Terranova Trattoria

Possibly the worst pizza I have ever eaten
There is not a lot for me to say about this place, but if you’ve been here once you’ve been here enough. This pizza sucks ass, I really can’t put it any other way. I ordered two Sicilian slices, and it was very foolish of me. The cheese tasted like it was scrubbed off the tiles of the floor, and it was just a piece of bread topped with cheese.
I’m never coming back or giving this place another chance.
If you want better tasting pizza, you have a better bet going to ⁷⁄₁₁ which is right around the corner.
Stay away from this garbage

Nothing much needs to be said, just really good pizza, plain and simple! There is nothing not to like. Certainly, ranks top of my list of local greats when it comes to a good pie!

Phenomenal food! Come here for pizza always. Stopped in for lunch today. Italian sausage sub and cold Italian hero were awesome. Large serving sizes and fast. Dinner menu is large and tasty. BYOB. If you’re in the area it’s a must-​stop for something to eat.

You might notice a common theme with most of my pizza reviews… so many of them revolve around getting one or both of my kids to some kind of sport practice or tournament. Well this one isn’t any different.
We were out in Hackettstown to do some field cleanup for a tournament my daughter’s team was going to host and I was in dire need of some lunch. On the way I found this little pizza joint. I was greeted immediately by the friendly guy behind the counter and ordered two slices to go… a sausage slice and a Sicilian slice. While it was warming up, I checked out the bathrooms-​very clean… as was the rest of the place.
The slices themselves were good, but I wouldn’t say great. The sausage slice was tasty, but the flavor of the sauce was a little different than I normally like… don’t know if it was a little sweet or it was just the spices, but it was just ‘different’. Someone else might love it. Crust was also thicker than I like. Again, the slice wasn’t bad and I’m sure some of you will love it and say I’m nuts, but it didn’t do it for me. The Sicilian slice was better, but not as crispy as I like. Taste was good (same issue with the sauce) but the cheese part of the slice was more well done than the sausage slice… and how I like my pizza.
I’d probably give Terranova 3 ½ stars if I could, but this wasn’t quite a four-​star visit. I’ll tell ya what, I don’t come out here very often, but when I do I’ll stop by Terranova’s again to give them another shot. Stay hungry my friend…