Aiello’s Pizzeria

This place is awesome. Our first visit today, but won’t be our last. We thoroughly enjoyed the Detroit Red Top we ordered. It was amazing. I don’t even have the best words to describe, like no other pizza I have ever tried. Thick, delightful, buttery crust, cheesy and topped with a sweet tasty sauce. Excellent service, and incredible food made with obviously the highest quality ingredients served in a spotless restaurant.

We are regular Aiello’s customers and have been since they opened in Harrison City. The food is consistently excellent. The pizzas, pastas, hoagies, salads and desserts are delicious. The staff is very friendly and the food is always ready for pick up at the time given to be there – and it’s hot! We highly recommend Aiello’s!

From the first time I came here, I have loved all the food I have tried. They make hands down the best chicken salad. Their pizza has been very good every time I have had it. They also didn’t have to but made me a whole Reese Peanut Butter cheesecake that my boyfriend got me for my birthday on very short notice. That’s honestly probably my favorite thing they make and hands down my favorite dessert at any establishment I have been to. They are expensive but its worth it. The inside of the restaurant is super clean. The only complaint I have is eating in as the only time we did, we felt like we were being rushed out and ended up leaving before we were finished due to that even though they weren’t closing for another hour. For take out though, there has never been an issue.

We’ve eaten from them at least a dozen times never a disappointment! Food is always excellent and the staff is always friendly. Keep up the good work.

Over priced and not that good. Very thin pizza. Would not go back again. Menios is way better and is twice the size and is the same price.

Just tried the wings and they were excellent. The «hot» sauce is very unique and one of the best I’ve had since moving here from Buffalo. Now I can say that Aeillos’ does it all. Best Pizza, amazing Italian dinners, awesome subs, and now I can confirm the wings are terrific. Keep up the great work. If you are looking for authentic food made with high quality ingredients, this is the place.

My favorite pizza place hands down. All there products are fresh and the dough is made in house. This day I had there gluten free pizza. The dough was surprisingly good. I don’t need to eat gluten free and would order this pizza again.

Came here for the first time a couple of days ago, what a little gem! Very nice inside, great décor, the employees are very friendly and greeted us when we walked in. We sat at the bar and watched them make the pizzas. Its self serve, you just place your order at the counter and grab your drinks etc and your set. I had the gyro salad and I can honestly say it was one of the best I ever had… It was huge, got two meals out of it. My boyfriend had the Italian hoagie and a slice of pizza… he is STILL talking about it and telling people about it. We personally thought the prices were very fair! Keep up the great work gentleman you have a gold mine here! We will be back often. If you haven’t been there yet make sure you stop in!

This is as good as it gets. If you have not been here you need to put it on your list of places to eat. The specialty pizzas are outstanding. Yes, the cost is more than average pizza, but you get what you pay for. You will not be disappointed. We had the zeus pizza and it was delicious. The pizza crust was nice and crispy and had loads of toppings. You can also buy the pizza by the slice to try a couple different kinds. Don’t pass on the steak and yellow pepper rolls either they are great for eating in or take out. To finish off a great dinner the deserts are in a category of their own, excellent.

Today was my first visit to Aiello’s and I wish I had tried it sooner! My friend and I ordered the The Opus X pizza which has poached pears on it, but they were unable to make it because they were out of poached pears. No problem, the extensive pizza menu made it easy to choose another. I did take off one star because they were unable to make it.
We chose the Montana — garlic ranch sauce, chicken, pancetta, kettle cooked potato chips (yes, chips!) and several cheeses. It was delicious! The crust is perfect, the flavors were great. We also shared a piece of devil’s food cheesecake which was extremely chocolatey and delicious. I look forward to trying many of the other pizzas, or, ALL of them.
They only take cash, which is somewhat inconvenient if you don’t know that ahead of time, but they do have an atm available inside the facility. It is nice and clean and well maintained and there is outdoor seating as well. Keep in mind the pizza is a bit pricey but they are using fresh and higher quality (and cost) ingredients. One 8 cut Montana and one slice of the cheesecake and our bill was $ 33. To me, worth it!

