Slice of NY Pizzeria

FINALLY!!! I’m from PA, and I have finally found a place after 15 years in the Midwest that knows how to make a PROPER *WHITE PIZZA!* HOORAY!!! The owner and his wife were super nice, the garlic knots were tasty and the bf were beyond satisfied with our slices! 2 homeless dudes were clearly regulars hanging out having pizza and water and I thought that whole thing was cool. This place has a ‘fund’ where you can donate to folks who need a meal, and then you can come in and if you are in need, you can get a slice and a drink. I was very very happy here and felt a little bit at home in Southern WI!!!

Delivery took an hour and a half, pizza was cold and soggy, forgot part of my order. Not very impressed.

Single slice is more than enough to satisfy a lunch craving and if you can’t find something to your liking, you’re too picky. This place is perfect for a quick bite at lunch or a late night snack after a drink.

I got a Valpak coupon in the mail. I thought I give them a try only a week after I got the coupon. The coupon had several different items. I tried to order their spaghetti but they didn’t have any even though it was early on a Saturday evening. So I asked for a slice of Lasagna which wasn’t on the coupon but is on their menu. Again they didn’t have it. The coupon offered wings for 49 cents each. Again, not available. Seems like bait and switch tactics to me. I ordered a small
. The good news: it came pretty fast and it was pretty big. The bad news: it wasn’t very good. The crust was very mushy, even for NY style pizza. The sausage was pretty unappealing, too. Small thin slices. of of what might have been sausage.

I eat lunch here about twice a month which I don’t really enjoy but it’s okay. I never really leave satisfied. First the pizza slice don’t get me wrong is pretty big but very thin. Second the 5 $ minimum to use any type of card is really irritating as I don’t like to use cash a lot and I always get either a slice of cheese and soft drink which adds up to $ 4.95 and they still don’t let me use my card or I’ll get a slice of cheese and a water but what’s bad about that is they don’t let you have just a cup for water you have to buy one of their expensive bottled waters that are just some kind you’d find in a grocery store. On the plus sometimes when you eat there they’ll come around with free rolls that they’ll give to all their dine in customers so that’s a plus. All in all the pizza is just okay. Would give a 3 star ranking but the management personnel aren’t always the most helpful or nicest.

Pizza is good, but that’s all I’ll give. The $ 5 minimum for cards is inconvenient if all you want is a single slice. You also have to pay for bottled water, no cups! I really wish they’d change this.
There’s a lot of word around of how the owner is a very bad human being in how he is treats his employees but I have yet to see anything official on it; it’s worrying and I wish they would come out about it.
The pizza is really good and the location is clean, but that’s all they really stand out for.

Worst pizza I have ever tasted. I thought the crust tasted like cardboard and the sauce had no flavor. Only thing that makes it one start is the size of the piece.

Not the greatest. Probably won’t go back. Better deal other places. Prices are okay but never tastes fresh.

As always truly the best. The girls behind the counter are never a disappointment and even the owner making the pizza there to greet and chat with is always a treat … along with the pizza. =) Viewing this and seeing 2 stars and so very sad as it is a location I take each and every family and friend when they come to town.

Best pizza to hit Kenosha since torre ulise left years ago– tiramisu is Devine. Not to be missed

Normally I enjoy coming here. The pizza is pretty good, I love how big the slice is, bit my last visit wasn’t so great. We stopped in a little late, probably a little after 12 am. I ordered 2 slices, one for mw, and one I wanted to bring home to my fiancé. I asked the girls behind the counter if I could pay now and grab it on my way out, they responded by saying «of course!» We ate our pizza, talked and had a good time. By closing time the manager or owner had come out and was telling ppl it was time to leave. I went up to grab my 2^nd slice and the girl gave me instructions on the best way to heat it up at home. After walking out the manager or owner had a different girl chase me down and told me I needed to pay for my pizza. I let the girl know that I had already paid for it when I purchased the slice I ate. She said okay and walked back inside and told the man who seemed very upset. I thought that was so rude. His own employee handed me the pizza and told me how to heat it up! Why wouldn’t he just ask her if I paid for it?!

This place is OK, but manage your expectations. It is better than little Caesar’s except that little Caesar’s is hot all of the time. I like Villa D’Carlo and Infusino’s but everyone is different.

Pizza was good… but…ordered a pizza and garlic knots and a 2 liter of Coke and only got the pizza :(.delivery girl claimed she got a speeding ticket and somehow that is why she didnt have the full order.

