Flying Pie Pizzeria

Pizza lunch special is a good deal. Very dissapointed that they removed the Coca Cola machine for an unknown soda company. Because of that I’ll probably only be ordering to go.

Lemme tell ya… this place has a great thin crust pizza! One of the best I’ve ever had, outside of Me n’ Ed’s in Lakewood, CA. And they are quite generous with the fresh meat toppings. The salad bar is decent, no regrets at all for ordering salads and a pizza between the missus and myself.
In the summertime, the place can get a little stuffy inside, and if you go all out on ordering your toppings, can be a bit spendy (A new Washingtonian term I learned lol)
Other than that, a fine place with amazing pizza and good cold beer/​wine. I just wish these nation-​wide pizza rater/​reviewers from Yahoo! would just stop raving all the time about Serious Pie in Seattle (who are also great) and take a drive across Lake Washington and try this something new.

We were looking forward to trying this place but the tables were not clean so we decided not to eat there. The food might be good but when the place is not clean we didn’t think we wanted to try the food.

For being an «order at the counter» kinda place, I’m giving this 5 stars.
Before I tell you about my experience, I’m going to say that this is based solely off of our experience. I will admit that their old fashioned salad bar kind if creeped me out a bit. I didn’t go loom at it, but the style is a complete turn off for me. (And I’m not that much of a germaphobe).
That being said, the pizza in his place was simply terrific. We stumbled in it while driving through this cute little area and decided we’d give it a try after checking out Unilocal (thank you, Unilocaler peeps). We got a pizza with pepperoni and sausage. I have NEVER gotten a pizza so loaded with toppings in my whole 51 years! I usually prefer sliced sausage to ground, this was ground but had very good flavor.
We only drank sodas, so can’t boast on anything exciting there.
The folks were nice. The place was clean. The atmosphere was a total throw back to hanging at the pizza place in the 80’s. Totally awesome!
I highly recommend you try their pizza at least once!!! If I’m ever back in the area, will be back!

Fun, family friendly atmosphere with some arcade games in the back. They really toss the pizza dough! And we ordered just a simple pepperoni pizza and it was quite delicious.
It was about $ 20 for a 16-​inch pizza.
It did take about 35 minutes until our pizza was ready which was longer than the declared 15 minutes.

Simply unbelievable. A little salad bar was stocked with incredibly fresh ingredients. The homemade ranch dressing is to die for. The pizza was so packed with toppings we both only ate a few pieces. That meant… leftovers! I am not sure how we had never been in Flying Pie before, but we shall be back!

Excellent pizza, so-​so service. I’ve been coming here for many years and the pizza has always been top notch. My ordering experience tonight has soured me to them a bit though… Wife said she wanted FP pizza for dinner tonight. I said I would order and pick up on the way home. I ordered through their online system. That seemed to work just fine. I requested a future pick up time to give me buffer to get there from work. I asked for it to be ready by 5:30. I arrived at 5:35 only to be told that they hadn’t even started making my pizza yet and that I’d have to wait 20 minutes. The clerks seemed very disorganized, and did not make any effort to make up for this mistake/​inconvenience. Overall, disappointed in a favorite local business.

Honestly. Nothing over the top. It was fine pizza but wouldnt go back. Old video games did bring back memories of being a kid and spending time at Godfathers.

Pepperoni pizza on New York thin crust. Very good! Salad bar was fresh and had good options. Breadstick was very good too! They say their ranch is famous and it should be. We did a take out order but it was also be fun to get a table there. Can’t wait to come back.

An average pizza joint. It’s often really crowded, so you know people like it. For the price, I don’t think it’s a stellar pie, but it gets the job done. They have beer on tap and it’s a good local feeling. But if you’re looking for a really high-​quality pizza, this probably isn’t your place. If you want a laid back joint to grab some cheesy slices and share a pitcher of beer with friends, you can accomplish that here in Old Town Issaquah.

Great service. Great food. Highly recommended. Server was so nice, offering me a sample of a new draft beer. A $ 5 sale turned into $ 53, as I decided to bring the wife there for dinner. We both had the large calzone. For $ 14 you get to choose your own ingredients, and you’ll be lucky if you can even eat half of it! (see pic)

Worst place ever — wait an hour for pizza and never get it. Could care less about their customers –awful
Place go to dominos. Other customers who ordered after we’re getting service before. When confronted the employees had absolutely no response. Yes I did lose my cool but shouldn’t have to confront staff about your order after an hour. Wish I would have read the negative reviews here first. The pizza is not worth it and toppings were poor quality cold veggies. Yuck! Oh and my profanity– I said this is fing ridiculous.

Depending on how many people you’re trying to serve, get one pizza less than what you would normally get. This place loads up their pizzas with looottts of the toppings. It’s so loaded that when you pick up your slice of pizza, there is some weight to it (haha). Also, the dough is always soft, and you can easily tell its handmade. It’s a solid pizza place in Issaquah. I always get the supreme pizza, and after a slice and a half, I am ready for a nap.

