Stone Soup Inn

Extremely unique! I’d definitely recommend this location if you’ve never stayed at an inn before! This was my first trip there, and I’ll definitely be coming back for future trips.
If you’re accustomed to staying at high-​class hotels, this might not meet your expectations, but if you’re a person who appreciates a nice home with unique details, you ought to try this one.
Breakfast was amazing. We had quiche, fresh fruit, coffee, and orange juice, ready at 8am!
Strangely, we were the only pair staying in a room that night. I’ve looked at this inn in the past and it has always been booked up! We stayed in the Victorian room, which was excellent, and I think we’ll try for the craftsman room next!

This was such a beautiful b&b! Had such a great experience for my first time staying at a bed and breakfast. Definitely recommend this place to anyone! Only reason I won’t give a five stars in water pressure went in and out and breakfast was just ok.

Been here twice and love love this place a lot. Its the only bb I’ve been to and both times me and my wife really enjoyed instead of that other place were they don’t even cook breakfast for u there. I love the loft rooms there nice and comfortiblr. I have only like two complient s I have was that their is only small movie.choices. and the tubs are kind of small but who gives a crap about that. This is a wonderful getaway

It is in a bad part of town, it’s old and weird. I don’t know how else to put it. I am literally bewildered why other reviewers referred to the lofts as either cute or cozy. The rooms are small, dark, and creepy. The furniture is so uncomfortable, like patio furniture.

I admit that the price seemed too good to be true; however, when looking for a place to stay for 5 nights, it seemed quite reasonable. The «lower level entrance» should have been my first clue that it’s actually in the basement of the inn, but I didn’t pick up on that. The inn’s website explains that the Garden Suite «…offers a tranquil seclusion as well as a private bath. A heavenly queen bed, kitchen, desk and bistro table make this a serene escape for business or pleasure.»
There is nothing tranquil about this room. It is directly beneath the kitchen/​dining room, and it’s like staying in your parents’ basement during a family reunion during which no one sleeps in and they all stomp around in the kitchen above you while you are trying to sleep in. Additionally, the stairs to the room are treacherous, at best, and if it’s snowy, you track in all of the rock salt and there’s no door mat to wipe your feet on.
In fairness, the rest of the inn looks lovely, I would definitely not recommend the Garden Suite, however. The location, however, is great!

My first experience at a B&B and I loved it! I would suggest the experience to everyone.
This one in particular has lots of room options, some with shared bathrooms and some with private (all the ones I saw had fantastic, giant tubs just calling out to me for a bubble bath). The rooms were cozy and clean. The house also had several other rooms to explore, full of board games, books, a piano, and photos with lots of history. It was so neat to have those open areas to meet and chat with the other visitors. The social aspect of a B&B is the extra oomph I have been looking for while traveling. Sharing breakfast with perfect strangers at the family dining room table was so fun! It was cool to read through visitors messeges in the guest book in each room too.
The guy running the place was sweet as ever. He served a simple but tasty breakfast on the weekday. Bummed I missed out on the big meal on the weekend.
Everything went just as smooth as ever which made all the difference since we had a wedding to focus on. My only complaint it the lack of parking.

This is a hidden gem located north of downtown. Walking distance to a wonderful treasure trove of restaurants and quaint shops on Mass Ave.
The rooms are elegantly cozy and full of antiques. I loved hanging out on the huge wrap around porch sipping wine from a bottle that I ordered from their sister Inn.
The Villa. I was thrilled to find a Lilly pond stocked with koi fish and surrounded by blooming tulips and a bench for sitting.
My room was very cool as it featured a steam bath. I purchased some aromatherapy oils from their spa located at The Villa and loved using them in the steam shower as it was pretty rainy and chilly weather. This was a special treat for sure!
The next morning my breakfast was pretty impressive considering that I was told that during the week it was continental. I was only expecting coffee, juice and cold cereal but there was yogurt, fresh fruit, bagels and some yummy muffins. Wow!
I will definitely tell my friends about this place. I loved it! Wendy

This place was a total win for me. I was in town for a small conference and the hotel was sold out. This place came up on Trivago, and after a little review, I thought I’d give it a try. The cost was less than the conference hotel, and the experience was so much more!
One of the things I love about staying at local inns/B&B’s is that they can offer more flexibility than your typical hotel. I was able to request my own check-​in time and did so, requesting a time shortly after lunch, a time when most hotels «can”t guarantee.» I was also able to hang around and get some work done in the morning before my meeting with no firm checkout/​the cleaning staff hovering.
The accommodations were great. Warm and homey but not homely. Classy, clean, and tasteful. My room (NW Loft) had a living space, kitchenette stocked with non-​food supplies (which I wasn’t expecting), separate bathroom, and lofted bed. I could have slept all morning as the loft was cozy, dark, and warm. I peaked in some other rooms when I checked in, and they all shared these positive qualities. There are also common areas inside and out, if you were with a group and looking for space to congregate, or read by yourself. The building had rfid entry and rooms were deadbolted. While there are hardwood floors, rugs keep things quiet and my general experience is people at these types of places are respectful.
Tom, the innkeeper, was friendly and conversational during breakfast and check in. Breakfast was continental (during the week) which was great for me and included fresh fruit, cereal, bagels, muffins, granola/​cereal bars, yogurt, and I think I saw boiled eggs. It’s a full breakfast on weekends. There’s an communal area to sit, or you can take it back to your room. There’s also a butler’s pantry with snacks and beverages available.
The location was easy to find, offered convenient parking, and was in a cute neighborhood. I also was able to walk to Mass Ave in about 20 minutes. Also walkable to the downtown area or a easy/​affordable cab ride. The only downside some might see is that there were quite a few stairs.
If I’m back in Indy, I would first check to see if this place is available!

