Shenanigan’s Pub

I heard that Shenanigans has the best pizza in town… at least thats what they boast on their sign. So after years of wondering, my family finally tried it and this is what happened:
We ordered it to go and it took 45 minutes for the order to be ready. The pizza looks decent as you can see in the picture; however, the crust was thick and pretty tough to chew. The toppings were «meh» at best and the whole thing reminded us of frozen pizza. The two pizzas cost $ 31.
It may have been fun to wait if they had a craft beer to help pass the time but they only have a few mass garden variety beers on tap.
Long story short, the other local pizza places don’t have anything to worry about in terms of competition. Unfortunately, I understand why the parking lot is relatively barren here. I’m not sure why I would come back to this place and that’s okay if my husband and I aren’t their target audience.
My/​Our opinion is don’t bother coming here for beer or pizza. There are much better choices in the area.

Great pizza. Would be a shame to see this establishment go under. Always looks like it’s closed because nobody is there. Pizza is top notch. Staff is very friendly and the service is great.

I stopped by Shenanigan’s Pub on the day before St. Patrick’s Day. The woman who helped us was incredible! She was so sweet and personable, I would definitely come back just to see her! She recommended we try her family recipe for Irish Stew, and it was perfect! She only makes it once a year so make sure to stop by next St. Patrick’s Day to give it a try.

Always fun to stop in here when I’m in H.L. The pizza takes a LOOOONG time, so don’t be starving when you arrive. :)
Drinks are relatively cheap, so thats cool.
:)