The Flying Cupcake Bakery

This place is so amazingly times a million satisfying. First of all– it’s cute. It’s bubbly and there are cute things for sale and jars of cupcake toppers that they’ll let you have one of if you ask nicely. Second of all– the cupcakes are what I dream about whenever I think of cupcakes. I have had a lot of cupcakes and the ones at Flying Cupcake are the only ones I gladly, willingly, wistfully think about and come back to.
My favorite by far is the red velvet Elvis. So delicious and rich and moist and just lovely. I’ve sampled others which have all been good but this one is by far my favorite.
Go here and buy cupcakes.

Doesn’t it in some weird way feel like Indy has kind of arrived now that we have actual places like cupcake shops seemingly on every side of town?
I dunno. It makes me view Indy through a more cultured, sweeter lens.
If you’re as old as I am, you likely remember the days when Indy was, let’s be honest, a fairly boring and bland place. We were a small town with enough people to be a big city. These days, Indy is growing into its improving reputation as an enjoyable place to be.
I think, somehow, The Flying Cupcake Bakery has a pretty sweet spot in the discussion of the little things that are adding up to make Indy a better place to live. The truth is that I have no idea how many Flying Cupcake locations there are now, though I’m aware of this location, Castleton, Mass Avenue, Greenwood and one that either is open or is soon to be open in Fishers that will also have donuts.
I’ve always wondered. Are they called The Flying Cupcake because their donuts fly or because you’re on a sweets high when you eat one?
This location is sort on the fringes of the Butler-​Tarkington neighborhood and within a couple block area that includes a children’s bookstore, a pizza shop, an ice cream parlor and more. As is true for most shops in this older strip center, entrance in a wheelchair is best handled through the rear entry as I believe each of the front entryways in this building have a step or two. The best parking is in back, so it works out anyway. There’s no identified accessible parking for this building, though there’s a couple spots that work naturally. While this strip center gets steady business, a lot of it’s neighborhood business and I’ve never had much problem parking here.
If you have been to The Flying Cupcake, then you have some idea of what to expect. The cupcakes are in the $ 3+ range and go up for «jumbo.» They have lots of different flavors, many with sort of a tongue-​in-​cheek name such as the «Irish Car Bomb,» the Bart Simpson, the «What’s Up, Doc?» and many others. I’d already tried the Ebony & Ivory and this time around opted for the Peanut Butter Blackout. I actually think I liked it more than the Ebony & Ivory.
The décor at this location is consistent with other locations. It looks and feels like a cupcake shop, though I’m not completely sure what that means. The young woman working the counter was taking a phone order when I arrived and one customer was in front of me. From what I gathered, they’d had a morning rush but the selection was still the best I’d seen it from earlier visits to other locations. The service was friendly, though there was an assumption I was taking it to «go» and I’d planned to stay. I ended up taking the cupcake over to nearby Holcomb Gardens for a sweet dessert in a sweet spot.
I don’t get several cupcakes at once because, well, I’m an overweight guy already and eating one is a splurge. That said, The Flying Cupcake is a nice but reasonable splurge. I’ll admit the idea of a $ 3 plus cupcake still feels weird to me and, quite honestly, as good as they are it’s really the flavor variety that sells them. That said, I’ve enjoyed every one I’ve had, the employees are always super friendly and the prices are definitely fair. They do make vegan and gluten free cupcakes, the price does drop by the dozen, and you can actually reserve a small party area at their Carmel location that sounds like a delight.
While I’m not quite ready to fork over that 4^th star, I still think The Flying Cupcake is one of those things that helps make Indy a little more special.

The Red Velvet Elvis would be my last meal before death.
It’s the best treat ever.
Love the flying cupcake!
My only wish – Bring one to the Westside!
(My office is close to the Illinois Street location– but I still wish it was closer…)

These are some serious homemade cupcakes. If you want a giant, fresh, real tasting cupcake then try their strawberry. What do I mean by ‘real’ tasting? I feel like so many bakeries either try to be too different and creative or put more effort into their decorations than they do the flavor of their cupcakes. But not here, you get a well thought out and well rounded bundle of deliciousness.
I’m typically a big fan of frosting! Don’t get me wrong, I wish the frosting here was running through my veins BUT the cake itself stands alone. Together the frosting and cake is bliss.
I could barely finish one of them on my own but I did… because mama didn’t raise no quitter.

