Yogurt Crazy

Neither the yoghurt or the bubble tea is any good here. Frozen yoghurt done self serve and choose from a variety of unhealthy toppings since there’s hardly any fresh fruit to choose from. The frozen yoghurt is chalky and gross. Even worse, the bubble tea which is seriously watered down and poorly made. This place always seems to be empty too. Wonder why… One positive note, they do offer free wifi.

The location is a nice size and has a kid friendly atmousphere.
The frozen yogurt was not as good as other spots in the area. My sister asked for bubble tea, which was clearly advertised on the window, and we were told they did not have any of their flavors.
It’s an okay stop for kids.

Sorry, I used to love this place but. The inconsistent hours drive me crazy. They used to be open until midnight but now it’s 1030. Google even says they are open until midnight! Make up your mind. They even sometimes close earlier. At least be open longer on weekends. Very disappointed.

Visit Date: June 20, 2015
My friends came here after we had dinner at sri thai for their birthday. I thought everyone was going to eat frozen yogurt but it turned out it was only me, my two friends and their son getting fro-​yo. So I momentarily felt like the awkward fat one in my group (truthfully I am the awkward fat one when I hang out with this group because they are tinier than I am).
I had the peanut butter and chocolate yogurt with delicious candy toppings, fudge and whipped cream. The topping were great you can’t go wrong with candy toppings. The yogurt was almost the same as many self serve yogurt places out there it was mostly tasteless and only delicious when you added toppings to it.
Not a terrible fro-​yo place to come to.

Clean place, staff every helpful, yogurt flavors change but always have the basics vanilla, chocolate, tart. Toppings are nice too… love the fresh cut fruit. Definitely try this place!

I think that yogurt crazy is amazing the toppings are good and the favors are good I also love how you can mix the favors you like and make the yogurt your own.

I am obsessed with froyo and love trying new places. So when I moved to Huntington, I was super excited about there being a place other than a Red Mango. Although this place had a lot of toppings, the froyo selection was disappointing. Is there really a need for three types of vanilla? However, the chunks of reeses peanut butter cups were amazingggg as well as the toasted coconut.
We also called 15 minutes before they closed and they said we could come on in… that’s a huge plus.
In you are in need of a froyo fixing and are close by then I recommend. otherwise I recommend 16 Handles or Yogo Delish in Port Jeff.

Painfully painfully painfully overpriced. Like break the bank status. Sure, great selective of flavors that change regularly. A majority of them stay the same, like chocolate, vanilla, cookies and cream, some sorbet type flavor and cake batter. There are a few flavors that rotate in and out. I usually opt for the fat free no sugar added options which have always been good. I rarely use toppings simply because I just don’t know whose hands have been in what. But, if you are a topping person then you will love the options here, they have everything. My Dad and I came in last week, got two cups of yogurt, no toppings and dropped $ 20. That is straight insanity, after my jaw dropped I pulled out my credit card and for about the 30^th time muttered that I will never be back, I know I will be, but YIKES guys lower your prices a bit! I can easily drive to Waldbaums and grab two half gallons for $ 5.

LOVE Yogurt Crazy! I am a huge fan of frozen desserts, and this trend of self serve frozen yogurt joints is right up my alley. I love the variety of flavors, which are generally good. The true magic is with the toppings. Huge selection of fresh fruit, candy, nuts, sprinkles, sauces, fudge and just about anything else you can think of to put on top of yogurt. The place is always clean, and has a nice bathroom and spacious seating area.

About a dozen flavors of yogurt but nothing too far out there. Plenty of sugar free type options for ya dieters or whatever makes you want to eat sugarless fro-​yo. The topping bar here is really where it’s at. Cereals, crushed up candy, sprinkles, nuts, gummy bears, chocolate, peanut butter… the list can go on. You def have to watch out when paying because if you’re like me you probably just loaded $ 8 worth of toppings on top of your Yogurt. Crazy. Overall, Crazy is really no better or worse than any other place in town (I believe there are about 5 different fro-​yo/​ice cream places in town now) but the size of the place, the cleanliness and the topping bar should send you their way.

Fresh toppings, self serve frozen yogurt in Huntington Village.
Staff are nice, place is clean.