Went there last night for a birthday dinner celebration. Everything was amazing! While we have tried their pizzas, it was the first time I had a dinner entrée. Wow! The portions are extremely generous– could have fed three with my veal dinner– they provide lots of garlic bread, salads were delicious. And since we brought our own wine, the bill was very reasonable! I highly recommend this place– Pete puts his heart into his food and it shows. My only suggestion is to get rid of the plastic utensils but overall, great night.

This pizza is amazing!!! And the salads are too! All of the ingredients are fresh & top of the line Italian specialty store taste. Did I mention the peanut butter cheesecake– best I’ve had! We loved it and will surely be back!

Best pizza I have had in a long time. Décor is fantastic
All food made fresh with great products. You get what you pay for. I look forward to my next visit.

This is by far the BEST pizza around. The sandwiches are great too. Yes a little pricey but you get what you pay for and here you get good quality ingredients and homemade food not frozen processed.

This is the best pizza around hands down. While not cheap the quality and freshness are worth it. Try the Siciliano for a great thick crust that’s not greasy. This is the place to go when you are craving pizza!

Love this place, I saw some complaints about no table service… Get over it, this is the way it is, many pizza places are like this. I like the owners, there very nice to us since we been going there. They do get busy so they can not devote there attention to you…
The food is delicious and it is all made when ordered so you may have to wait, but it’s worth it! It is our favorite Pizza by far!
Thanks to my buddy Italian Tony for recommending it!

I got a pizza to go today. I ordered one of their artisanal pizzas the sopressata. The pizza was beyond good. It was as the Unilocaler above said 5*. I’ve eaten the Squirrel Hill location 100’s of times and it is spot on here. The inside of the place is amazingly decorated. Very very nice atmosphere. They do sell slices like in PGH. The reason I didn’t give a 5 star has nothing to do with the food but what I noticed inside. First off it’s expensive. I always thought a Vinnie Pie was expensive, this place thinks they are a fine dining pizza shop. If you get a xl plain its almost $ 20. The other reason only 4 star, I noticed on their soda dispenser they charge for tap water, they say its purified but I don’t care. Who charges for tap water? This also goes to my above EXPENSIVE. Last thing I agree with the other reviewer if you spend all this money to make the place this nice why not have servers? Your not dealing with Murry Ave. where people just walk in off the street. Last thing who only accepts cash at their prices? Over all I would go back and get another pie.

We drove from Monroeville PA to enjoy there extended menu of items. We walked in to a very pleasant atmosphere, beautiful décor, great aroma. We sat down at a table for four and someone screamed over «when ever your ready come on up and place your order». Hmmm, not going well so far. Went to the counter to order, one pizza for my wife, baked ziti for me and I asked if they could do plain pasta with butter in lieu of sauce… only fettucini noodles, everything else has sauce on it. Hmmmm still not going well. The owner came over to put the order in the computer and had a little hissy fit because the computer wouldn’t respond has be pounded the screen. We told the order taker that our order was for dine in, we then helped ourselves to some soda in «to go» cups, got my wife some water in a plastic bottle and then sat and waited. You will wait a while because the pizza is made to order, the only thing I am guessing that’s made to order. Six people behind the counter and one person doing everything, cooking, calling out peoples names for the orders etc. After about 20 minutes or name was called, went to the counter to pick up our to eat in order, to see my baked ziti in a tin foil to go container with out the lid, that must be the eat in part, same for my son’s pasta with butter and they were kind enough to bring over our pizza. The ziti was dry dry dry, and the pasta with butter sauce was hard like the noodles had not been cooked enough, I was afraid to say anything to the «Pizza Natzi». The Pizza was outstanding and I would give the pizza a 5 star! I just don’t know why they would spend the money on the décor to make people feel like they shouldn’t eat there. Even our dinner salad was placed in a to go container, and given to us after we told them that we never received our salad. We happen to over hear the wife, or the waitress taking with another table about being a third generation mozzarella maker and having fresh basil in the back yard, all true, but you need a new generation on customer service. This area is pretty wealthy and I have a feeling they won’t like the lack of customer service they don’t deliver. Paper plates, plastic forks, knives and plastic cups is not the way to serve dine in customers that pay a premium for there meal. I will be back for the pizza, but it will be «TO GO», I wouldn’t order anything else, I think they make everything in advance and reheat the food. To bad.