The Cotillion Catering Hall

Have been here a few times for different parties/​receptions. The décor is a little to very dated and the staff are a little underwhelming but it seems to be a popular venue nonetheless. I’m guessing that’s because their catering prices must be very reasonable. Plus. they do have a decent-​sized parking lot.
As for the food, it’s decent (not a resounding endorsement, I know). I wouldn’t classify it as high-​end or anything but most items are nicely prepared and pretty filling (buffet).
Last weekend, we were here a reception and a few of tiles on the floor of the large hall on the main level were loose. One tile at the tail end of the buffet line was so bad that when several guests — including me — stepped on it, it would tilt upward and cause you to lose your balance a little. Someone pointed it out to the staff but I don’t think they did or could fix it right then and there.
I did also notice that some of the table covers were a little dirty. Not what you want to see when you’re attending a semi-​formal occasion. I don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect clean/​white linens, especially when it’s for a special occasion.
At the buffet, the only silverware they had out were forks. I know most of the items are easily edible with just a fork but when you have items such as (very) bony goat curry, a knife would help get some of that meat off. I’m sure some folks — especially those with small kids — could have also used a spoon. I’m not trying to nitpick but I found it odd that you can’t at least have the option of multiple utensils.
I wouldn’t rush here for a meal but wouldn’t decline coming for another such gathering in the future.

Very upset with this place. My sister had her mehndi here, we left all of our stuff in the bridal suite and someone opened the door while everyone was gone and stole all of our money! All the cash from my SISTER (BRIDE) that she was using towards her stylist bill. $ 500 GONE. The Mehndi also, was not what we were expecting. Very upset, ruined her whole weekend. The place smelled, was not pleased at all with the food. Would definitely not recommend this place to ANYONE.

Definitely recommend this place if you’re in the area!
Over the years I have been to the cotillion many times, but the last few events the food has been outstanding. Having an Indian background I know how chicken tikka and daal should taste, frankly I haven’t had better Indian food in New York than at cotillion. Can’t wait to come again next time hopefully soon!

Was here recently for a large birthday party in one of the banquet rooms and have only great things to say. The food was excellent — we had a pre-​set menu which offered a nice variety of vegetarian and meat dishes. Some of the best spicy paneer I have ever had! Very friendly and courteous staff. Food was offered up very quickly and plates were continuously being cleared. Though there were several parties going on that evening, I felt we received lots of care and attention. Definitely recommend!

Having been to several events at Cotillion, i knew this was an option for a party i wanted to host last week. After inquiring several out of this world rates from a few venues that were quite astronomical for a simple event I was planning, I thought I’d try my luck with Cotillion. From the first phone call, the respect and importance of customer service was out of this world. Hence, the same day I opted to go in person to see if we could make the event happen there. Upon arrival, I was greeted by the manager, Manoj. Now, I have hosted many parties and events across the Island, but I have to make it clear, by far this has been the best and easiest planning I’ve done in the past 6 years at least.
With the number of people i had, we were told we’d be getting the hall downstairs as not enough guests were met for the bigger hall on the main floor. That was fine as both halls are elegant, spacious, as well as seem to give a good atmosphere. As we discussed the pricing options with Manoj, he asked what our budget was and how best he could accommodate us. In the past, I’ve had people change prices on me during the event, not serve food that was agreed upon, or simply the quality of food/​venue preps have been less than pleasant. This is what sets Cotillion apart from most places on LI, their respect and giving importance to the customer. The prices were not only reasonable, but very fair and offered over 14 food items throughout the event. On top of that, we were told that if the bigger hall is available on the day of the event, as a courtesy our event would be shifted upstairs on the main floor, which it was.
From the time we put the deposit down to the day of the venue, the manager touched base to make sure everything would be perfect and if any changes or ideas we needed to address. This showed their level of integrity and willingness to make our event of about 100+ people as close to perfection as possible. Even, lighting and a beautiful stage with sofas was provided at no charge. How many times is it that at an event of 100+ people, every single person loved every single food option and went for seconds and thirds without any hesitation. All of the food items from the appetizers to dessert, each item was freshly prepared and tasted extraordinary.
The menu was as follows:
Appetizers: Pani Poori, Cauliflower Salt & Pepper, Tawa chicken seekh kabob & Tikka, Veg Samosa, Chili Chicken Dry.
Entrees: Chicken Shahi Korma, Chili Fried Lamb, Paneer Makhni, Bhindi Masala, Chana Masala, Naan Assortment, Green Pea Pillao
Salad/​Dessert: Mango Salad, Macaroni Salad, Chocolate Ice Cream, Malai Kulfi, Gulab Jaman
Drinks: Sodas, Mango Lassi
As you can see, this menu was not a simple menu. Each item was not only delicious but the combination of Asian Fusion and Desi, totally was loved by guests. I have to make one point here, the Pani Puri here has got to be one of the best I’ve ever had outside of South Asia. Their tamarind water was out of this world and without it, the pani puri can be a deal breaker. Overall, the food was great, the service was top notch and the venue was beautifully prepped on time and each staff member went above and beyond to make sure the event was a hit. I for one will definitely be back for future events, as well as recommend this gem to anyone looking to have a party or occasion on the island. My sincerest thanks and gratitude to Manoj and the entire staff here for not only living up to the words as promised, but for the respect and care shown for all those that came.

I love The Cotillion. At the last minute, the place I was going to use for a large
family event, went out of business. I inquired of The Cotillion if they would take me at the last minute, and they were very accommodating. No problem. The food was very good. It is pleasant. Not frilly, not fussy, but just right for my taste. Nice people there. Good service. Very pleased. Will use them again.

Cute place to have a gathering for any kind of party. The Indian food is good, not the best, but decent considering that it’s a reception hall.
Staff are nice, plenty of parking, and clean bathrooms. As long as the party is pumping, the place is a decent establishment to host a celebration of any kind.

Been here many times. never reviewed it… was here this past Saturday for a pre — engagement party known as ROKA or THAKA… desi folks will know what I am talkin about… supposedly it has a downstairs hall also but all the time I have come here which maybe thrice has been to the upstairs hall…
This is a good venue for party of about 250 ppl max. especially if you gonna have a lot of dancing. We were for a punjabi occasion and rocked the dance floor all night. the ceiling here is pretty low about 12 feet max which helps a lot with the effect of the music.
The catering is a standard affair, pretty consistent and good… there is ample parking outside, the ambience is good, and the décor is standard … like most of the Desi party halls around… nothing exceptional…
–1star of a not so good mens restroom, but hey when you have an OPEN BAR at a PUNJABI PARTY!!! what do you expect???