Mr Gyro’s

This place is amazing. I had read the reviews and wanted to check it out. The sad thing is, I have been multiple times, but I am so in love with the grilled chicken sandwich (on flat top grill with mayo, lettuce, tomato and onion) that I have not tried anything else. I admit this is redic, but I honestly crave those sandwiches. Their fries have always been good, too. They recently changed their style. They used to be crinkle cut, but are not standard fries (thicker kind). Awesome value, and fast. I get my sandwich, fries (good sized serving) and a drink for less than $ 7. Mr. Gyro, keep it up! Someday I hope to branch out…

You get what you pay for. Sometimes you get great fresh food, and other times you get blah! I always order the gyro with fries. It’s okay. Sometimes the sauce is like water other times it’s nice and thick. I once got a popcorn shrimp meal for my baby cousin and it tasted like cardboard. Over processed food without any taste. Quite gross!

Great food and best driver thru speak I’ve ever heard! You can’t go wrong with this place when looking for a great tasting gyro or Italian beef sandwich.

Has a bit of everything and the price is great. If you’re a Westsider you have to go!

Great value for money. The gyro meal comes with a generous serving of fries. Great variety of food. Fish. Chicken, pizza puffs. Something for most.
Friendly owners and excellent service.

Unilocal the closest Gyro spot and got Mr Gyro. Best so far. Only one been too just here for the day. Recommend this place to everyone. The have a lot to offer. And dec my price for lots of food!

This place wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t amazing, either. I had the chicken gyro, and while it wasn’t bad, it did have a bit of a tang to it. However, the Greek salad was probably the best salad I’ve ever had, anywhere! You should definitely check it out, though. I can’t eat beef (which is why I had the chicken), but I’ve heard their regular gyro is pretty great.

Gyro Plate dinner special was less than $ 8.00 for a Gyro, Salad & a Drink… can’t beat it. The people taking my order were very friendly and conversational. The place was extremely clean and well kept with the only exception of being out of soap in the bathroom but a busy holiday weekend could explain that. I left full and content so I couldn’t ask for anything more out of Mr Gyro!

Delicious fast food. I hadn’t been here in a few years since I no longer live in the area, but I had a craving and am glad I made the trip back. Food is always fresh and tasty with ample portions. Great burgers, delicious fries (though you’ll need to salt them). A pretty varied menu — I’d recommend going in the first time rather than using the drive-​thru.

Not the best gyro I’ve ever had, but solid. Place is clean and serves above average gyros at a slightly higher then avarage price point. It’s not a place I have to stop at, but rather I place I go to every once in a while. Personally, I prefer King Gyro, for gyros.

Really, could this place be any better?
There’s a drive through, all the fried food your heart desires and delicious gyros! WE only had the gyros and the fried mushrooms but all of it was great and our service was fast and friendly to boot!
Love this place and the people who own/​run it! Westside gem!

The menu is overwhelming, and I felt a little pressured to order since the employees behind the counter were waiting on me to order. I got the traditional gyro dinner — lamb gyro with a small Greek salad. The gyro was a very large portion. I had to eat a lot of lamb out of the gyro before I could pick up the pita bread to eat it. I could only eat half of the gyro because I got full. The Greek salad was okay — iceberg lettuce, three tomato wedges, two Kalamata olives, feta cheese and Greek dressing. Not bad, but not great either.
I would go back to try other menu items and to have the gyro again. Prices are relatively inexpensive, and there is a drive thru.

Great food, low prices, and the owners are fantastic people. I used to eat there once a week minimum, but now I don’t work on that side of town. I still drop by after church every once in a while. The only down side is the location. Move to Avon please!

Finally, I’ve found a good gyro place owned and operated by real greeks! You order by number which makes it easy. The meat is tender and juicy and the pita bread is light, buttery and tastes like it was homemade from scratch that very day. Tomato is very fresh and tzatki sauce is definitly fresh and made the same day as well. Other gyro places in town seem like thier meat is dried out and pita isn’t fresh. I get my usual here, gyro and an order of cheese fries and it’s only abbout $ 7.50. Great prices and good services. It’s not super fast, but that’s because it’s not fast food, it’s greek food made quickly. If we ever move I think I’ll miss this place the most. Don’t let it’s exterior fool you, it’s what’s inside that counts!