I was in Indy for the holidays, but on the opposite side of the city. I made the drive to Broadripple because when a bakery offers gluten free/​vegan cupcakes, you’re going to do anything to get those dang cupcakes. Here I am driving forty minutes away from The Flying Cupcake, and oh man, the drive was worth it. I tried the Salty Dawg, and purchased Cinnamon Toast for later (I still haven’t devoured this one yet, because I’m going to savor this cupcake for as long as I can). The cupcake was fairly moist for gluten free cake, and the buttercream icing was rich and sugary and full of every taste that you wouldn’t normally find in vegan baked goods.
I may have to trek back to Indy sooner than anticipated just so I can get another cupcake. Next time, I’m hoping there will be a few cinnamon rolls to choose from.

My favorite small business in Indianapolis. The one place I can eat in town where my food allergy is not an issue.

The young lady at the counter was incredibly friendly and polite. The store was quaint and whimsical. The cupcakes I had were yum and moist! It was my first time purchasing Flying Cupcake, I live in Atlanta and have my go-​to places there. So I was reliant on online review and suggestions from friends in Indy. Flying Cupcake won my business because they were one of the few open on Sunday and when I called ahead, they were super friendly and helpful on the phone.
I purchased 2 doz cupcakes for an impromptu celebration and they gave me s $ 12 discount! They had quite the assortment of vegan cupcakes which was very impressive and appreciated!

I have been a long time supporter of The Flying Cupcake. Delicious cupcakes, unique flavors, inventive names (Burt Reynolds, anyone?) And it’s a local business. What’s not to love?
I was totally blown away by the customer service this evening though. I visited the Illinois street location today from about 5pm-​6pm with my two year old twins. I can’t recall the name of the girl behind the counter’s name but she was so sweet. She interacted with my kids and was so patient while they decided on a flavor. We ate in and at one point we had a fall off the bench. My daughter was fine, but it was a bit of a fall and it scared her pretty badly. This employee was so sweet trying to help calm my kids down (her sister was crying in empathy). She even brought them over a couple of «dolls» (read: ballerina cupcake toppers) to distract them and calmed them down. I was very appreciative and impressed!

The flying cupcake is by far my favorite cupcake bakery in indianapolis. They have fun flavors, cute décor, and friendly service. Also they don’t over frost their cup cakes!!! They are a must for birthdays and even weddings.

I have never gone wrong with this place. Always great cupcakes!

Their cupcakes are great! They taste AMAZING! The carrot cake one is to die for. Cute shop. Great place to bring your kids into for a special treat. They have a flavor for everyone. Super friendly staff. Make sure you get cupcakes that have been made recently or the frosting can be a little hard.

They really do have the best cupcakes in town… I love, love, love the «Here Comes the Bride», «Pretty in Pink», and «Cinnamon Sugar» flavors. The other cupcakeries just can’t compare (sorry y’all).

I was driving through Indianapolis and Unilocaled «VEGAN» and The Flying Cupcake Bakery popped up. We went to the bakery at 5617 N Illinois Street and it has a really cool flying cupcake statue outside. I assumed they might have one or two vegan varieties but was I SHOCKED when I walked in and they had tray after tray after tray of delicious and unique vegan varieties of cupcakes!!! They were SOO good, I ate two and took one to go. The woman working ended up being vegan (always such a nice surprise to meet a fellow vegan!) and she gave me all her vegan dinner recommendations in Indy. The only downside was they didn’t have coffee so I had walk to the starbucks on the corner (booo) and get gross coffee. However, the delicious cupcakes and knowing I was supporting a local business made up for that though! I will be back here everytime I drive through Indy!!!

I stopped in today to treat mah self and try a Skinny Fat Elvis cupcake. I was pleasantly surprised at how friendly the girl at the counter was today (versus the zombie I encountered previously).
I drove home with my boxed cupcake, eagerly awaiting eating the chocolate/​banana/​peanut butter concoction.
Just a few bites in I realized the «cupcake» was actually a mountain of hard frosting crushing an already thin cupcake… patty (please refer to my photo). This cupcake was entirely inedible, and I’m really surprised and saddened to see The Flying Cupcake cutting corners like this.
I suppose I’ll be seeking out my gluten-​free treats elsewhere from now on.