I like being able to add an absurd amount of toppings to my little bit if froyo. Unfortunately the cake batter tasted like vanilla to me so that was slightly disappointing.
Tons of topping options and a nice variety of flavor options as well.
I did get a chuckle from the fact that there’s a tip jar at the register. Really?

Delicious flavors, fresh toppings, and great location. I like the fact that you can swirl two adjacent flavors and the workers are always sure to replace the toppings that are running low.

The first time I tried this place, I thought it was great. Great flavors like red velvet (which has never made a subsequent appearance, to my knowledge), rich chocolate and peanut butter. The place seems very clean and is bright. The MINUSes are: (1) They purposely put out Large and XLarge cups — after all, the price is by weight; (2) Upon paying, I noticed a TIP Jar??? I stated to the young cashier «Am I supposed to select my OWN tip from the Tip Jar, since this is self serve???» So confused. LOL. Tip Jar is pretentious and insulting. That said, I will hold my own cup, standing right outside, requesting my own Tips. For what? Yeah, that’s the point.

Wow!!! What a great idea, self serve, GREAT flavors, great toppings, staff is really nice. I have been going about 2 nights every week since they opened and still extremely satisfied, most flavors are non fat, low calories and still taste amazing! Great place for huntington.

I basically traveled here because I heard they had captain crunch as a topping which I feel is awesome. Ever since tastee delite or however u spell it changed to the lite choice it is a huge disappointment. Finally another place that does toppings right. fresh cut strawberries is the way to go.
The place was clean kind of awkward with like 10 tweens hanging out in front of the register but what are ya gonna do?
My only negative comment would be that they have a tip jar out, and my first thought is kinda ballsy to put out a tip jar at a self serve.
I’ll definitely be back its a great place.

Fun atmosphere, seating. Self serve makes it fun-​pile it on! Great flavors and toppings. Def a hot day stop by place.

I heard amazing things about Yogurt Crazy so I decided to check it out for myself.
I walked in and was super exciting. It was exactly like I pictured it! Awesome. I went to a place like this in Vancouver once and talked about how much we needed something like it here forever… and now here it is!
You go in, help yourself to a container, and load it up with deliciousness. There are 12 different yogurt flavors that change regularly and you can take as much or as little as you like of as many or as few different flavors as you like (I had original and peanut butter). After that, you can move on to the 36 different toppings they have out. There’s everything from strawberries and raspberries to cookie dough bits and mini peanut butter cups. There is also a fudge pump at the end of the row. You get to customize your yogurt cup however you like it. Fun AND delicious!
Plus, the whole place is super clean and there is a decent sized seating area in the back.
The prices seem okay; I felt like I took quite a bit of stuff in my cup and the whole thing was under $ 7, which is I think is fair.
I fell in love with Yogurt Crazy immediately and I cannot WAIT to go back. More more more!

love me some yogs. my friends come from all over the island for yogurt crazy. the yogurt itself isn’t as creamy as the tcby that is rotting in the back of the local subway, because its actual real yogurt. it has that fresh ‘real’ taste to it. goes really well with the fruit toppings. unlike the red mango in the area, yc keeps the toppings station clean. mango was a mess when i popped in there. and gotta root for the local business. very happy this place opened up in my part of town.
and gotta disagree with the last guy who wrote a review. this is the only area to find parking in huntington village on a weekend. (i know cause i live on that corner).

****** This is the same review I wrote for the first Yogurt Crazy listing I created *******
A freshly opened frozen yogurt shop just on the outside of Huntington Village. The idea is actually quite simple but really works well in the very nicely appointed yogurt shop. Everything is self serve and there’s a ton of flavors and toppings to choose from. The interior is very clean and fresh looking inside and there’s plenty of room to sit and eat.
The toppings area is loaded with everything you can think of and is constantly being attended to by someone with a food brush to brush away the the mess that the person before you made, nice to see attention to detail like that.
There’s one thing that I’m not a fan of though is the hugely oversize cups that they use, it seems rather wasteful if your only looking for a small portion.
The texture of their yogurt is not a creamy as TCBY or TLC but the abundance of toppings and nicely appointed interior makes up for that. Also parking in this area can be tricky at times.