought us out a full tray of cupcakes featuring at least 12 different cake flavors, plus a substantial variety of flavors. I ate way more than I should have but they were so good I couldn’t stop myself.
We decided on a variety of combinations (lemon cake with lemon filling, vanilla cake with raspberry jam filling, and carrot cake with cream cheese buttercream filling) and Johanna helped us pick a variety of styles for decoration. We knew we wanted something vibrant and colorful and she had some awesome suggestions that we loved.
When we left we were very confident that we would pick Sugar Plum. When we received the contract we were thrilled with the reasonable price!
On wedding day, Sugar Plum delivered the cakes and worked with our coordinator. When we first saw them we were floored. They were SO much more beautiful than we had ever imagined they would be. Throughout the night multiple guests kept remarking about how beautiful the cakes were! Of course they tasted delicious too, soft and moist just as we expected from the tasting. I can’t wait until our first anniversary to eat the top tier!

Love it here. They have done cute cakes and cupcakes for me on several occassions and all were delicious. Decorations are great. Owner, Johanna, is so sweet. Definitely an awesome place to go.

Ladies working here are always awesome and their treats are delicious. The best half and half cookies around! I hate chocolate cake and their is something about theirs that I love! It’s got this cocoa-​ey goodness to it rather than that fake chocolate kinda taste I always loath! Average prices for a cupcake place and their selection is more interesting (Cannolli and Cadbury egg cupcakes? YUM!)

This small town bakery is wonderful! Cupcakes are creative and yummy! I had the strawberry champagne cupcake recently and it is heavenly… fresh strawberry filling… tasted like I was biting into a strawberry! Well done!

I have stopped by here a few times for cupcakes. They have a good selection of flavors, from classic to crazy. Some of them are rotating specials. They are a bit pricey though for the size.$ 3 – 4 each. But, they are pretty tasty.
Attention: Raspberry Lemon Cupcake lovers
SugarPlum has THE best raz-​Lemo cupcake I’ve ever had. It is filled with an insane raspberry jam and the flavors are amazing in this cupcake! Try it!!!
The bakery also has a selection of cookies, brownies and of course cakes. Cute little place. A bit $$ but cupcakes are yummy.

Wonderful brownies and caramel apple cheeses cakes. Trust me I’m a brownie and cheesecake snob.

We had our wedding cake done here and they were easy to work with and made a beautiful and delicious product. For the tasting we were able to try all the flavors and fillings, which was amazing, but we were even more impressed by the actual cake– and got a lot of compliments on it (carrot w/​cream cheese in the middle, vanilla and chocolate tiers with buttercream). I would definitely return for a cake in the future.

We had our wedding cake/​cupcakes done by Sugar Plum and I’ve continued to go here since then. I love their treats! Seven layer bars are my favorite. We’ve also had various request for allergen friendly cupcakes/​treats and they are always very responsive.

I’ve had both cupcakes and brownies from Sugar Plum. Everyone felt the cupcakes were good, but I didn’t enjoy the vanilla custard filling. In fact, although all the cupcakes were different, they all had different fillings. I would have preferred either frosting for filling, or no filling at all. As for the S’Mores brownie, the brownie itself was ok, could have been fudgier, but the frosting– oh my god! The frosting was absolutely amazing! Definitely made it worth the $ 1.95.

We had an unusual request and Plum Sugar Bakery delivered.
My sister and her husband were looking for angel food cake for their wedding. 1 week before the wedding, I called about 15 places around the South Shore; essentially anywhere within an hour drive looking for someone to do an angel food cake. No one except Plum Sugar Bakery even considered fulfilling this request. The lady I spoke to on the phone immediately told me they could help. They were very cordial and did everything they could to make sure I (the customer) was happy. She took my info and what I needed to order and the next day I got a follow up call to nail down the details. They were even willing to do a tasting and decorate it all on such short notice.
The day of the wedding, we picked up 3 gorgeous angel food cakes and they were delicious! I even grabbed a cupcake from the wonderful selection they had and that was amazing too.
All in all, the bakery came through for us when we had almost lost hope. The guests at the wedding loved the cake. The bride (who is picky about her angel food cake, as it is a childhood favorite of hers) LOVED the cake. Everyone was happy! I couldn’t have asked for anything more from this bakery and my sister (who lives in Pembroke) will be back!

