Paradise Pizza

Pizza great. Customer service not good at all!
My husband and I walked in, no other customers, the girl behind the counter was cleaning the oven for about ten min and didn’t great us, she didn’t acknowledge us, and off course she didn’t take our order. We were standing there waiting. After 10min, my husband asked her if we can order and her response was «can I finish cleaning the oven before I take your order? Is that ok?» No it’s not ok. Someone needs to teach her about customer service. You greet the customer and you take their order, not that hard. Two simple things. That’s all she had to do… it’s sad because the pizza tastes really good and we ended up walking out. Our friends had a worst experience two days prior.

Best pizza in the keys, probably in all of Florida… No contest, hands down. I don’t know them and I’m not affiliated with them… But I AM from NJ and lived in NYC for 15 years… If you like thin crust, NY style pizza, this is the best! You would think you were at Joe’s or John’s in the village… If you prefer thick crust pizza or Chicago style… Then you just don’t have good taste in pizza! ;)

Favorite pizza in key west. Have tried many other places around but this is still my favorite. Wish I could have it more often!

Pizza was good. Mac and cheese with bacon awesome. The service and the ambiance was just downright bad. I wouldn’t bother for a $ 4.50 slice unless you just want a fast food hit to go.

Visited March 2015
My husband & I stopped in after a night of drinking for a quick slice of cheese pizza. The girl behind the counter made t seem like we were bothering her when we came in. The pizza was nothing special but filled me up after a night of drinking.

I had the responsibility of ordering dinner for about 15 sailing crew members and what better than pizza. We basically ordered 2 of everything that was appealing to us and we got exactly that and it was hot and tasty. We did have plenty of left overs that served as lunch the next day!
Would be happy to order from them again!

It’s a crime to give this place even one star! Most disgusting experience. Apparently they are employing the homeless and they don’t realize that people standing waiting for food means they want to pay you. Apparently they don’t care. The man at the counter used his hands to cut our BURNT pizza. When I brought this to the owner’s attention he didnt care! I have NEVER written a review at all. But stopped to take a photo and write this. I’m sorry I didn’t check first before entering this dive.

Service is terrible. I ordered the supreme pizza. The pizza was… Ok and lady was really mean! The pizza was precoked and cold :(

Rude to military visiting the area. Has the worst pizza around. Another service member said a roach in their pizza. This place is unpatriotic because they now won’t deliver to military bases anymore. They made fun of us being military. Don’t eat here!

This place is not a paradise. The girl at the counter was rude and looked so unhappy. They allowed people to cut in line in front of us. They allowed people at the table next to us to have their dogs up by the tables and then didn’t clean it after. And I couldn’t even buy food for myself because they require a $ 10 minimum for card purchases. (Right as she swiped my friends card we begged to cancel the transaction so I could add my slice of pizza to the order to make $ 10– the answer? «$ 10 minimum.» No mercy at all.) Don’t come here.

Wasn’t impressed! The pizza was over cooked to begin with and then when try put it in to reheat it the crust was burnt. I’m not a fan of burnt crust! I did watch a drunk girl drop her whole slice on the floor cheese side down and pick up and eat it. That was pretty entertaining!

I dropped it on the floor and yes I still ate it. But it was slightly over cooked. Thanks for staying open late for my drunk ass.

Amazing pizza! SO glad we stopped here. Light crispy crust with awesome flavors. Just make sure you get pizza that had been recently cooked otherwise it’s a little dry. Great portions and decent price. Great late night food!!!

Now why have I been going to Angelinas for Pizza for the past few years???
NEVER, EVER AGAIN!!!
The owner by the name of James, from Northport L.I., aka NY, knows his pizza. Owned a pizzeria back on L.I. and now has this high volume joint, with big slices worth every single penny for. $ 3.50 is like having pizza in Hoboken, NJ, but Benny Tudinos has nothing on this young man. Quality is the key here, NOT QUANTITY!!! James gives you both here, which is no easy task nowadays. Such a humble owner, and super friendly!!!
Sam & Pam Cohen, will now be your future lifers eating here, every time we come back here to Key West.
You’re the best by far, James!!!
Your number one fans from North Jersey!!!

A hole in the wall type place where you can buy pizza by the slice. Nothing exceptional but not a bad place to run in and get a snack. Good sized pieces — 4 slices, a bottled water, and a soda = $ 18.

I wish I had read some of these reviews before walking into this dump. I had a very similar experience to Katherine K with the rude cashier. I was well aware of the poorly written menu on the wall but was unable to read the chicken-​scratch. When I asked the girl the difference in prices for a simple pepperoni pizza she groaned and pointed at the menu, the menu I had spent 5 minutes trying to decrypt. About that time the delivery driver walked in at which point she began yelling at him for God knows what reason. He maintained composure and eventually HE was the one to answer my question.
The bathrooms were filthy with no paper towels. I watched the cook come out of it and I was disgusted to feel wet doorhandles. By no fault of his own, he probably contaminated some poor schmucks food. The seat cushions aren’t screwed on and I nearly fell through when one side tipped down.
The pizza was pretty decent but that girl should be fired. If she’s a manger or owner, she should find a new line of work.
Pizza earns a solid 4.5 stars but, thanks to that moody girl, they get only one star.

Last night around midnight we were looking for something to eat and went in. The pizza looked legit through the window, so we decided to try it. I don’t think I have ever encountered such a rude cashier in my life. I tried to ask the difference between the sizes and she just gave me a dirty look and pointed at some boxes. I really wanted to walk out at this point but didn’t know what else was open at this hour.
So we are sitting and waiting and hear a bell from the kitchen and a salad pizza box sitting there… Meanwhile the rude cashier is playing on he phone and eating so i walked over there to retrieve my food. The pizza was actually really good, but the service is horrible!!!

I am not sure about the paradise because we ordered for delivery. Although the toppings on the pizza were correct and it had the remnants of a good pie, the coldness overpowered the experience. And of course being a tourist there is no recourse. I recommend if you are beyond a 5 minute scooter ride, dine in. Otherwise pick it up yourself. Good pizza just the typical Key West laid-​back attitude toward business. Pizzas take at most 7 minutes to cook and one can get anywhere in KW in 15 minutes not the hour it took so I stand by my stereotyping the island.

The Pizza here is OK. You can get better in town, but it is very convenient to stop in for a slice here.

Great stop-​in pizza slices! Their mini oven up front brings a pizza sitting there to fresh quality. Big floppy NY-​style slices with a variety of toppings. The BBQ chicken and mushroom lovers (fresh, not canned!) were well enjoyed at the table, while I had the Greek. It had lots of spinach, gobs of feta, and a soft-​inside crispy outside crust.
If you’re walking about at any hour, this is a traditional stop to get you moving again.