Hunter’s Pub and Steakhouse

For starter this place is NOT handicap accessible. They have handicap parking but if you are in a wheel chair you have go into the restaurant from the back kitchen entrance, and forget using the bathroom. The steak and steak sauce was good, and the staff were friendly. They use plastic cups which was strange. and we waited almost 2 hours for our table. The peanut butter pie is NOT peanut butter pie! It’s custard pie with peanut butter and white sugar (I’m guessing) sprinkled on top, but no peanut butter in the pie.

Food is great BUT the owner really needs to invest in a better system for the door. I could hardly enjoy my meal because everyone kept opening the door and freezing my family. It would not take much for him to build a little foyer outside the building to prevent freezing wind from gushing in to the establishment. The lobster tails have gotten a lot smaller than they used to be. I’ve been going to this restaurant for over 10 years. It’s not as good as it used to be. Also, they need to work on the bathroom situation. The one outside is like living in Alaska with an outhouse and the one inside is always occupied. There is a lot of land beside and behind this restaurant. It needs to be revamped, Mark!

Delightful surprise! Order the fried lobster tails, steak entrée and don’t miss the peanut butter pie. Loved the service and the food. Also, the wine selection was surprisingly good (and so cheap!)

Delicious food! Steak tips, lobster tail, and peanut butter pie please. Can’t ask for a better pub just right down the road.

Excellent food and service! Staff is friendly, funny and will make your dining experience a blast. Highly recommend for a time you won’t forget

Great Food! Great Service! This is the definition of a hole in the wall. Very very small dining area. But the food is unbelievable. The ribeye was to die for. I just wish they had homemade ranch dressing. They use pre packages ranch. Other than that, this place is great. Beer and wine only, no whiskey at the bar. Food is The best around. Highly recommend! We drove an hour to eat here.

Probably the best steak place to go to in Columbus area. It is a little drove to get there (middle of no where) but food won’t disappoint you. Try fried lobster tails for appetizer, they are pretty good. If you re not a steak person, you can also get a fish. Staffs were friendly and food was served fast.

I found this place while working in Columbus about 8 yrs ago and fell in love with it! Anytime time I’m on I-​185 passing through I stop in for a filet. Their steaks are as good as any big city upscale steakhouse with very reasonable prices. It’s definitely a hidden gem that I’m thankful I stumbled across! I give it 2 ‘s up!!!

This place is well worth the drive if you’re staying in the area… everything the other Unilocalers state in their reviews is right on. My ribeye was cooked to perfection. The cheese-​bread starter is phenomenal. Service was excellent. Save room for the peanut butter pie.

Pretend it’s your bday. They’ll give you free pie. Try the peanut butter pie. I don’t like anything peanut butter, but this pie is the best pie I’ve ever had!

My husband and I are new to the area and I found this WONDERFUL place online on Unilocal. The food is to DIE FOR, the help wonderful. I am a VERY picky guest. I don’t want to be rushed through my meal. And I wasn’t! From drinks to appetiser, to meal, to dessert, it was a pleasure to dine here! Even the divey ambiance was great!

A real Gem. Thanks to good friends for taking us to dinner. Steaks were cooked perfectly and nicely seasoned, fried lobster tails delicious, and a bottle of Stags Leap made for a top notch dinner in a low key environment. We’ll be back.

The food was amazing!!! Country fried steak was so good! Service was great. Nice local restaurant/​bar. Peanut butter pie was delicious

Ok me and three co-​workers went here last Thursday for a work dinner.
I don’t eat steak but I agreed to go anyway.
If you don’t eat steak you have few options; a fish option that changes (red snapper the night I was there) and grilled chicken breast. I think that’s pretty much it.
Of course all my co-​workers ordered steaks while I went with the chicken.
I can’t personally speak to the steaks but I can tell you there was nothing left on anyone’s plate so maybe that’s all that needs to be said. With each meal you get two sides to pick from as well. I can honestly say that for a basic grilled chicken breast it was probably the best I’ve ever had. The grits were good maybe a little heavy and the salad was nothing special.
For dessert apparently you MUST get the peanut butter pie. All mu co-​workers did but I went with the key lime pie. I believe both are homemade.
The place is in the middle of nowhere. On a Thursday evening the lot was full and cars were parked up and down the street. In other words the place was packed. But we only waited maybe 20 minutes to get a table; not too bad
This place isn’t inexpensive but not unreasonable either.
If you can find it, this place is worth a visit especially if you like steak. Or even chicken.

This is a hidden gem. A perfectly cooked steak. Don’t be fooled by the «austere» look of the place. After all… it is a hunters pub, so it is probably a great place to stop when returning from a good hunt in the Georgia woods. Place was extremely packed, but the service was spot on. Very happy and will make this a stop when back in town. The peanut butter pie was amazing! I am going to have to do some extra exercises tomorrow!

The Hunters Pub is awesome! First off let me say there are no neon signs & if you come out here at night you will not find this place due to the woodland camo paint job. This is a local favorite & is always packed so be prepared to wait. I always get the 12oz filet & it never disappoints.

Great steak. Great service. Get over the price and the plasticware… it matches the ambiance and the food makes it worth it. You’re going to a «hunters pub» and you should expect that ambiance.
Ribeye was cooked great and tasted great. Mashed potatoes were great. Peanut butter pie was awesome. We got the fried lobster tails to start and they (and the salad) were the only part of the meal that was just ok.
Worth the drive.

Great place to eat. Friendly staff and comfortable atmosphere. We enjoyed the ribeye, filet, sweet potato fries and loaded baked potato. All was great! BUT, whatever you do, don’t leave there until you try the peanut butter pie! Oh my gosh! It’s the best ever!

I’m going all-​out (in terms of stars) in my review for this hidden gem of a spot. Certainly an unexpected find (came to me via a recommendation from a good friend) and so glad I took his advice and got off the highway traveling between Columbus and LaGrange.
This roadside dinner place is about the size of someone’s house, but don’t let the outside fool you… they are grilling up some righteous steak here! Cooked to perfection and accompanied by a large salad and a potato, this meal hit the spot. Steak were cooked to the exact temps we all ordered, and the sides and salad were quite tasty as well.
Prices are reasonable and the staff is as friendly as they come. The place was completely packed by the time we got up from our (early) dinner table. Don’t pass this spot up, you’ll be sorry you did!

Nice service but it’s over-​priced and crowded. I’ve been twice. The first time I had the marinated grilled chicken breast ($ 12) and asparagus. It was good enough to make me return. The second trip was on a Friday night, we were warned about the crowds but thought, how long can it take? It took about thirty minutes for us to get a table and at least an hour for our food to arrive. I ordered the steak tips. The iceberg salad was small and forgettable. Worse yet, the server made it without gloves. Taking money and then adding tiny tomatoes to my salad with bare hands is a little scary. The bread was delicious but the sweet potato fries weren’t anything to write home about. The steak tips were disappointing. There was a lot of meat, it was cut thick and it got cold and chewy fast. It’s also smothered in overcooked mushrooms and onions (I had mine without onions). Even adding the sauce, it wasn’t good.
I’m not sure why anyone would rate this place five stars. They do have nice servers. I left my purse and no-​one went through it or anything. The jukebox is cool. They fill it with money on Friday evenings so you don’t have to pay. And I appreciate the semi-​late hours. But the seating is uncomfortable, the atmosphere is noisy and the food only warrants three stars. Being generous, I’d give four stars for the chicken breast and two for the steak tips. I won’t return.