I came in here for happy hour to get a quick bite to eat with my child. There was no one else in the restaurant other then the 2 employees working.
I ordered the spicy wings and a small pizza. The wings were flavorful but the meat itself was borderline repulsive. It was mushy and gooey and just, not good. I did not have more then one and ended up regretting that one for the next hour. The pizza was ok, not bad but not extraordinary.
Now, I like to support my local businesses but I can’t say nice things about Flying Pie. Mainly because the «service» or whatever you would call it was terrible! Seriously awful and I’m not even talking about myself…
While I was eating, a man, his wife and child came in to pick up their pizza (s). Long story short, someone at flying pie made the mistake of putting hot peppers on their pizza. The man picking up the pizza was really nice about it though, even though it was FLYING PIE’S FAULT! And this guy says sorry about 10 times (I don’t know why he was apologizing, but ya know, people do that) he keeps saying «ya, sorry about that» The employee (s) does not apologize ONCE.
This is where is gets cringe worthy… the (female) employee asks him if he’ll take it with the peppers, (ha, HA!!) I think to myself, wow, OK, go on… The guy kinda laughs which I can only imagine is out of disbelief and says «no». I kid you not, the employee makes the «ugh!» noise right then and there and proceeds to tell him «well, it’s gonna be another 25 minutes» Ooooh, I was soooo mad.
Kudos to this nice man and his wife for keeping their composure in the face of this HORRIBLE customer service. (from the lady with the long brown hair, raspy voice?)

Decided to check this place out on my way by. My friends weren’t hungry so I decided to get something to eat by my self. I had the primo pesto zappi (calzone).
The zappi had chicken, spinach, artichoke hearts, peppers and feta cheese. It was so good.
Next time I visit I am definitely trying one of their pizzas.

Flying Pie Pizzeria is the BEST pizza in the world!
The facilities aren’t the greatest but it’s about the Pizza Pie!
Back in my college days living in the Dorms, some of my Dorm mates took me to Flying Pie in Portland over on SE Stark St.
I’ve never forgotten it.
Whenever I’m in Portland, I try to eat there.
Apparently, someone knows the owner.
Flying Pie could easily become the next Chic Fil A
You won’t be disappointed.
The best 45.00 pizza Pie you’ve ever eaten !!

In a world of sub-​par, strip mall pizzerias, this place is a unique gem.
1. They sell pizza by the slice.
2. Several good micros on tap.
3. Old video games and pinball machines.
4. Crazy stuff hanging from the ceiling.
5. Good prices.
6. Laid back atmosphere.
7. Outdoor seating.
8. The pizza is pretty good – nothing fancy, but it’s tasty.

Ordered from this place for the first time tonight. For 2 12′ pizzas and a dozen wings, bill came to $ 56 I got off the phone and told my husband, «This better be some damn good pizza for 56 bucks» DING DING DING, WE HAVE A WINNER!!! Was worth every penny!
When the pizza’s were delivered, my husband said «feel he weight of these boxes», I took the boxes and it felt like 5 pounds. We opened the boxes and the pizza’s were LOADED with tons of toppings. I ordered x-​thick with extra cheese, pepperoni & mushrooms. IT WAS OVERLOADED WITH TONS OF YUMMY TOPPINGS, THEY DO NOT SKIMP!!! I had 3 pieces and full to the brim. My husband said his Hawaiian was great!
The wings I didn’t like, but my husband loved. They were loaded with Italian seasoning and baked. I didn’t care for the seasoning, I like my wings BBQ and deep fried, so I will pass on the wings next time, but the pizza, HELL YES WE WILL ORDER AGAIN!!!

Pretty awesome place! He salad bar was my favorite part! «Old school» salad bar if that makes any sense. Great ingredients, fresh, and tasty.
We ordered two 12inch pizzas a pepperoni for my son and I and my husband got Chive pizza. Great ingredients! Was really good! My son ate two slices that’s how good it was!
Atmosphere was awesome! Great place for families! I love the vibe in there too! My son is a little loud but it felt like it was ok, a few other kids were running around playing with all the arcade games!
If we’re ever in the area again we will for sure stop by! Great pizza, great salad, just a little pricy for a family of four.

This is an old school hole in the wall Pizza Joint. With the old arcade & pinball décor, this place brought back fond memories of both my college days and growing up. It’s a shame that there are not more of these types of places.
I had the Vegetarian Pizza… LOVED IT. They didn’t fully cook the vegetables (ie tomato’s, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, olives, etc), so you could taste the freshness. Doubt they use organic, but if they did, major kudos.
Lost a couple quarters in the Raiden Arcade as it was jammed and I probably made the jam worst. Salad bar looked kinda boring and they had ultra cheap utensils. Parking was kind of tricky so have fun looking for spaces if you come during peak hours.
Awesome place, will definitely come back again.