Andrews Inn

Our stay was perfect! Location was perfect !
We talked with Lisa before and during our stay. The staff were polite and friendly. Perfect spot right off Duval, but without the crazy noises late night. Hidden and nestled between fruit trees and tropical plants!
Our room was located in the Eyebrow House which is right around the corner from the main cottage. We had a full kitchen, upper deck, hot tub and living room space. They had all the little things you would need to have a perfect stay. Everything was clean and bright and it really felt like home.
PERFECT spot! We will def be back again!

We stayed here last night and found it to be a quiet, charming little place. The proprietors were very friendly and accommodating. The room was clean and quaint. The bed was very comfortable and we slept well. The location to Duval was perfect as well. Will stay here again.

A very nice little hotel with only 6 rooms or so. We stayed in «Paris», equipped with Paris-​themed decorations and all. The hotel is in the back of an alleyway right off Duval, and you can see the Hemingway home from our balcony. They have a happy hour with free wine and beer every day from 4:30 — 5:30 and a complimentary light breakfast. In general the place is very cozy and quiet and the staff are all friendly. Also, they have bike rentals at $ ¹⁰⁄₂₄ hours and free beach gear to borrow (chairs, umbrella, mask and snorkel, fun noodles, etc.). We had a great stay!

This was our second time staying at Andrews Inn. Last year we stayed in the Mango Hideaway and this year we stayed in the Treetop Studio. We enjoyed both cottages, but Treetop had more privacy and a full kitchen. It felt like you were really in an oversized tree house! Andrews Inn has a very relaxed feel and includes all the amenities you could ask for on a Key West getaway. The location is perfect and the staff is the best! Our dogs think so too:)

We had an amazing vacation here before Thanksgiving. Every employee was kind, courteous, and helpful during our stay. The inn is literally next to Hemingway’s home and has its own little group of cats that lounge about. We stayed in the Roma, which had tons of space and a gigantic bed. Everything was clean and orderly and we even had our own little porch to relax on.
It was a bit secluded which was nice for sleeping at night, but also right off Duval street so everything was walking distance. Every morning, we were provided breakfast and every afternoon there was happy hour with complimentary drinks. I believe the inn was fully booked our first couple of days but it definitely didn’t feel crowded at all.
This is the only inn we’ll stay at when visiting Key West in the future. I absolutely love it.

Amazing! Place is super cute and very clean! Very intimate setting, similar to what it must feel like to be a ‘conch!’ Walking distance to everything!

I can’t imagine staying anywhere else on our next visit! Perfect location, good price, no breed restrictions on dogs (we had a hard time with this) with a reasonable pet fee, very friendly staff, and beautiful rooms.
My girlfriend, pup, and I stayed in the Treehouse loft and it was truly awesome. Don’t let the ‘loft’ in the name fool you… It was very spacious on the inside with a slightly smaller full sized kitchen and it was nice having a little porch on the outside to relax and get some sun. I loved the outdoor shower! The jacuzzi was nice, but not necessary IMO. And don’t get me started on the complimentary happy hour every day! Met a lot of really nice folks there. It was the perfect time to grab a drink before heading to dinner or just perusing Duval in general.
The ONLY knock I could give our location (Treehouse Loft), was the lack of parking. We didn’t have any assigned spots, but every time we left, I was able to find one within the view of the room. Maybe I just got lucky. But really, most people who visit probably won’t even have a car. Just rent a bike!
Andrews Inn will be the first place I call next time I’m in Key West.

Overall it’s not a bad place. But, there were rooms for improvement.
We spent 3 days there renting one of their vacation homes — the EyeBrow house i think. The service was good, and the place was very clean. However, the bed was a bit small and the mattress was uncomfortable. They also had tenants upstairs, you could hear them walking around and it got worse at night when you are trying to sleep. Breakfast was on the lower end — very basic. We’ve had better.

This place is on the Duval strip but hidden enough to get restful night of sleep. It seemed like most of the people that were staying this past weekend are repeat customers :) Very friendly staff and so are the cats that were chilling in the premises. The property is also right behind the Hemingway house. We stayed at the Malaga room with queen size bed, sofabed and private patio where you can glance at the Hemingway house. Office is open from 9am-​6pm so try to get there early if not, they will leave the key for you with instructions. Our room is clean and spacious enough. Bathroom has modern amenities. We really enjoyed our stay here and will be coming back.

You will find this place down a dingy alley off Duval St., and as you walk there you think, oh my God, what did we book. But then, you open the gate, and let me say, this is a great place! Pool, breakfast, happy hour. We stayed in the Malaga Room, which had a private patio overlooking the Hemmingway House pool. Lotsa cats which even tho I am not a cat person, was OK. Loud roosters nearby but that’s Key West for you. Jorge the manager was very affable and helpful. We left our phone charging cord at home, but they lent us one which saved the day and we didn’t have to buy one! 6 rooms plus they have I think 2 houses that the renters can come by here for b-​fast and happy hour. Not alot of parking but we didn’t have a problem as we used our rental car sparingly. The room was clean. Lush landscaping around the salt water pool.
Did I mention happy hour? In the pool no less. Stay here!

I’ve been coming to the Andrews Inn for several years now and refuse to stay anywhere else on the island.
Both sites (the main inn and the Eyebrow House) are just steps from Duval Street, which comes in very handy when you are crawling back at 3am from a night out!
Jorge is always a pleasure to deal with and he makes a great butter spread for breakfast… he’s also pretty awesome with NEVER forgetting the complimentary happy hour everyday at the main inn!
Blanche is always on-​the-​spot in case you ever need anything and if you have a few minutes to spare (he can talk!) have him tell one of his funny stories of «back-in-the-day»…hilarious!
I’ve never had a single bad experience at the Andrews Inn but have TONS of great ones!
This is the place to go to get away and relax, but to also be very close to the action on Duval Street. The Hemingway House actually shares the back wall with the main inn and some of multiple-​toed cats will hang out with you at the pool. Pretty cool!
The beds are all comfortable with clean linens and the rooms have pretty thick walls, if you catch my drift. (wink, wink… nudge, nudge…)
Also, the pool is always the right temperature, although you would be hard pressed to do laps in it.
I’m looking forward to my next Key West trip and like I said, there is nowhere else I’d rather stay!

Just got back from vacation and we stayed in the Tree Top Suite at the Eyebrow house at Andrews Inn. I was so impressed with the level of service we received. Our room was everything we had hoped it would be and more. Our staff was so helpful and friendly. Not to mention, free breakfast and happy hour every day! It’s so close to all the major places to go and see!