Puccini’s Smiling Teeth

The calzone was just okay. Filling was limited but the wedge salad was delicious. Our server was very knowledgable and let us know the pizza sauce had cheese in it for my dairy free daughter. The pizza is very good as well.

Mmmm. Best location. Best atmosphere. Best prices. Friendly staff. I was able to sit down and just relax and the waiter took perfect care of us. The vodka pasta is to die for. So creamy and sweet. You definitely get your money’s worth and there are so many options. Your teeth will definitely be smiling ;)

Good pizza, delivers to the boat! Kids loved it, so did the adults. We liked it so much we ate it a second night, we carried out, but it appeared clean and friendly for the few minutes I was in side.

We had a lousy experience at the one off 82^nd street a few weeks back, and after posting an abysmal review on it, the owner of Puccini’s messaged me and offered a gift card to give them another chance. Well I wasn’t going to waste the gift card on the same location and risk another lackluster experience. So we went to the Fall Creek location where we have only been one other time, which was our first time to Puccini’s in general. I am very happy to say it was an awesome choice for dinner last night. Upon arriving at the place, it was packed, as in people circling outside looking for parking. Luckily, we found a spot right away that was right in front of the door. We got inside to find the entire place filled, tables, booths, every seat was taken. While I was a little nervous we would be waiting awhile, especially since there were people already waiting, we were seated in literally less than 10 minutes. The staff was very quick and showed great hustle and bustle, friendly and personable, and as before, the food was just great stuff. The only reason I give 4 stars and not 5 is because we were seated near the door and the airflow came in and made it quite cool every time people came in and left. Maybe if there could be a separate door for the waiting area or something like that, it wouldn’t be as drafty. But other than that one small feat, as expected, we loved our experience here for a 2^nd time in a row. Great service, fast, friendly, good food, and reasonable pricing. Always worth coming here, especially with what appeared to be a family hotspot which really gave it a neighborhood type feel that we liked, not like some big chain restaurant. Kudos to Puccini’s and the owner for being professionals at great service with great product!

Fantastic extensive gluten free menu. We have never had a poor experience with Puccini’s. Excellent pizza topping choices and the pastas are delicious. Outdoor dining is also a treat. This is a must for a gluten free diner based on all of the options available.

You can’t go wrong with any of their pizzas. My favorite is the BBQ Chicken or the Margarita one. Don’t forget the breadsticks though. The only downside is that the wait can be long even for carry out. Especially in the summertime. All the employees are always accommodating and happy to offer up some new dishes if you’re bored with the usual ones.

Food is always extra fresh, moist & tasty:) love this place ! & waitresses are very friendly that’s always a plus

Great local pizza. We’ve dined in at several locations, but this is my favorite. Love the location in the marina. Pizzas are all great, I’m partial to the Veg Head. Tad pricey, but the toppings all taste very fresh. Definitely my fave local pizza.

Excellent marghuerita pizza! Delicious cheesy garlic bread! Salads are usually fresh and the buttermilk herb dressing is wonderful. Young, but friendly staff. Interior could use some updating, but overall an ok atmosphere.

I’ve had better. The breadsticks were pretty good. The cheese will be a bit spicy for some, though. The house salad was very watery, and the fettucini alfredo was tasteless. The lasagna had some kind of oil pooled on the top and did not look appetizing. Probably won’t be returning.

Very good and flavorful sausage and pepperoni pizzas, can’t comment on other items because I always gets pizza’s to go.

I had pasta. I really love shrimp diabolo but this was so spicy that I couldn’t eat it :/​I guess it was my fault– I ordered it spicy, but I normally do like hot food.
That aside, the wine was delicious and the salad was huge. I also had tiramisu and it was delicious. I would go again, especially since everyone else enjoyed their meal.

Good unique pizzas. Love the campfire, twicebaked potato, and sweet little razorback. Chicken torino rocks & spicy shrimp pasta dish. Service is hit and miss. Good local joint.

They have a different type of pizza. Good
Choice if you want a change, a good change.

Yum! This is definitely one of my favorite pizza places in Indy. Their lunch special includes a meat or veggie slice, salad and drink all for under 6.50. The atmosphere is «come as you are», and the food will definitely leave you satisfied. There is a huge selection of pizzas, calzones and pasta (not to mention the garlic bread). My all time favorite would have to be the BBQ chicken pizza… I guarantee you’ll fall in love.