Frosty Treat

Had my first Ice Cream Cone of the year with Mr. Wonderful (my grandson) a vanilla twist and it was everything it always is — super fantastic — best place in the area for ice cream!
There was only one person doing the scoopin today so things were a bit slow, but as always the taste and price both fit nicely!
PLEASE NOTE — they do NOT accept credit cards — most likely no checks — so bring some cash!
The only reasons this is not a 5 star for me is because it doesn’t take credit and there are always lines! Of course the lines tell you it’s the spot.

Love love love this place. I married into Buffalo and one of the best benefits is the food. Frosty Treat is a hidden little gem down in Silver Creek that you should try. It has a real old-​style ice cream parlor feel with only window service and a few benches to sit on out front. There are picnic tables and a large grassy area out back to sit and for the kids to run around. Coming from California, the prices here are cheap and the ice cream is first rate. You can get all the standards — cones, cups, sundaes, milkshakes, flurries, and so on, but the real treat are all the custom sundaes. There are dozens of specialty sundaes like the Cookie Monster, Penguins Paradise and Monkey in a Tree. And each one has its own illustration showing what is in the sundae and an architect’s layout of how the sundae is constructed. If I have any complaint it’s that the older sundaes are all hand drawn and the newer ones were done on a computer. That’s a crappy complaint, I know, but the whole place has such a 1950s feel that you almost don’t want to see any piece of modern technology creep in. We’ve been coming for years and some of the workers/​owners have been there since we started coming. It’s a great way to end the day, grab some ice cream and then go watch the sun set over Lake Erie.

Went here for the 1^st time recently while I was on vacation in WNY & loved it. Lines are long, move steadily (not fast, not slow) & the place is a bit pricey BUT you get a HUGE sundae for the money! The Golf –themed sundae was recommended to me, however, I went for the banana split & was quite pleased! Almost didn’t finish it!