Grecian Garden

Falafel was awful. Not sure if it had been frozen or the pita it was served in had been. Something had a freezer burn taste. I like crispy falafel. This was soft and mushy. The tomatoes were not ripped but only two little pieces so was able to take them off. Maybe something else there is better but avoid the falafel!

If you enter the city market on an empty stomach, your senses may go a little wild. Every major kind of cuisine is at your disposal and if you are indecisive, you are going to be in trouble. Today, I was starving and needed something quick before I went back to my office. Grecian Garden caught my attention and the second I saw a chicken gyro on their menu, I knew I was at the right place to satisfy my midday cravings.
The staff is very responsive and friendly. If you’re hungry or in a hurry, this place should definitely be at the top of your list. Some of the places in the market take FOREVER to make your order, not this place! only waited about a minute and a half for my food. Not bad considering it’s hot and fresh! My gyro was delicious, hot, and the perfect size for lunch. I’ll definitely be going back to try some of their other menu options.

Solid place to score a gyro in city market and I love their green beans. The avgolemono (chicken lemon) soup needs work. The broth had enough lemon, but it was watery. And something about the chicken just tasted off.

I had the chicken gyro, and as a person that doesn’t eat beef or pork, this was a pleasant surprise! The chicken tasted fresh and organic (like it had come from the farmer’s market :) and the Greek potatoes were tasty and well seasoned. I will def. be back!

Worst falafel I’ve ever had. It was hard as a rock and tasted like it’d been sitting out for days. The tzatziki was tasteless. The lettuce was just iceberg, and the couple slices of tomato weren’t ripe. The only thing decent was the pita and even that wasn’t very good. Never again.

I heart Greek food. I’m spoiled because I am neighbors with Santorini’s. I mean hello, you can’t get better than that. But when I came to lunch with the hubby on his break, I figured I was in the mood and would take a shot at this place. I’ve passed it a hundred times and I should have kept passing!
I ordered the lamb-​beef gyro which was just alright. The tzakiki sauce didn’t taste very unique or Grecian at all to me. She asked if I wanted lettuce and tomatoes. apparently tomatoes mean two small slices. The lamb-​beef wasn’t very flavorful and tasted bland. I also got a side order of Greek potatoes which did not fall apart in your mouth and make you want more! The only thing I liked was the baklava but that set me back $ 2.50. Another shop over sells it for $ 1.35…should have looked around better!
Needless to say for $ 12 it wasn’t satisfying, it wasn’t anything unique or special to my palette and it definitely wasn’t worth $ 12. For that amount I can go to my fav Greek restaurant and ordered the same thing and get the greek potatoes, beans, and rice as part of the gyro for the SAME PRICE and of course take home leftovers.
Too bad. Too sad for me. I’m $ 12 out.

Service is friendly, food is a great quality! This is a great lunch destination. I’m a fan of Mama’s meatloaf, but my mother fell in love with their gyro!

The staff is very nice, and the food is quite good. Good value, too.

Wow — that was about the worst lunch experience I think I’ve had to date here in Indy. I feel like being detailed/​ranting right now, so here we go.
Decided to try a Greek Salad, a safe enough bet? no — not this time.
–asked if it came with pita, he said yes. It came with ¼ of a pita. urgh.
–salad dressing was not the greek I’d expect. It resembled and tasted like Kraft Italian
–feta was weird, not sure if it was cheap or some weird type, but it wasn’t your typical feta.
–I asked for extra olives. he offered to sell me a cup of five olives for $ 1. i said no.
As I’m eating it I accept that it is mediocre at best and am dealing with it, I’m hungry after all. Then something pricks my tongue as I’m eating. I pull it out and it’s a super spikey leaf of some sort, I spit it out and try not to think too much of it. I look down again at the salad I’m picking through and I see this big weed with an unopened flower (dandilion?) on it in my salad — you know, the kind you pull out of your yard with the big spikey leaves. GROSS! I finished my ¼ pita and olive and take it down to return or exchange it.
They look at me like I’m crazy when I walk up and explain my problem and then the lady argues with me. She tell me she gets the salad from the bag — goes in the back to get the big bag of lettute to show me. seriously? i ask her if she would eat the weed and she says yes. come on. All she had to do was admit someone made a mistake and didn’t see it when they were making the salad and move on, but no, she wanted to argue with me.
I ask to exchange the salad for a falafel sandwich since it’s the same price and they give that to me without any stress. yay.
Too bad the falafel is disgusting. It’s greasy, bad texture, bad flavor, probably the worst falafel I’ve ever had — i didn’t even eat it. Just took it off and ate the pita with the lettuce and tomato and will never be back.
To end on a positive note, the pita was good.

Try the falafel, pay the extra dollar to add feta, it’ll make it worth it. I’m not so sure as to the freshness of the actual chunks of falafel but it was pretty tasty. The service was extra friendly and fast and I was surprised by how much food they crammed onto that tiny pita.

Mama’s back, it’s time to Eat !!!

Not a satisfied customer. Eat at Arby’s.