SweeTies Gourmet Treats

the way my order turned out for my daughter kindergarten graduation. We will most defiantly be back. Their cakes are just the right amount of sweetness without being too sweet.

Hands down, my favorite bakery! Have had probably every cupcake they make, and ordered two birthday cakes on separate occasions that were beautiful AND delicious (red velvet and good ol’ chocolate). Reasonably priced, as well! They have many specialty flavors and combinations, all delightful. Stop by when you’re in the ‘hood…you won’t be sorry!

I love Sweeties cupcakes! My favorites are the Brown Butter Caramel, Caramel Apple, and Birthday Cake. The associates are nice and friendly as well and usually I am in and out the store in no time so pretty quick service.

I ordered gender reveal cupcakes from Sweeties and I could not be happier with my order. I emailed them a few times before placing the order and my emails were always returned promptly. They were open to whatever we wanted the cupcakes to look like, and ultimately we ended up with vanilla cupcakes with vanilla frosting, and pink or blue icing in the middle for the reveal. They turned out so pretty and our entire family had fun biting into them to see what color would be inside. On top of being pretty and fun, they were also delicious! The cake to icing ratio was perfect and the cake was light and moist. Usually I find that cupcake bakeries have a dense cake and really thick icing, but these were perfect. I would definitely recommend them for custom orders.

I LOVE THE Flying Cupcake. After going here, well, I still love FC but now I kinda like this place and would be willing to go again. On a whim, trying to kill time, I stopped here. They have cupcakes, brownies, cookies, and pie and cake. Cupcakes are $ 2.50, but $ 3 if they are filled. I selected the peanut butter and chocolate cupcake. Super cute. Comes with a mini Reese’s on top. The peanut butter frosting was better than most places. However, it was almost entirely filled with frosting. Barely any cake. Now, the frosting wasn’t super sweet so I did eat it all in one sitting but… if you’re not a big fan of frosting don’t get the filled cupcakes. Way too much frosting, not enough cake.

I have been a committed customer and loyal fan of Sweeties for years, however, not honoring gift cards sold by your company because you moved and failed to keep accurate records is a GREAT way to lose business. The cupcakes are yummy, but if this is the way that this company does business, I won’t be returning.
If you do decide to visit, be sure to try the sweet potato flavor. I know, it sounds odd, but it’s the absolute best flavor they have. You won’t regret it.

I like coming in when I’m craving a sweet potato or brown butter cupcake. If you can only choose one, go for the brown butter cupcake!

I made a pit stop here to surprise the wife with a cupcake. She’s a huge fan of another local cupcake bakery, but I was in Broadripple and figured she wouldn’t fight a cupcake, regardless of its origins.
He shop is tiny and they sell quite a few baked goods outside of cupcakes. Brownies, cookies, etc. I selected one of the most chocolate filled concoctions and paid my $ 3 (even, no tax on top of that). I was almost certain what I ordered would be dry and old.
My wife was pleasantly surprised with the cupcake and said it was incredibly moist. I’m not a huge fan of sweets, but I gave it a try to judge it. It was, in fact, the most moist cupcake I’ve ever had. Touché sweeties. You did good.
The only reason I hold back on a 5^th star is the service. It wasn’t bad, but the workers were younger girls and were busy talking to each other and one was on her phone while I was there. The other local shop has a corner on the friendly service market for sure.

Needed a couple thank you gifts for some neighbors so we went to SweeTies to pick out 2 half-​dozen boxes, and of course 2 extra for us to try.
All the cupcakes looked great as did the pies, I was especially tempted by the ½ off day old cookies too (no fear of an «old» cookie here!).
We tried the sweet potato which had a great savory flavor and the key lime pie which was delicious as well.
The cupcakes came out to about $ 30/​dozen, which seems like a competitive price and certainly were worth it. They packaged them into nice sturdy containers as well.
I’ll be back!

