Classificação do local: 5 Port Jefferson Station, NY
I had my husband’s Surprise 50th Birthday Party here on Saturday night. Everything was done perfectly. Great food, great staff, a great place all around. A wonderful time was had by everyone. A big thank you to Mike & staff…
Darrell B.
Classificação do local: 5 Los Angeles, CA
I am amazed by the service. I have traveled all over the United States and this is the best steak I have eaten. The staff is like meeting a an old friend. Stop your search this the best place to eat tonight!
John S.
Classificação do local: 2 Patchogue, NY
The waitress was outstanding a great personality it’s because of her I gave it 2 stars the food had no taste whatsoever matter of fact it came undercooked and I had to sent it back the lemonade had an aftertaste then I ordered a Pepsi and it was flat the potatoes were cold first time last time that’s probably why the place was half full on a Saturday night
Samantha B.
Classificação do local: 1 Hauppauge, NY
My mom came here with a few of her work friends. They had a good experience till the bill came. They didn’t give them an itemized bill so they requested to see the itemized bill so they can see what they are paying for. The bartender came over screaming at them. The manager then came over screaming at them following the bartender. My mom and her work friends both came there twice that day and spent close to $ 300. I don’t understand why someone would treat a customer that way. It very much aggravates me. They are very lucky I was not there. That’s all I have to say. Beware. If you do come here– be prepared for a fight match if you want to see what you are paying for.
Teresa C.
Classificação do local: 4 West Islip, NY
I have been going to Butterfield for years now. I love their food and drinks. I usually go for happy hour. Judy is always a pleasure to talk to and always greets us with a smile.
Mike G.
Classificação do local: 4 Commack, NY
Had the price fix dinner. Pretty good food. Busy night too. Halloween party. They do a nice job here. Nice presentation
Joe G.
Classificação do local: 2 Ronkonkoma, NY
Was there for a b day party/dinner. Server was terrible, food was average at best, overall hospitality was atrocious. Manger made disparaging comments to a woman in our group. First and last time I will be going there
Doug W.
Classificação do local: 4 Patchogue, NY
Stopped in for lunch and had fantastic calamari and one of the best roast beef sandwiches of my life, excited for their great crème brûlée I ordered that as well and was a little let down, not the most attentive service today but still a great spot Went back and had this to say: Very Good. A full meal with a nice bottle of wine runs about 50 bucks a head; that being said I was still very pleased with big portion size and service; The main course, to me, was satisfying and more than acceptable but not as flavorful as expected… still very good. The chicken was very tender and plentiful. I’ve been back a handful of times and I really enjoy their specials from time to time–
Genny S.
Classificação do local: 5 Bethpage, NY
Last night we had 60 plus guests at Butterfield’s for an engagement party. everything about the evening was fantastic! The food was perfectly prepared and everyone was exclaiming about how delicious it was. The staff could not have been more accommodating, even providing special dishes for the little ones and a gluten free meal for one of the guests. We had beer and wine included and they had a ton of different wines and craft beers to choose from along with domestics. Thank you Mike and staff for a wonderful time! We will be back!
Mostafa S.
Classificação do local: 5 Brooklyn, NY
This place is the best place here on long island, i really enjoyed the lunch. i had salmon with green salad and i had to go back for the second time. this place is the way to go for dinner and lunch.
Augusto D.
Classificação do local: 5 Bay Shore, NY
Butterfields has impeccable service and great food. This place is one of my favorite places to eat. Bartenders Diana & Eileen are awesome. This is a great place to go for happy hour, dinner for two, or group of people. I have been here many times for all different occasions and always had a great experience. It’s the perfect place to take customers and colleagues for business lunches. I have tried just about everything on the bar and dinner menu and I have never been disappointed.
Anthony A.
Classificação do local: 5 Saratoga Springs, NY
I have not been there in about 4 years, and it is only 2 miles away. What was I thinking? My wife and I went there for drinks, had dinner and stood there for the band. We got there at 7. I did not get home until 12. The bartenders, Diane and Eileen treated us like we were regulars. According to my wife Diane made the best watermelon martini she ever had. Our waitress Liz could not be more friendly and accommodating to us. Our meal was beyond excellent. Can’t wait until next week until we go back again
Kevin L.
Classificação do local: 5 Smithtown, NY
Butterfields is this area’s best kept secret. They do a great happy hour with half price drinks, the dining and bar menu is great — everything is worth trying. Diana is a true pro bartender, handles crowds well and makes sure you never have an empty glass. Plus she makes a mean cocktail. Eileen holds it down also behind the bar(you can tell where I spend my time). Try to avoid Mondays when the service is a bit slower even though the bar area is typically less crowded — go figure. Overall highly recommended, in large part because of Di.
Desiree S.
Classificação do local: 5 West Islip, NY
Went down for happy hour today. We sat at the bar with Diana. We ordered the ultimate nachos for 4 of us and it was the perfect appetizer to pick on. The serving was huge and it was delicious. Did I mention Diana makes the best cocktails? I have been here a few times before and have not been disappointed with the service or food. The fish is fresh, the bartenders are quick and the beer is cold :)
Veronica M.
Classificação do local: 5 Murrieta, CA
Butterfields is the best. We had my dad’s 50th birthday here. The food was so good, it’s a very beautiful restaurant, and the atmosphere is fun. All of the staff are super friendly. My family will definitely be coming back here for more family get togethers
Lisa M.
Classificação do local: 1 Setauket- East Setauket, NY
Slow lunch service, not many options, overpriced. Not going back
Vanessa P.
Classificação do local: 2 Brentwood, NY
Much older crowd. I think I saw about 4 people under forty in the whole restaurant. The food ok. I ordered penne a la vodka, it was good but the sauce did not taste like a la vodka sauce at all. However, The drinks were very good.
Steven L.
Classificação do local: 4 Deer Park, NY
The food was really good. I got a Caprese salad(fresh mozzarella with tomatoes, prosciutto with a pesto and a balsamic drizzling). For dinner I got the Gorgonzola Grilled Chicken Pasta. The food was very good and the portion size of the pasta was FANTASTIC!(I hate when restaurants give you small portions). The atmosphere was nice and the staff was very friendly. My only complaint was that they rushed us quite a bit. It wasn’t done to be rude, but everything came out so fast and was cleaned up/wrapped up the second they saw us finish. Overall, it was a pleasant experience and I would go back!
Bill C.
Classificação do local: 3 Broomfield, CO
First the positives: goat cheese salad is outstanding. Butterfield burger is without compare. Good atmosphere despite the strip mall look. Now the negatives: slow service. servers don’t write anything down so when you have a large group, they get everything wrong. Poor beer choice if you are into craft beers. Valet parking on the weekends — I think it’s cheesy when your parking lot holds 15 cars and you do valet.
Franco C.
Classificação do local: 3 Oyster Bay, NY
Bar /Restaurant This place has many personas: it caters to a banging lunch crowd from the industrial park during the day, a dinner crowd in the evening and a late night bar crowd, particularly on weekends. This review is mostly for the late night action as I tend not to be over there for lunch or dinner. That being said the food they have is better than the average bar food– the menu is pretty extensive for bar items and it is all tasty and the portions are large. The two bartenders are solid, but can be slow at times. The place can get crazy busy on weekends as they have live music and dancing — it is an older crowd — like north of 35… which gives everyone a place to hang and dance without it being a kid club scene. The owner /manager is always around and stops by to say hi and to be sure everyone is doing well– nice touch. Overall a great place to kick back with a few drinks or mostly to go dance before going to sleep. Parking side and back.