Oh my! Here for a conference. I booked everything late and was struggling to get a place to put my head for around $ 100 a night. Then I came across Stone Soup Inn
I could not have been more happy. I was able to secure a loft and it wad truly delightful. Decent bed for two (I was on my own!) a fridge, oven, microwave, sink, cupboards, great subdued paint and lighting, writing desk, walk thru closet/​passage to own bathroom with very clean toilet, shower, basin and room to spare.
The atmosphere is very old world — charming and homely. Very tastefully decorated in proof correct fashion.
Free snacks and tea/​coffee was another bonus.
The booking people were very thorough and because I was arriving around midnight, were careful to explain how to get my key and how to find my room.
I would love to come back here and sit on the porch in summer!

This must be one of the best little gems in Indianapolis!
The building is lovingly restored to the craftsman/​revival style. The downstairs common area is classy, elegant, yet homey at the same time. I was attracted to this B&B due to their lovely lofts. I dont know why they do not post more pictures of these lofts on their website. They are so cute and cozy! Each is furnished with a full kitchen set up. We stayed in the NE loft. I loved sleeping in the loft «in the sky» (see my pics). The two person Jacuzzi tub was a wonderful bonus.
We also loved the complimentary snacks and refreshments and breakfast. Although the full breakfast is only served on weekends; we met a spread that is way more than the typical «continental» breakfast on Monday morning.
The inn is also on the bus line and only about a half mile from downtown. For about the same price as a typical downtown hotel room, minus the daily parking rate of $ 15 – 25; plus the snacks and breakfast; there is definitely value in staying in a B&B. We would definitely come here again the next time we are in Indi!

Super relaxing spot & about .5 miles away from Mass Ave. which has a ton restaurants, bars, shops, etc.
I stayed in the Blue Room which was perfect for someone flying solo. This room has a steam shower. Nice addition but a lot of steam and so much so I had to crack the shower door open. This is really a minor quibble as the staff was super helpful about recommendations around town.

My boyfriend and I stayed in the SE loft. It was so cozy and quaint. There was free M&M’s, popcorn and pop. The breakfast was really good. I recommend getting the room with the jacuzzi. Well worth the extra money.

I was here a few weeks ago with my boyfriend, and we had *the most amazing* time! Nate, the innkeeper, was so courteous, friendly, and warm. The house itself is charming and adorable. The NW Loft was more than we could have asked for — honestly, I can’t say enough good things! Honestly, we always hated leaving our room when we HAD to go out and meet friends and family! Quiet, close to some great things in Indy, pristine, cosy — we can’t wait to go back! Nate, thanks so much!

What a great experience we had at the Stone Soup Inn. Honestly I just picked this place to stay for a night in Indianapolis because it was the cheapest place that I could find that was close to downtown, what we got was a great experience. The house is beautiful and located in a quiet neighborhood. We got one of the lofts and had tons of space. The room included a full kitchen, a dining table and an area with a couch/​tv. There was tons of common space with free drinks, snacks and things to do laying around everywhere (I probably had more than my fair share of M&Ms). In the morning the breakfast wasn’t anything extraordinary but there was plenty of food and the staff was beyond hospitable. There is nothing to complain about here. Everyone who works there is nice and is available ²⁴⁄₇ for anything you could need. They have a private driveway that you can park on and the price is more than reasonable. I’d recommend this place for everyone who wants to stay somewhere near downtown even if you aren’t looking for a B&B.

A strange location, but a great little addition to the Old Northside.

I’ve stayed here twice, both during large conventions, and had phenomenal experiences both times. The location is beautiful, the service impeccable, and the food delicious. The cheaper rooms are a real deal ($ 85 when I booked), though I hope one day to be able to afford the more luxurious options. The downstairs living room is fantastic for entertaining friends, more like a home than a hotel lobby. The outdoor patio perfect for sitting and reading a book with your morning coffee. I’ve recommended several family members to find an excuse to visit Indianapolis just to stay here.

After a very long, but joyous day, my wife and I came here for our wedding night. Located in the old historic district, this old mansion was perfect for us. We had eaten at St. Elmo right before we got there, and so it was about 8:00 by the time we arrived.
The inn was hidden behind large trees, and had a small parking lot. We walked up to the door, but it was locked. We rang the doorbell. We heard a scurry throughout the house. Eventually the door opened and there stood a quirky woman, somewhat out of breath.
«Hello,» she muttered. «Welcome to the Stone Soup Inn.»
She looked every which way and seemed somewhat nervous.
«Let me show you around.»
So she showed us the inn and told us what we could expect. It was a great, rustic place. It had antiques all around, and the rooms were well decorated. The woman was super nice.
We finally came to our room, the Lilly Room. It has a bay window with a bathroom that has a two person jacuzzi. We had a small refrigerator with complimentary drinks.
The best thing is that we practically had the place to ourselves. That next morning we went down to the dining room. (A room with a small dining room table) and ate breakfast with a man from Canada and a man from France. One man was here for a conference, the other for a wedding. A delightful conversation occurred.
In the bedroom, there is a book at the foot of the bed which allows everyone to write their story. It was great to read everyone’s stories.
The place had a baby grand piano if you would like to play it, and they also have a library with books and DVD’s in it.
It was a wonderful place and a wonderful experience. The perfect wedding night getaway.