OK everyone… if there is one thing I can’t tolerate, it’s an owner of a restaurant that tells its customers «if you think we take too long to deliver your pizza, don’t order»
WHAT!!!
We «WERE» regular customers despite the fact that on average, it takes 1.5hrs to deliver our pizzas. Tonight broke the camels back! Who was responsible? The owner, of all people. This guy doesn’t have an ounce of professionalism or a clue what customer service is.
I explained politely that the average delivery time is 1.5 hrs and we were concerned it would happen again and he’s says «I don’t think so, I should know… I’m the owner». What a Dickle!
As if we have time or the energy to fabricate this crap!
And if you’re reading this «slice of NY», you probably think i don’t know what it’s like to run a restaurant. Well In fact, I ran a pizza shop and I can tell you that we would never tell a customer not to order if he/​she felt the service was lacking.
My wife and I have been very patient over the past year with all the late deliveries and cold pizza.
Don’t bother giving business to this shop!
People like this do not deserve our hard earned money. They need us more than we need them… cause let’s face it, pizza shops are a dime a dozen!
YES, I’M PISSED OFF we gave this Jackhole
over $ 240 of business last year!

*Forgot to give garlic rolls with my order.
*slice of pizza was cold. Put in over for like 1minute
*They don’t give cups of water
*$ 5 minimum
*Girl working (manager) is sooooo rude to staff & customers. Rolling eyes… very short & unfriendly. I’ve been here multiple times and each visit she seems more disgruntled.
* this place has potential but get rid of the bad vibes

The pizza was decent first time I have tried it. I wanted to use a coupon off of their website when I had mentioned the coupon they told me they did not take coupons after 10pm. There is free delivery which is why I have given it three stars. The girl that had taken my order I thought was rather rude. She did not mention the type of payment I could use while ordering delivery and did not even say hello when answering the phone. If you are looking for a place open late I would pick here but do not except to receive nice service from their staff.

The pizza is decent, but TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE. The girl working at the counter was so rude. I probably saw her roll her eyes four times within the span of 10 minutes (not at me but at the people working in the kitchen). She barely spoke a word to me and seemed annoyed that I was even there and seemed even more annoyed to take my order. (I ordered a slice of cheese pizza and a bottle of water.)
It’s also annoying that there is a $ 5 minimum to use a credit card (which is even more annoying when you only want a slice of pizza — the entire reason I went there and a slice of pizza is less than $ 5).
I can get over the credit card minimum, but the girl at the front counter was so rude and SO UNFRIENDLY that it compelled me to want to write this review.

I came here with my girlfriend and a mutual friend of ours around lunch time and I have to say that my buddy and I were mostly unimpressed. My girlfriend seemed to like it, but quite frankly I think she is just happy to have something that isn’t the mediocre thin crust most places in town are pumping out.
Anyways, on to the dirty details:
The pizza looked like it had been sitting out for awhile and looked pretty dry and unappetizing. I figured I’d still give ‘em a shot as we were hungry and looking for something quick.
One of the girls at the counter took our order and the other checked us out. The girl who checked us out couldn’t be bothered to feign a smile and hardly looked up from the register. Oh well, no big deal, we sat down and waited for our food.
The cashier girl eventually brought my girlfriend’s slice out along with mine and at the rate she was moving I wanted to tell her to just stay there and I’ll come to her, but alas she dropped off our slices. Since my buddy’s slice hadn’t come out and the pizza was hot we waited a bit, but he eventually insisted on us going ahead. I started with the garlic knot which hardly tasted of anything but oily bread. Then the pizza, it still looked like it had been sitting out for awhile, all their preparation did to it was add a new sheen of grease. The flavor was pretty underwhelming so I just gave up and covered it in oregano, pepper flakes, and Parmesan.
Finally, as I was finishing up my friend’s slice came despite being ordered at nearly the same time and him having the same slice as my gf’s. Don’t know why it took so long, but hey, at least he could finally eat. He mirrored my thoughts and stated «Not too impressive, I would come again if someone else really wanted me to come with them, but I wouldn’t go out of my way». Honestly, they may be better if you ordered a while pizza fresh, but I haven’t really felt the urge to give it a shot since my first encounter.

Ordered a cheese slice for $ 3, it heated up nice and came with a free garlic knot.
I approve.

I was pretty disappointed in this place. Didn’t feel like going out to get food so decided to try Slice of NY since they delivered and were located near my home. First issue, you couldn’t order a dinner entrée.at 8:45pm.when they are open late on weekends. ok so I guess that was fine, still was able to order a pizza and CHEESY breadsticks. The breadsticks that were delivered to me were NOT cheesy breadsticks although I was charged as such. They were just regular breadsticks, how hard is that? Also the pizza I tried was terrible. Tasted like it had been sitting out all day. Ended up throwing it away as the rest of my family refused to eat it as well.
The delivery took well over an hour. So what I wanted to be a delicious and convenient experience was far from. I know people who enjoy their pizza by the slice but I will never go back here.