Big portions. Great gyro. Seasoned well. Could use one more pita bc they give so much lamb. Had a salad, kinda skimpy but still good. Was lettuce and a few tomatoes and olives. My Lil sis had the fries. Twstes great. Restaurant is simple, almost threadbare. I presume many do takeout.
Lots of options on the menu. Great prices. My dinner was below $ 8.00 and had enough for leftovers. Will definitely return.

Mr. Gyro’s should be renamed to Mr. Good Eats!
I have known about Mr. Gyro’s since it opened up. I forget the exact date, but I can tell you it has been open for at least 10 years in this same location. I decided to go and try Mr. Gyro’s recently, I didn’t know anyone who ate there so I never got any good or bad references about the place, but I do know this about locally-​owned restaurants in general– if they have been open for several years, it’s not because the food is bad, right?
Well Mr. Gyro’s certainly follows this statement– Overall the food in here is very good, freshly made, and an excellent value! How many restaurants have all those qualities these days? Very few indeed.
I’m not real big into gyros, which was the big reason for staying away for so long before trying it out. i was plesantly surprised to find that the menu is quite extensive for being such a small restaurant– anything from cheeseburgers to breakfast items can be ordered here. I’ve had the tenderloin, double cheeseburger, grilled cheese, fries, and hot dogs here– no culinary fireworks at all, just very good quality food. This is a perfect place for lunch if you are in the area.
And the value– I once ordered a ½ pound double cheeseburger, generous portion of fries, and drink– all for around $ 7! Try that at any sit down restaurant, hell, try that at any fast food restaurant– it can’t be done! And the quality of the food was definitely superior to fast food, with only the elite burger joints serving up a better burger than Gyro’s.
I still haven’t tried the gyros there, but I did observe about 10 people and what they were eating and 3 of them had gyro platters, so I take it to mean that the gyros are also pretty good. The décor is well, let’s say, old fast food restaurant style– not very inviting for sure. Don’t let that keep you away, the food makes up for it.
If you are in the area and need quick cheap eats, stop by and grab anything on the menu. This is a great place for people on this side of town.

Quick cheap bite? This is your place. When lamb is on your mind but don’t want to go to a nice, sit down restaurant Mr Gyros has you covered. Their menu is large but its all about the gyro and the fries.
Food: ⁴⁄₅
Location: ³⁄₅
Service: ³⁄₅

I love this place and was eating here once a week for a while until I’d tried almost everything on their menu. The staff is friendly enough. My wife and I returned here after being gone for almost a year and they still recognized us. This is a family owned place and you’ll probably be greeted by mr Gyro, himself or his wife. The only thing that I really shy away from here is the bathrooms, which I can’t remember ever being clean. It’s worth stopping in for sure if you don’t have to make a pit-​stop inside. The gyro dinner or the hummus plate are my favorites

Lots to choose from. We ate inside the restaurant. Had the 2 Chicago Dogs, fries, and drink special. It was good. The hot dogs were Vienna. French fries were hot, good, and fresher than you would find at other places with similar prices.

When I’m really hungry and can’t quite put a finger on what to get I head to Mr. Gyro, cause I know he’s got the solution to my problem.
Mr. Gyro is ran by a Brother/​Sister act that after being a regular for years I know they could give Donnie & Marie a run for their $. They are always zinging each other to the delight of who ever is within ear shot. This place is one of many Jack of all Trades menu Gyro joins that have sprung up in Indy in the last decade or more. They have everything on their menu but the kitchen sink. I can’t speak about much more than the gyro’s because they are so good, and so generous in portion I won’t bother with trying anything else on the menu.
I get a huge Gyro with feta & extra sauce, huge order fries & a pop for around $ 7. That’s excellent value in my book. Plus the fact that the flavors are exactly what their supposed to be it’s a no brainier.
*One last tip, I recommend the drive-​tru or take out. The Dinning Room has all the charm of a county hospital waiting room.
** If it’s after dark don’t risk getting out of your car the neighborhood is that bad!