Crooks with a spatula!!! Not to mention every «treat» I’ve tried was dreadfully discusting. I would give no stars if that was an option. Everything from their cucakes to their half moons are extremely dry with a cornbead like consistency (yet no where near delicious like cornbread).
The owners are comeletely rude. They put out a coupon for 25% off ANY cakes and then come up with an excuse as to why they can’t accept the coupon when trying to make a purchase with it. I don’t understand why businesses make coupons available to customers when they just get upset everytime someone tries to redeem one. To make a long story short… I presented a coupon for a VERY expensive cake quoted my the owner and after taking my $ 50 deposit they contacted me telling me that they cannot accept the coupon for my custom cake and presented me with a completely different cost. I couldn’t afford the updated cost so I had to tell them no thank you and then they wouldn’t give me back my deposit. I only put down the deposit because I agreed to the price they originally quoted me with the coupon, therefore, it was an error on their part and I surely, in good faith, should have been able to get my $ 50 deposit back. I even signed a contract for the originally quoted price! The funny part is that I knew I shouldnt have gone with them for my cake in the first place because I hated the taste but I chose them because I wanted to take advantage of the coupon to help fit my budget. I guess it’s not always worse saving. Superior customer service is far more satisfying than saving a few dollars sometimes. On a happy note I went to another bakery and told them the story and they went above and beyond to make a cake at the right price for me and complely satisfied my every need. Sugarplum still never refunded me my $ 50 though. DON’T GO HERE UNLESS YOU WANT SHOTTY FOOD AND SHOTTY SERVICE! They deserve to be shut down for false advertising! FYI… I“ve never written a bad review ever in my life. That’s how important this was to me to get the word out. I hope this helps you all!

I got my wedding cake and cupcakes through them. the staff was nice, food was amazing. (besides my wifes wedding dress) they were the most talked about part of my wedding.

One of my best friends birthdays happened to fall on Friday the 13^th this year and she is a huge horror fan. I took my idea for a Jason Voorhees inspired cake to Sugar Plum and the final product blew my expectations out of the water. The cake was a piece of horror art and it tasted amazing!
I can’t wait to have another event so I can challenge the talents of the girls of Sugar Plum.

GROSS… before walking into this bakery I didn’t think it was possible for a glass display case filled with baked goodness to have a REPULSIVE effect. Barely filled cases with dirty crumbs leftover in their place… Every ounce of me wanted to turn right around at this first impression and run out of there. However, I proved my impressions to be correct by ordering one of the most inedible cupcakes EVER… Cupcake Charlies has no competition in this area!

It pains me to write a bad review for a bakery but, as a self proclaimed cake snob, it’s my duty to be honest & to not only post good reviews but bad ones too.
My mom ordered me a red velvet cake for my birthday last week (my first birthday cake in YEARS!) & the level of disappointment was insurmountable when we tried to eat it.
First of all, the cake was way way overpriced for the size & honestly, if that was Sugar Plum’s version of RED VELVET I shudder to think about how they make other things.
I’m sorry but, my cake was NOT & should never have been called red velvet. The taste was bad & far more dense than it should have been & the color? It was a very dull rust color and not the traditional vibrant RED that a red velvet cake should be. Hence the name RED velvet. The frosting was disgusting, super stiff & left a very icky film in my mouth that made me want to stab my own face.
It was such a huge let down.
When I was back home visiting my family in ’09 I went to Sugar Plum Bakery & bought a few cupcakes & wasn’t thrilled with those either but didn’t want to write them off completely so we decided to try them again. BIG MISTAKE. Never again.
If nothing else, the folks at Sugar Plum should really contemplate reevaluating their recipes & work on their presentation. People pay a lot of money for their products to end up throwing 90% of it away because it’s inedible.
I’m so disappointed & will NEVER go here again.

I’ve had some cupcakes at Sugar Plum when they first opened, and I got a birthday cake for my husband shortly thereafter (a little over two years ago). Some of the cupcakes were very good, others were just okay. On the cake they use a different frosting and I didn’t like it as much.
Last January I stopped back in for cupcakes on my birthday because Cupcake Charlies in Plymouth was closed for the season. I got two cupcakes, and was disappointed. The cake was too dense and dry, the frosting was sickeningly sweet — I couldn’t even finish the second cupcake! I am a girl who loves sweets and will eat frosting straight out of the bowl, but I couldn’t handle the sweetness!
Sugar Plum is okay, and I would nibble on a cake or cupcake from here if someone else bought it. However, for cupcakes I will stick with Cupcake Charlies in Plymouth, and for regular cakes, Sweetcakes in Marshfield.

I went into Sugar Plum Bakery with high hopes since there are not many bakeries in the area. I purchased several cupcakes. It all looked very good. Unfortunately, everything I bought was rather «ok» and not exceptionally good. I found every cupcake to be on the dry side, and exceptionally underwhelming. I am not an accomplished baker by any means but I really think I could have done the same, if not slightly better. I have not gone back since that first visit; maybe it was a bad baking day. Prices are not low enough for me to rush back there to try anything else. Maybe some day…