We recently used SweeTies as the dessert portion for a fundraiser (one mini-​cupcake per person) We ran out of cupcakes long before I ever got mine, so I had to make a special trip myself to check them out. I love desserts, well starches in general, and was looking forward to checking them out. After reading some of the reviews here I was not sure which way this was going to go. I noticed immediately that the shop will be moving down the street soon, so future visitors might want to check the location before heading there.
The current shop was large and fairly nicely decorated. There were probably ten cupcake choices that afternoon, plus cookies and one cake. I was only there for cupcakes, so I didn’t taste anything else. The cupcakes were large, with a moderate amount of frosting (unlike some shops that pile on frosting as high or higher than the cake itself). The servers were indifferent, not rude, but not super warm, either. I did ask about the Boston cupcake, and one server erroneously told me it was not filled (it was — the second server corrected her). I eventually ordered the sweet potato and the chocolate blackout. The sweet potato is perfectly spiced, cake and icing; there was no question what you were eating. The Blackout was also delicious, chocolate flavor coming through the cake and frosting. I did not find these cakes to be dense, heavy, or in any way inedible. Further, these frostings were both buttercream, and delicious buttercream at that. I wolfed them both down on my way home, and was quite satisfied with the purchase. yes, they are a bit expensive, but if I wanted cheap cupcakes I could buy them at any grocery store, or make my own.
I would happily visit there again when I was in town (I live an hour away), and would recommend them for a fundraiser/​party if cupcakes were needed.

Sweeties in another fierce contender in the ever growing cupcake war invading our city. Sweeties doesn’t just offer a delicious assortment of cupcakes, they also offer cookies, pies, brownies, cake pops, and ice cream. So many delicious treats to fulfill your sweet tooth. My favorite cupcakes are the strawberry lemonade and sweet potato. Both are fairly unique and tasty treats. I enjoy the strawberry filling inside of the strawberry lemonade cupcake. Not only do I enjoy the cupcakes, but their cookies are pretty good. I don’t necessary like how thin they are, but they are delicious non-​the-​less. The toffee by far is my favorite. The caramel brownie with a scoop of ice cream on the side is heavenly. The price for all items is fairly reasonable. They also design custom cakes. You might see their cupcake mobile roaming around the city, which is always a hit! This is one of my go-​to places to pick up treats for parties or just because. My only complaint is how they handle gift cards. They do not have the appropriate system for electronic gift cards, so they have to keep a tally on the back of each card. That makes me nervous.
The owners of Sweeties not only provide sweet treats, but they are incredible active in the community hosting sports camps for local youth. They are also a great supporter of local organizations and businesses. This place is definitely worth a visit!
They are closed on Sundays. Also hours vary per season. Be sure to follow them on Facebook and Instagram. Sometimes they announce happy hours specials, contests, etc.

Tried this place for the first time and I won’t be back. I saw good reviews, but I honestly don’t understand what they are talking about. The milli vanili cupcake was average at best. Somewhat dry and icing was just ok, nothing special. Tried the yellow cake with chocolate icing and again very disappointed. Cake was $ 5.00 for one piece and not worth the price. Walmart and Kroger are just as good and much fresher. I also tried the butter pecan and snickerdoodle cookies. They were pretty good, but overpriced at $ 1.50 per cookie. I’ve had snickerdoodles from Kroger that were just as good and cheaper.
I hate giving bad reviews, but I am giving you my honest opinion.

Normally I feel bad giving a cupcake place a bad review. I don’t really feel that bad with this place. Before I purchased my cupcake, I asked the cashier if the vanilla was made with buttercream frosting. She looked at me like I asked her to describe the theory of relativity. She had no idea. Then she asked someone else who worked there who had to think about it for a while before she finally said, «yes.» So I got my vanilla cupcake with buttercream frosting. My sister got a chocolate cupcake with chocolate frosting.
M cupcake was not made with buttercream frosting!!! If that was buttercream, it was the worst tasting buttercream in the history of man kind! The cupcake was soo heavy. It was by far the heaviest cupcake I’ve ever had. I took about two to three bites but had to stop for fear of throwing up. The rest of the cupcake went in the trash. My sister’s as well. It’s pretty bad if I can’t even finish your cupcake.

