Yetty’s Pizza & Pasta

Pizza, wings and other typical Italian staples: antipasto, calamari, etc. They have this special (super top secret) sauce called «creamy western». We tried it; it was pretty good.
The portions here are so huge that it is almost ridiculous! Seriously, we were a group of four people and each one of us had enough food left for two more meals. Unfortunately, we had almost a two hour drive home, so we didn’t want take home boxes, and the server told us she felt bad that we were wasting so much food! Well… stop serving such large portions.
In any case, the food was tasty… what you would expect for a pizza place. Pricing was more than reasonable. I’d go again. I would just order half as much food!

It’s just okay here – if you order a sandwich, they just slop it on the plate! A piece of kale or a handful of chips would make the presentation ten times nicer!
Their southwest wings are pretty good, though!

My children arrived in from Las Vegas and we all went to eat out and locally. We chose Yettys. The calzones were very very good. However, I ordered the Long Hots dinner and was disappointed. Not that tasty at all and with hard, bland sausage filling. Service was pleasant and prompt. All in all we had a good time. I just wont order the Long Hots ever again though.

Service is really good. Big menu. Food is excellent but sometimes takes a little while for the kitchen to cook it. Nice bar. Outside tables. Wish they had wifi.
Nice atmosphere — waitresses really good.
Pizza wings and sandwiches are awesome — so are pasta dishes. Chef salad is Giant and well worth the money — comes with garlic bread that is incredible. We go there every couple weeks.

Great upside down pizza, never disappointed with this place. Creamy western wings are always a good purchase as well

Chicken wings are very good if you order extra crispy, hot. Pasta is very good. Have been going for years and I live 3,000 miles away.

We are on vacation and we wanted a pizza so we looked at Unilocal for some reviews on some local pizza places. I’ve got to tell you this place makes the BEST pizza we have ever had. We had a large with meat balls, black olives, extra cheese and they loaded on the cheese. There crust is awesome, thick and no grease on the bottom like with others we’ve had. This place is fabulous!

The only redeeming aspect of my experience at this restaurant was the service. The staff was super friendly and very accommodating. Unfortunately, the food was YUCK. We got an antipasto salad, which was boring, lacking, and looked like it had been thrown together in 30 seconds. We ordered two large pizzas. One was the buffalo chicken, which has blue cheese, and this cheese was SUPER blue. Actually, it was more like green. Way to pungent for pizza. My sister and mother couldn’t even eat it. The other pizza was a regular red sauce, with pepperoni and bacon. Boring, bland, and weird. They put the cheese under the sauce, which made for a really awkward pizza, and the flavor was not right. Overall, not worth it.

Yetty’s used to be my go-​to restaurant a couple years ago, but since then, they’ve gone downhill, and quickly. The garlic bread they bring out with every meal has changed and it no longer good. They slather it with some sort of garlic sauce and barely even toast the bread anymore. They used to be the only restaurant that carried Parmesan Peppercorn dressing (which is my favorite), but they just recently got rid of it (which is just a personal let down to me). And their Chicken and Broccoli Alfredo has gotten pretty bad and I do not recommend it anymore when I used to die for it. It’s a very watery sauce now and their chicken doesn’t taste as good. :(I’ve been going here regularly for the past 7~ years now and am slowly beginning to stop now that they’ve changed everything I used to love about the place.

Awesome pizza. Flavorful and innovative! Family owned = awesome service. And with the delicious sauce you can dig right in without scalding your mouth. If you’re on a date no need to worry about infinite strings of cheese or cheese gobs sliding off the sauce. Don’t miss this Herkimer diamond of a pizza haven!
PS Thank you «Jo!»

A few friends and I ate lunch here and quickly realized that this is a spot the local go. And, the atmosphere makes you feel like a local. We had a woman server who was patient, helpful and very attentive. Service was great. I’d give this place a 3.5 stars: the food is all good and the value is exceptional. Large portions and cheap prices. If you are in town to visit Herkimer College come here and you won’t be disappointed. Blows the fast food chains away.
We started with the antipasta salad, which was enough to feed three growing boys and have some left over. The garlic bread sure isn’t healthy, but damn tasty! We also ordered the Upside Down pizza, which is baked with the sauce on top of the cheese. It doesn’t taste much different than normal pizza, but can be a fun thing to try.
The main courses are inexpensive and flavorful. I had pasta with red sauce. The sauce tastes homemade and has a ton of flavor. The two Herkimer students I was with ordered small sandwiches. They were huge! And, came with homemade bread. Great stuff.

Great pizza by the slice & really great fries. I love that they have deep fried pickle chips (!) on the appetizer menu — I hadn’t had those in more than a decade but only because I’ve not seen them on a menu since then.
The restaurant is clean, I like the entrance and the full bar is definitely inviting. This restaurant has a ‘town favorite’ kind of feel as you look around and notice the worn floors, the digital photo frame, the advertisement placemats and dim lighting with added neon lights and the genuinely friendly servers who will chat with you like old pals while tending thoughtfully to your needs.
I ordered the deep fried pickle chips as an appetizer, which were exactly what I was expecting, and I loved them with the obviously homemade sauce they were served with. For my main meal I ordered the chili burger basket and my lunch date ordered a slice with pepperoni and a pound of wings. I wouldn’t order the chili burger basket again, but I would try every burger they had just to get the ‘fries with that’. They are so good: crispy, crunchy, soft in the middle and golden golden brown. I tried a bite (or 4) of my date’s pizza and loved it for it’s cheezy gooiness, soft firm dough, great pepperoni, extra sauce and delicious garlic flavor. I’m a garlic head though.
I can’t speak for the wings myself, but my date thought they were adequate.
Overall, I will definitely give Yetty’s another try, I look forward to it in fact if for no other reason than the cleanliness, friendly staff and comfy feel.

Good pizza (ask for it burnt) not so hot salads (see my picture). Customer service is not that good.

Ordered the fried clams, they were inedible, all 4 of us in our party tried them and agreed, tough and chewy, couldn’t eat them. Told the waitress, was charged full price for them anyway. Someone else ordered a calzone, it took one hour, everyone else was done eating before it finally arrived. also charged full price for that. Guess they would rather have their couple of bucks than a satisfied repeat customer, because we’ll sure never go back.

Get the creamy western wings. Brian is
a lost soul about pizza