Red Line Frozen Yogurt

Nice place to grab some froyo on the southeast side. Lots of flavor & topping choices. Also, they have a loyalty program, which is always nice.

Great flavors to choose from! Very friendly staff. I didn’t like that they do the samples for you. I would have liked to try a few more flavors, but I felt pressured to be done after a couple.

This is a fantastic froyo establishment. Starting with the atmosphere, it’s a lot of fun. It’s got a subway train theme from Chicago, and being from that area it makes me happy.
As far as the actual product goes, they have a great selection of both yogurt and toppings. It’s not limited to yogurt, either. They also have custard and sorbet options. I’m a fan of the Cookies ‘n’ Crème froyo, because what I usually do in other places is start with Vanilla and add Oreos to make it CnC anyway. And actually, I still do that here, just with the CnC base to start.
One cool feature that I haven’t seen anywhere else is a small cardboard piece that you can put in your cup to split your froyo into two halves. Having trouble deciding what you want? Have some of both! I haven’t actually used it because I always get the same thing, but my wife really enjoys being able to split it like that.
The topping selection leaves nothing to be desired. I’m fairly simple when it comes to the toppings, but their selection of the some of the more «out there» toppings is good, too. They have whipped cream, hot fudge, and plenty of fresh fruit if you like to keep it on the healthier side.
I’d highly recommend this place for froyo, as well as the Chicago’s Pizza it’s connected to!

The entire store has a train (rapid transit) theme and I think it’s absolutely adorable. The cash register and the fresh toppings are in an open train car, there is a row of chairs that were supposedly real conductor chairs, and a wall decorated with a city skyline (which I’m assuming is Chicago).
The store is connected to Chicago Pizza so the Chicago train theme makes sense. While I have never tried Chicago Pizza, it would be super convenient to get dinner there and then grab some dessert without even having to go outside.
The froyo itself is pretty decent. There are a good amount of flavors to choose from — 14 different ones, 21 if you include the swirl combos. I didn’t particularly like the vanilla custard but I tried lemonade, mint chocolate, cookies n cream, chocolate obsession, cheesecake, watermelon popsicle (watermelon + tahitian vanilla) and these were all good. There were an average number of the usual toppings; nothing that uniquely stood out.
I would come back if I’m in the area and feeling like a treat.

Super cool inside w/​a Subway car. Kids loved it & think it’s even better than Orange Leaf. Lots of options to choose from. Great job Chicago’s gang.

This is a wonderful frozen yogurt shop to take the kiddos. My daughter loves it! The frozen yogurt flavors and toppings selections are better (and different!!) from the chain yogurt shops. The ambiance though, that’s the cherry on top. The cash registers are placed in a car that looks like it came right off of Chicago’s L. There’s also a subway train track that runs along one wall that the kids love to watch.
I love this place because it’s local, more in-​tune with kids, and is directly connected to Chicago’s Pizza. Great location for a sweet treat!

Tastes great. Great flavors and toppings. Great fun atmosphere inside and out. Clean place. Great service. What more could I want?

This place is super cool on appearance. It has a train car you can sit in and eat your self made concoction. So the staff was great, super helpful and friendly. As my BFF and I conqur one fro yo store at a time we sit back and compare the texture, creaminess and flavor, fake vs legit. I got a cup minus the cookie in the bottom. Cup divider and all… i don’t like seperate flavors touching. I got the orange sorbet on one side and NY cheesecake on the other. My friend got chocolate and I’m not really sure what else, we deteremined that the flavors weren’t true to their nature or to me. My friend thought they had a soapy after taste. I had to agree after I thought about it. It ultimatley turned me off and I ended up throwing away the rest of my fro yo. I did sample the greek yogurt berry verision they had available and it was the best of the 5 flavors we tried. Creamy and no funky after taste. But to many berry blends for me. It’s the cheaper of the recent fro yo explosion around Indy… maybe this is why the after taste? Is there something added in the probiotics that causes this… With the options around work for a fro yo fix… I’ll stick to my favorite. Sorry Redline I wanted to pull in here and love it… but I can’t.

This is by far one of the neatest little shops, of any kind, I have walked into. The owner has put a lot of thought into making this a Shrine of the Red Line of Chicago’s subway fame.
I love the interactive, magnetic Chicago skyline on the wall. The repurposed conductor chairs, hand-​poles and subway station stop maps from the CTA are brilliant. The cashier area is very cool. This place, for some reason, reminds me of the Indy Children’s Museum.
The yogurt is very creamy, with a lot of toppings. I enjoyed the salted caramel pretzel flavor. The service was friendly and the young man who greeted us at the door seemed quite proud of the place.

Great looking place! We swung by here after grabbing some dinner at Chicago’s Pizza. This place has a good atmosphere as its a bit different than other froyo places.
They have plenty of different flavors of yogurt to keep you occupied and full! They have a couple good mixes, like peanut butter cup and moose trax. As far as toppings go… its the normal items. Nothing stuck out as super out of the box. They have a lot of them and they are well organized.
The shop was clean and easy to find your way around. My only minor complaint is the area by the actual machines is a bit cramped when there are people that don’t know what they are doing. Not much room for standing around to figure out what flavors you want.

When you walk in, you feel like you entered a subway station! There is a life size subway car that looks like it is entering the station. You grab toppings from the car and pay. Then there is seating in the front! There is also a really awesome kids play area with a model subway car running and the Chicago skyline that is magnetized (you can build your own buildings). It also has authentic pieces from the Chicago Transit Authority all around the restaurant! This place is awesome!