I loooovveee this bakery! Last August my aunt and I came across this adorable shop and fell in love! Everyone was so nice and very patient and helpful! Yes patient because we had a ton of questions for them so we could pick the perfect cupcake! Haha! They all look amazing so it is a bit overwhelming! This past weekend we had a «wedding BBQ» with the family and my aunt bought 4 dozen cupcakes! They were a HUGE hit! Even with my 79 year old grandma who does not like change at all! She ate and entire cupcake then took two home! I wish you guys were in St. Louis because I would def be a weekly customer! Next time I come to Indy I am for sure making it mandatory to come see you guys! Oh yeah the Burt Reynolds is my favorite! LOVE iT!

Today I walked into my office like every other Monday — coffee already spilled on my shirt, eyes half-​closed, mind running through the day’s to-​do list, already behind schedule before I even opened my email.
Then I stopped.
On my desk sat a perfect little pink box. My heart jumped. It couldn’t be. I couldn’t be starting this Monday with cupcakes on my desk. But I was. Oh. But. I. Was. I opened the lid and two beautiful cupcakes stared back at me — a Red Velvet Elvis and a Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough. I was through the roof at the incredibly thoughtful gift from a truly wonderful person. I’ve been wanting to try the treats from Flying Cupcake for a long time.
So here’s the deal — I wasn’t a huge fan of the ‘cakes. They were a tad on the dry side and were just kind of ordinary. I did like the more moderate use of icing than other cupcake places.
I’d also like to note that these weren’t the choices probably best suited to me — although certainly not the worst. I’m keeping my mind open because I desperately need to try the Homer Simpson Doh! Nut Cupcake. I used to order one similar from Crumbs and it was delightful. Perhaps the Butterbeer, the Blueberry Cream Cheese, and/​or the Bees Knees, too. It’s not over between us, Flying Cupcake. Until next time…

Flying Cupcake, have I told you lately how much I love you? Our love affair started the moment I tasted the Red Velvet Elvis almost four years ago. The delicious red velvet cake mixed with chocolate chips topped with a dallop of cream cheese frosting. It was truly love at first bite. You keep me coming back through the years with so many delicious flavors: Happy Birthday, Bart Simpson, Candy Land, and Cloud 9 to name just a few of my favorites. I mean I could go on and on and on. You even show love to those desiring a vegan or gluten free treat. Oh Flying Cupcake, I love you so. I get excited like a child when I see Petunia delivering your sugary goodness across the city. I love you, Flying Cupcake. Don’t ever change. :-)

I’m from a very small town in Illinois and the flying cupcake was my first fancy gourmet cupcake experience. I have to say, I get the hype now. yeah, gourmet cupcakes can get pricey however if you are living a vegan or gluten free diet then this place is Disney World to your sweet tooth. I grabbed a «its not a hoho remix» cupcake today that is vegan and gluten free and it was to die for. normally I wouldn’t throw down 4 bucks on one cupcake but finding healthier versions of sweet treats is a pain. so thank you Flying Cupcake for going the extra mile for people with restricted diets!

My favorite cupcakes in the city! Red Velvet Elvis and Black Bottom are my FAVS!
The service is mediocre at best. I always feel like the workers there are miserable and hate their job! I do not like that atomsphere. They make me feel like they are going to tell me to «hurry up and buy».
I will keep going there for 1 or 2 cupcake at a time! But I will save my larger orders for a friendlier place that appreciates my biz a little more

I have had cupcakes from various parts of The States and from multiple competitors in the area and I keep coming back to give my money to The Flying Cupcake. Thus far, nobody does a red velvet like a Red Velvet Elvis and what ever is in the bee one.
Even when the staff is zipping around behind the counter filling orders and baking up fresh batches, I never feel like I am a bother. They drop whatever it is they are doing to help the customers at the cases, which a huge A+ in my book.
Thank you, Flying Cupcake, for existing :-)