I’ll admit it, I’m kind of a cupcake snob. I’ve been burned by quite a few places across this great country of ours. Either the cake is dry and the frosting is great or the cake is moist and the frosting is tasteless and whipped. Thankfully SweeTies hit the mark on both.
I always break off the bottom of the cupcake and try that first because almost any cake can taste good with a bunch of frosting. If it’s dry, I throw it out. Nope. Both cupcakes I ordered were moist and delicious on the cake front. Then on to the frosting, my make or break. Sweet but not overly so. Thankfully it wasn’t whipped, it was dense and tasty. I got the peanut butter cup which had some yummy peanut butter frosting inside and my go to for any cupcake place, a plain vanilla or «Milli Vanilli.» My husband got the blackout and peanut butter cup and loved both of them. We would definitely get these again when we’re in the area!

One of my favorite places for plain olé vanilla cupcake «milli vanilli» yum! If a plain vanilla cupcake fails than nothing else there matters! The cake is super moist and even though the icing tastes like the ones you find on a walmart cupcake, they are my favorite! Lol. Everything else looks delicious, but I never quit need to step outside of my plain vanilla cupcake!

Picked up three cupcakes for my birthday and in support of small-​business Saturday from Sweeties. My sister has been taking about this place for a while. I will say the cake was very moist, even after 2 days. There is a lot of frosting; good just much of it. I enjoyed their apple pie/​spice cupcake the most from the three I selected. I definitely will be back to try to red velvet, as well as other favors. I will be back!

Loved what I tried. The cake was really moist. The frosting was awesome. The strawberry lemonade and the chocolate peanut butter were both pretty darned good. I liked that each of them had fillings in the cupcakes as well. So many cupcake places these days just throw some Duncan Hines mix in and top it w/​a colorful icing. These seemed so lovely and thought out. Decorated nicely; really appealing to the eye and the tummy. Thank you to my friend Faith for the treat!

It was nothing particularly spectacular. A wide selection of common sweets with new names, basically. That’s not to say that it wasn’t delicious, there were certainly some hits, but there were also some misses.
That being said, the sweets were a bit too rich for my tastes. Some of the chocolate-​based sweets were just too sweet too the point where it didn’t taste good. Maybe this place is better served in smaller doses, which is fine because portions were relatively small (though a bit pricey as well).
I can’t say that I’ll ever be back. I can find a better balance of sweets elsewhere
Also, the one employee working at the time was of little help. When asked which of their cupcakes were the top-​sellers, I was told «all of them». Thanks, that narrowed it down to about 20 different cupcake choices.

My boyfriend and I were running errands in B. Ripple and was in the mood for some cupcakes. We were planning to try The Flying Cupcake, but we were at the UPS store and we noticed SweeTies next door. I briefly checked it on Unilocal and saw that they had cupcakes, might as well since we were already there.
We picked out 4 different flavor; red velvet, pinky (strawberry), strawberry lemonade, and chocolate. The cupcakes were a tad bigger than what I’ve had at other places. I had a little bite of every flavor and nothing really wowed me. It wasn’t as moist as I would like. The red velvet frosting was just really weird to me, I was expecting some cream cheese flavor but didn’t really get anything close to that. The Strawberry Lemonade was probably the best ones because it had some filling in the middle which gave it some moistness. For $ 2.50 a cupcake, I’ve definitely had better ones from the grocery store.
I’m not into sweets, unless you count frozen yogurt as sweets, so i’m pretty picky when it comes to desserts. SweeTies does not only sell cupcakes but other sweets like brownies and ice cream. I would have given this place 2 stars but I figure I only tried the cupcakes. Maybe the other sweets are better?

The best cupcake is the Strawberry Lemonade! I dare you to tell me different! For you chocolate lovers, the brownie is ridiculous! Get a glass of milk though, you’ll need it! You won’t want to share any of them.